Rnd 8 Match Day Thread. Richmond V Sydney. MCG 19.25 pm.

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • snajik
    Senior Player
    • Jan 2003
    • 1115

    Originally posted by Captain
    Yep he was shocking. Can't think of a worse debutant in years.
    I'm not keen on judging a player on one game but he certainly seemed overawed by the occasion. There were times when he appeared to freeze.
    It's very hard to live in a studio apartment in San Jose with a man who's learning to play violin. That's what she told the police when she handed them the empty revolver.
    The Scarlatti Tilt - Richard Brautigan

    Comment

    • Dosser
      Just wild about Harry
      • Mar 2011
      • 1833

      I should know better than to read this thread straight after a loss. Some people get way too nasty and personal. A bit more class would be nice. Not a good game but it is done now and hopefully we will wake up and play properly because of it.

      Comment

      • Velour&Ruffles
        Regular in the Side
        • Jun 2006
        • 896

        Originally posted by dejavoodoo44
        Franklin's kicking was a joy to watch. Who knows how many he would have kicked, if Rance was being umpired in the same manner as Grundy.
        I thought the same at the ground. It seems Rance has been issued the same Golden Ticket that Stephen Silvagni used to have, where you can constantly scrag and hold, even when the ball isn't anywhere near, and the umpires just let it go. If Rance had been umpired the same way Grundy was then Buddy kicks 27 off his own boot tonight. Seriously.
        That said, that wasn't why we lost. We still have nobody but ourselves to blame. I counted 142 brain farts by our players but I might have missed a couple.
        My opinion is objective truth in its purest form

        Comment

        • Daisi
          Senior Player
          • Jul 2011
          • 1468

          Devastated...really poor decision making in the last minute of the game...where was the leadership group? Where were the runners to tell Towers to kick the ball to Buddy? Where was the coach? Seriously unprofessional behaviour from all concerned...

          Would like to echo the comments re Buddy and Rance...great contest to watch...well played by both..( I forgive Buddy his occasional lapses)

          Kudos to Richmond...they didn't give up...kept persisting and deserved the win......

          I was looking forward to a good year this year...mmmm not so sure about that now..this was a failure of communication on field and off..a professionally run football team does not lose in the last minute of a game..

          Comment

          • Blue Sun
            Senior Player
            • May 2010
            • 1438

            We should have lost to Brisbane a fortnight ago, and deserved to lose tonight. The Swans are a top 8 side at best. You're kidding yourself if you think otherwise. Sure, the Swans have a talented list, but they're underperforming big time. If Franklin didn't play tonight, Sydney would have been hosed by a cellar-dweller, instead we go down by a point. The next two matches will be difficult, and to be honest, I think we'll lose to Hawthorn next week at the MCG and I wouldn't be surprised if North put us away at the SCG too. The season is long, which is lucky, because theres a lot of room for improvement.

            BTW, I know this comes across as a "negative Nancy" type post, but its spot on as far as I'm concerned. Horse has his work cut out for him.

            Comment

            • aardvark
              Veterans List
              • Mar 2010
              • 5685

              Hannebury was fantastic tonight, time to make him captain. It would be nice to have a captain that leads by example and inspires the troops for a change, one who at least knows what a contest is.

              Comment

              • Maltopia
                Senior Player
                • Apr 2016
                • 1556

                Lots of dumb plays today, I don't know why we have Mills doing the kick out after a point is scored. He will be amazing in a few years, but why put the extra pressure on him now when there are calmer heads in such a tight game? Re Hiscox and Towers, I wanted both to succeed, but better to find out now who can handle the pressure and who can't than in September. BJ would have been such a better selection, at least you know he has got the ticker even if his execution isn't the best.

                Thank goodness that Tahlia, Reid and Rampe are all going to be available for senior selection again soon as I think we are getting a bit carried away with the youth who have mostly outperformed all expectations but should not be what we are banking on for the rest of the season.

                Comment

                • Doctor
                  Bay 29
                  • Sep 2003
                  • 2757

                  Originally posted by Dosser
                  I should know better than to read this thread straight after a loss. Some people get way too nasty and personal. A bit more class would be nice. Not a good game but it is done now and hopefully we will wake up and play properly because of it.
                  Agreed on all counts.

                  ...and if anyone wants evidence of how the trade ban hurt us, tonight is it.
                  Last edited by Doctor; 14 May 2016, 11:39 PM.
                  Today's a draft of your epitaph

                  Comment

                  • CureTheSane
                    Carpe Noctem
                    • Jan 2003
                    • 5032

                    On Hiscox - I didn't see people being all upset when he was selected.
                    The difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.

                    Comment

                    • CureTheSane
                      Carpe Noctem
                      • Jan 2003
                      • 5032

                      McVeigh watch - very poor tonight. Way too many turnovers and passing to players under pressure. It was a good thing when his kicks fell short of a one on one rather than in front of a Tiger.
                      The difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.

                      Comment

                      • rojo
                        Opti-pessi-misti
                        • Mar 2009
                        • 1100

                        Originally posted by CureTheSane
                        On Hiscox - I didn't see people being all upset when he was selected.
                        We were in a state of shock!!

                        Comment

                        • Ludwig
                          Veterans List
                          • Apr 2007
                          • 9359

                          Originally posted by Doctor

                          ...and if anyone wants evidence of how the trade ban hurt us, tonight is it.
                          And who might have been in our side to save the day for us if we didn't have the trade ban? I didn't see a scintilla of evidence connected to the trade ban.

                          Originally posted by CureTheSane
                          On Hiscox - I didn't see people being all upset when he was selected.
                          There were quite a lot of us who had doubts on Hiscox. There was general disappointed with his performance int the NAB preseason games. He just so happened to have a pretty decent game in the NEAFL last week. I got the feeling that Horse thought Hiscox would run the Tigers ragged.

                          Of the senior listed players, Rose and Davis have been our best and certainly would have preferred them to Hiscox and Towers. Even Brandon Jack has been playing better.

                          I thought Robinson was added to the LTIL. I would elevate either Marsh or Newman, both have been consistently among our best players in the reserves. They can add some pace to the backline. Marsh has turned into a pretty solid defender. I'd bring one of them in and move Mills to the midfield. Newman is pretty decent at kick-ins as well and gets plenty of the ball.

                          Comment

                          • Doctor
                            Bay 29
                            • Sep 2003
                            • 2757

                            Originally posted by Ludwig
                            And who might have been in our side to save the day for us if we didn't have the trade ban? I didn't see a scintilla of evidence connected to the trade ban.
                            The KPD or two we would have traded for but were prohibited from doing so.
                            Today's a draft of your epitaph

                            Comment

                            • Ludwig
                              Veterans List
                              • Apr 2007
                              • 9359

                              Originally posted by Doctor
                              The KPD or two we would have traded for but were prohibited from doing so.
                              The only possibility would have been Patfull, who might have been in the side in lieu of Laidler. And I don't see how that changes the game we just lost. We were limited in our trading due to the loss of COLA more than the trading ban.

                              Comment

                              • CureTheSane
                                Carpe Noctem
                                • Jan 2003
                                • 5032

                                I thought Towers was OK tonight. Obviously he made his mistakes, but then again so did many others.
                                Certainly no reason for what he's copping.
                                Hope he keeps his spot next week.
                                Until players like him and Hiscox get a taste, we'll never know if they are going to make it.
                                McVeigh is the perfect example. If the coaching staff listened to everyone here when he was 'McHack' he would have dwindled away and never become what he did.
                                Sure he looks like he may be starting to look like he won't hang around too much longer (IMO) but he became a very valuable part of the club.
                                The difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.

                                Comment

                                Working...