Paul Roos commentating our games

[Triple B]

I would like to see a Swans only commentary similar to the one Eddie and Tony Shaw did for the Pies the other week. I started watching that game with the standard commentary then switched to the Collingwood one thinking I'd last about 30 seconds, to the contrary I watched it for the whole game. It was fun and very funny at times and I think the ex Swans now working at Foxtel could do a similar thing.

I would have loved to tune into a 'Press Red for Ed' commentary a fortnight ago when we pumped them, it would have been gold listening to the tears...

On subject, I'm not a fan of Roos' constant Swans references and absolutely see how they alienate fans of all other clubs.

- - - Updated - - -

For too long players of genuine merit have been overlooked and discredited merely because they do not have a postcode beginning with a 3.

I personally appreciate Gerard Whateley...

Disappointed with him last night when Robbo, not unexpectedly for him, was struggling with who cannoned into Dempsey on Sat night. Gerard offered up Rampe and they both ran with it.

Nick Smith is a premiership player and arguably best small defender in the AFL. I mean, seriously....

[Dosser]

Oops 3 things in common

Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition...

[Jewels]

I would have loved to tune into a 'Press Red for Ed' commentary a fortnight ago when we pumped them, it would have been gold listening to the tears....

Now that would have been a treat ????

[Plugger46]

Disappointed with him last night when Robbo, not unexpectedly for him, was struggling with who cannoned into Dempsey on Sat night. Gerard offered up Rampe and they both ran with it.

Nick Smith is a premiership player and arguably best small defender in the AFL. I mean, seriously....

Noticed that.

Overrated Gerard.

[Melbournehammer]

Roos performed a vintage version of that one. After the Swans got a goal over the back, he said 'that wouldn't happen with the Swans. Teddy and Reggie are the best at getting back into the goal square yada yada.'
Took about a minute for the Bombers to get one off a fast break. No sign of you know who.

I'm not anti Roos, just wish he would t sound so enthusiastic about us and not keep repeating the same things.

this is the frustrating thing about it for me. if you listen to roos the swans would never be scored against because every swans seems to have clean hands, outrun their opponent, have better vision, are the best player at dropping off thier opponent, outwork the fremantle midfielder and so on.

i personally dont like his commentary because it is often so super critical of any error.

[ShockOfHair]

Roos should be given credit for launching the word 'outnumber' as a noun.

[Primmy]

I just do not like his constant talking over the current action with something about what happened at some other stage or some other game. Its like Malcolm Blight all over again. I really enjoy listening to the exchange of pace and syntax with Rooshoooto (sic) and Dunstall because these two enjoy the game itself and I don't feel like I am being lectured at. He doesn't have a grasp of the sense of occasion and cut his comments to size. Will always respect Roos as a coach and player, but ..... no.

[swanspant12]

I don't care what Roosy does. I still thank The Lord above that we never hired that goose Wallace.

[Jewels]

I don't care what Roosy does. I still thank The Lord above that we never hired that goose Wallace.

Amen to that.

[dimelb]

I don't care what Roosy does. I still thank The Lord above that we never hired that goose Wallace.

And all the people said Amen.