Changes for Round 4 versus Kangaroos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • mcs
    Travelling Swannie!!
    • Jul 2007
    • 8166

    #61
    Originally posted by Matt80
    It's been very unsatisfactory to read the posts of people who are targeting a particular umpire.

    The umpire in question is highly experienced, and has been endorsed as an elite umpire by the AFL.

    We all teach our kids about the importance of respecting the umpires decision, and moving on positively with the game. Let's do this ourselves and show some respect to a highly experienced official.
    Well lets see him prove himself to be an 'elite' umpire - he has been an ordinary umpire for a long time if you ask me.

    Its all nice to say you need to respect umpires decisions, but it doesn't mean they don't deserve stick when they make absolute howlers, like he did that day against Freo.

    Not that I condone anyone spitting on an umpire. - and no, it wasn't me!
    "You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."

    Comment

    • Big Al
      Veterans List
      • Feb 2005
      • 7007

      #62
      Originally posted by Matt80
      It's been very unsatisfactory to read the posts of people who are targeting a particular umpire.

      The umpire in question is highly experienced, and has been endorsed as an elite umpire by the AFL.

      We all teach our kids about the importance of respecting the umpires decision, and moving on positively with the game. Let's do this ourselves and show some respect to a highly experienced official.
      I agree. The ego-centric goose would love all the attention so we should just meet his decisions with deathly respectful silence. Maybe he'll start doing the job he's paid to do without histrionics.

      Edit: Anyone caught spitting on anyone should be banned for life. It's pathetic and there are no excuses.
      ..And the Swans are the Premiers...The Ultimate Team...The Ultimate Warriors. They have overcome the highly fancied Hawks in brilliant style. Sydney the 2012 Premiers - Gerard Whately ABC

      Here it is Again! - Huddo SEN

      Comment

      • Jewels
        On the Rookie List
        • Oct 2006
        • 3258

        #63
        Originally posted by Matt80
        It's been very unsatisfactory to read the posts of people who are targeting a particular umpire.

        The umpire in question is highly experienced, and has been endorsed as an elite umpire by the AFL.

        We all teach our kids about the importance of respecting the umpires decision, and moving on positively with the game. Let's do this ourselves and show some respect to a highly experienced official.
        Sorry Matt, but you could not have seen the game in question to not have been outraged at the way we were treated that day and as someone else pointed out, the more outraged we got the more his ego inflated. Most times I would agree with your sentiments but not as far as he is concerned.

        Originally posted by Big Al
        I agree. The ego-centric goose would love all the attention so we should just meet his decisions with deathly respectful silence. Maybe he'll start doing the job he's paid to do without histrionics.

        Edit: Anyone caught spitting on anyone should be banned for life. It's pathetic and there are no excuses.
        Spot on, on both points Al.

        Comment

        • DamY
          Senior Player
          • Sep 2011
          • 1479

          #64
          Like

          Comment

          • Doctor
            Bay 29
            • Sep 2003
            • 2757

            #65
            When an umpire is incompetent they are going to make mistakes that go the way of both teams. There was no incompetence about the umpiring during that Freo game.
            Today's a draft of your epitaph

            Comment

            • Matt80
              Suspended by the MRP
              • Sep 2013
              • 1802

              #66
              Originally posted by Doctor
              When an umpire is incompetent they are going to make mistakes that go the way of both teams. There was no incompetence about the umpiring during that Freo game.
              Come on guys. You can't be making statements that question an officials integrity.

              Some umpiring decisions don't go your way and some do. I recall in the 2012 GF that the Swans got a mark in the goal square in the 2nd quarter, because the umpire had clearly missed Kennedy throwing the ball after being tackled. The decision should have gone to the Hawks. Now do you think that umpire has more integrity than Mother Teresa?

              The umpires performance is assessed every week. The coaches can talk to the umpires director if there is a concern.

              This umpire has been assessed as competent to play a part in the 2014 season. Let's not lower ourselves to the level where we are questioning his integrity and fondly recalling stories of abusing him when he leaves the playing field!

              Comment

              • DeadlyAkkuret
                Veterans List
                • Oct 2006
                • 4547

                #67
                This should go down well.

                Comment

                • erica
                  Happy and I know it
                  • Jan 2008
                  • 1247

                  #68
                  Originally posted by Matt80
                  Come on guys. You can't be making statements that question an officials integrity.

                  Some umpiring decisions don't go your way and some do. I recall in the 2012 GF that the Swans got a mark in the goal square in the 2nd quarter, because the umpire had clearly missed Kennedy throwing the ball after being tackled. The decision should have gone to the Hawks. Now do you think that umpire has more integrity than Mother Teresa?

                  The umpires performance is assessed every week. The coaches can talk to the umpires director if there is a concern.

                  This umpire has been assessed as competent to play a part in the 2014 season. Let's not lower ourselves to the level where we are questioning his integrity and fondly recalling stories of abusing him when he leaves the playing field!
                  It's great to see your view of the situation is so positive, Matt80. Keep believing.
                  All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing. - Edmund Burke

                  Comment

                  • Faunac8
                    Senior Player
                    • Mar 2014
                    • 1548

                    #69
                    It's OK to express frustration with umpiring decisions that's part of sport
                    It's not OK to use them as an excuse or justification of a loss
                    It's unacceptable to personally verbally and physically attack the umpire
                    It's inexcusable to teach kids that it's ok to do so

                    Comment

                    • Matt80
                      Suspended by the MRP
                      • Sep 2013
                      • 1802

                      #70
                      Originally posted by Faunac8
                      It's OK to express frustration with umpiring decisions that's part of sport
                      It's not OK to use them as an excuse or justification of a loss
                      It's unacceptable to personally verbally and physically attack the umpire
                      It's inexcusable to teach kids that it's ok to do so
                      Superb stuff.

                      Comment

                      • Dosser
                        Just wild about Harry
                        • Mar 2011
                        • 1833

                        #71
                        Originally posted by Matt80
                        Come on guys. You can't be making statements that question an officials integrity.

                        Some umpiring decisions don't go your way and some do. I recall in the 2012 GF that the Swans got a mark in the goal square in the 2nd quarter, because the umpire had clearly missed Kennedy throwing the ball after being tackled. The decision should have gone to the Hawks. Now do you think that umpire has more integrity than Mother Teresa?

                        The umpires performance is assessed every week. The coaches can talk to the umpires director if there is a concern.

                        This umpire has been assessed as competent to play a part in the 2014 season. Let's not lower ourselves to the level where we are questioning his integrity and fondly recalling stories of abusing him when he leaves the playing field!
                        I have always held to the opinion that the umpires have very little to do with a win/loss. In fact the perception of the umpires performance is largely dependent upon whether your team won or lost. Having said that, the game in question put razor on my radar as I had never seen a one-sided display like that before. It is puzzling because I know that umpires are impartial but that game seemed very wrong.
                        I think razors problem is that he feels he had to adjudicate on everything. He never lets the game flow. If it is something thatmost umpires will let go, razor will blow the whistle. I just hope he had learned.

                        Comment

                        • Gezball
                          Warming the Bench
                          • Mar 2010
                          • 244

                          #72
                          This has become a thread about umpires....

                          Comment

                          • mcs
                            Travelling Swannie!!
                            • Jul 2007
                            • 8166

                            #73
                            Originally posted by Matt80
                            Come on guys. You can't be making statements that question an officials integrity.

                            Some umpiring decisions don't go your way and some do. I recall in the 2012 GF that the Swans got a mark in the goal square in the 2nd quarter, because the umpire had clearly missed Kennedy throwing the ball after being tackled. The decision should have gone to the Hawks. Now do you think that umpire has more integrity than Mother Teresa?

                            The umpires performance is assessed every week. The coaches can talk to the umpires director if there is a concern.

                            This umpire has been assessed as competent to play a part in the 2014 season. Let's not lower ourselves to the level where we are questioning his integrity and fondly recalling stories of abusing him when he leaves the playing field!
                            Can I ask Matt80, were you at that game against Freo, or did you watch it? Just intrigued if you remember what game we are talking about?

                            - - - Updated - - -

                            Anyway, Let's get back to the football.... what's the weather like in Sydney today? Going to be a dry track?
                            "You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."

                            Comment

                            • aardvark
                              Veterans List
                              • Mar 2010
                              • 5685

                              #74
                              I'm feeling just a tad nervous about this one. Last kick of the game Swans by 2pts.

                              Comment

                              • swanwolf
                                Warming the Bench
                                • Apr 2013
                                • 198

                                #75
                                Originally posted by mcs
                                Anyway, Let's get back to the football.... what's the weather like in Sydney today? Going to be a dry track?
                                Showers with a chance of Biblical Flood. Don't worry mcs, the team can always evacuate the SCG in Buddy's Natural Ark - 2 by 2.
                                I hope one of the ruckman is straight, reduces the danger of them breeding.

                                Comment

                                Working...