Worst Umpiring Decision in the History of Football

[ShockOfHair]

Has anyone mentioned that free against Leo Barry in the 2005 QF?

[Big Al]

Re: Worst Umpiring Decision in the History of Football

Has anyone mentioned that free against Leo Barry in the 2005 QF?

Not that I'm aware.

The Stenglein one has been mentioned though.

[Triple B]

"Polly, don't mention the war, I mentioned it once, but I think I got away with it"

[ShockOfHair]

Come on look on the bright side, if we had won that qualifying final we would have faced Adelaide in the prelim and given our track record against them at the time, we could have easily lots that game. No Grand Final. No Flag.

But if we didn't win the 2005 flag, our ruckman would have had a less jolly time over Christmas and would have been a matchwinner in the '06 final.

[Nico]

Come on look on the bright side, if we had won that qualifying final we would have faced Adelaide in the prelim and given our track record against them at the time, we could have easily lots that game. No Grand Final. No Flag.

I seem to remember that was said in 2012.

[PerthSwannie]

OK. That game at Subi. 2005 QF. I was there and I`ve gotta say I was @@@@@ing pissed off. I was seated on the left forward pocket(as in the Swans last qrt). I didn`t see the Leo/Stenglein one but the ultimate in outrageous umpiring was when Goodesy got legged right in front of me by Wirra. NO free, then a second later Bolts gets done for a high.
I was totally livid with anger. I was surrounded by Wet Toasters and I must say, they looked a bit sheepish because they new it was a free for Goodes. Plus listen to those bastard commentators. They say something like (Fair call) Give me a @@@@ing break!!!

I found this clip. Must say I`ve never watched that game again so this was the first time I`d seen it since. Very exciting. Clip starts with about 8mins to go in the game.

The crucial part is at 7.45.

https://<iframe width="640" height="...reen></iframe>

[jono2707]

Good to see the anger levels are getting back to our normal pre-2012-premiership - cant be resting on our laurels for too long can we

[Vonsteinman]

OK. That game at Subi. 2005 QF. I was there and I`ve gotta say I was @@@@@ing pissed off. I was seated on the left forward pocket(as in the Swans last qrt). I didn`t see the Leo/Stenglein one but the ultimate in outrageous umpiring was when Goodesy got legged right in front of me by Wirra. NO free, then a second later Bolts gets done for a high.
I was totally livid with anger. I was surrounded by Wet Toasters and I must say, they looked a bit sheepish because they new it was a free for Goodes. Plus listen to those bastard commentators. They say something like (Fair call) Give me a @@@@ing break!!!

It's funny what you remember isn't it? Today is the first time I've watched any footage from that game. I still have the brand spanking new DVD in the box set. I must admit I didn't immediately recall the Stenglein incident - must have blocked it out - but this trip on Goodesy still drifts into my mind in idle moments and makes the blood start to boil.

To make me feel better this afternoon, I watched the highlights of the 2006 QF, as I had ventured to Subi for that game. We were in with all a couple of hundred Swans fans on the upper deck and copped it all night from the surrounding fans, particularly when Barry Hall marked on the 50 in the pocket in front of us (from about 5:08 on this clip). The booing was seriously deafening. He walked back and calmly slotted it. I had never seen Swans fans react in the way we did. It sounds quiet on the audio but it certainly wasn't in the stand. And then when Mick kicked the sealer an hour later..... I will simply never forget it.

West Coast Eagles v Sydney Swans - 2006 Qualifying Final Highlights - AFL - YouTube

[PerthSwannie]

Yeeeeeehhhhh;Vonsteinman. I was there at that one to. I was up in the nose bleed section. When Baz was kicking for that goal he was probably looking straight at me. Man, I had this screaming banshee of a wet toast woman beside me who was giving me the @@@@s all night but at the end I just looked at her and said YeeeeEEEEEEEYYYYYYYY. Pissed off she was. HaHAHa.

[ScottH]

It's funny what you remember isn't it? Today is the first time I've watched any footage from that game. I still have the brand spanking new DVD in the box set. I must admit I didn't immediately recall the Stenglein incident - must have blocked it out - but this trip on Goodesy still drifts into my mind in idle moments and makes the blood start to boil.

To make me feel better this afternoon, I watched the highlights of the 2006 QF, as I had ventured to Subi for that game. We were in with all a couple of hundred Swans fans on the upper deck and copped it all night from the surrounding fans, particularly when Barry Hall marked on the 50 in the pocket in front of us (from about 5:08 on this clip). The booing was seriously deafening. He walked back and calmly slotted it. I had never seen Swans fans react in the way we did. It sounds quiet on the audio but it certainly wasn't in the stand. And then when Mick kicked the sealer an hour later..... I will simply never forget it.

West Coast Eagles v Sydney Swans - 2006 Qualifying Final Highlights - AFL - YouTube

9:55 onwards. One of the best passages of play under that sort of pressure. Play with BALLS!!

[mcs]

9:55 onwards. One of the best passages of play under that sort of pressure. Play with BALLS!!

Unbelievable piece of play with one of the most memorable finishes to it in history!

[Doctor]

I'd forgotten the Stenglein one until I saw that clip again and all the memories, bile and outrage came flooding back. What a shocking decision! Plus I had to look at clips of Hunter again. Good to know I can still be furious about an injustice against our team from 7 years ago.

[Triple B]

West Coast Eagles v Sydney Swans - 2006 Qualifying Final Highlights - AFL - YouTube

Massive LOL @ 4:15.

Somebody has doctored the clip and it cuts away. You'll need to pause it at the right moment, it only lasts a millisecond, but it's hilarious.....

[Triple B]

Looks like I went off a bit early (no need to comment Al) and there is a few edits at different times. Shame, I preferred the subtle 'blink and you miss it' type humour...

[Swansongster]

9:55 onwards. One of the best passages of play under that sort of pressure. Play with BALLS!!

Reminds me of Reid's goal in last year's grand final. Admittedly one largely by hand and the other largely by foot but both A1 rebound plays.