Secret to Swans success

[bloodsbigot]

Agree with 1,2,5,6 but 3 and 4 cmon.. I don't like the Hawks either but no need to be hateful

For 3. I'm half joking but there's been rumblings for a while. I wouldn't be surprised at all if they were getting extra cash, especially for commercials/media appearances on the condition they stay at Hawthorn.

For 4, I'm exaggerating of course but for whatever reason Hawthorn are favoured by the umps. I have a sneaky suspicion that their gameplan revolves around drawing frees and Clarkson trains them for this.

Either that, or the umpires actually are closet Hawk supporters. Pretty dodgy when they have images like these on their twitter page:
stephens.jpg

I find it unbelievable how many close games of theirs this year has been won by 50-50 calls this year. They must study the umpires very closely (if they aren't paying them under the table), and study how each umpire interprets the rules.

[Maltopia]

I am one of those that perceives umpire bias. It would be so interesting to have stats for each umpire showing frees for/against each team (also inside 50s). That would certainly either confirm or debunk some theories about certain umpires.

[The Big Cat]

Losing to the Tigers and Dogs in such a fashion was really difficult to take, but them being able to bounce back both times with a win shows this is a good team.

I soothe my disappointment in losing those two games with the view (mine) that they wouldn't have won the next game if not for being gutted by the loss. Hawks at the G and cats at Geelong, who would have pencilled them in prior to the season?

[dawson]

I soothe my disappointment in losing those two games with the view (mine) that they wouldn't have won the next game if not for being gutted by the loss. Hawks at the G and cats at Geelong, who would have pencilled them in prior to the season?

And then once you get to finals, these games all become meaningless....

[kilroy]

Agree with 1,2,5,6 but 3 and 4 cmon.. I don't like the Hawks either but no need to be hateful

This denial by Afl fans and acceptance that thou shall not speak against umpires annoys me no end. No wonder the AFL continue to do as they please when they have the most submissive fans to ever follow a code.

"Sit there, wave your little AFL endorsed flag but dont wave it too much, clap a few times and then make sure to show the TV cameras the sponsored signs we gave you as part of the fun aspect of going to a game. Oh and naughty naughty dont say a word about the amazing umpiring. yay go team!"

- - - Updated - - -

For 3. I'm half joking but there's been rumblings for a while. I wouldn't be surprised at all if they were getting extra cash, especially for commercials/media appearances on the condition they stay at Hawthorn.

For 4, I'm exaggerating of course but for whatever reason Hawthorn are favoured by the umps. I have a sneaky suspicion that their gameplan revolves around drawing frees and Clarkson trains them for this.

Either that, or the umpires actually are closet Hawk supporters. Pretty dodgy when they have images like these on their twitter page:
[ATTACH=CONFIG]1555[/ATTACH]

I find it unbelievable how many close games of theirs this year has been won by 50-50 calls this year. They must study the umpires very closely (if they aren't paying them under the table), and study how each umpire interprets the rules.

I am glad im not the only one, but having an umpire officiate the team they support is so unprofessional and just crap.

[kilroy]

I am one of those that perceives umpire bias. It would be so interesting to have stats for each umpire showing frees for/against each team (also inside 50s). That would certainly either confirm or debunk some theories about certain umpires.

Its amazing we have stats for basically everything these days and a lot of fans are stat nerds, yet no one has ever made a stat for umpires. I would like to see a stat that shows how many goals are scored from umpiring free kicks per team per game.

Also where the free was paid.

I am sure champion data have one for the umpires which they then hand over to the umpires coach, but the image conscious AFL has suppressed it to the general public as it would reveal some damning stats, like how many frees does Stevic give the hawks in front of goal 45 out and on a slight angle.

[Jewels]

Its amazing we have stats for basically everything these days and a lot of fans are stat nerds, yet no one has ever made a stat for umpires. I would like to see a stat that shows how many goals are scored from umpiring free kicks per team per game.

Also where the free was paid.

I am sure champion data have one for the umpires which they then hand over to the umpires coach, but the image conscious AFL has suppressed it to the general public as it would reveal some damning stats, like how many frees does Stevic give the hawks in front of goal 45 out and on a slight angle.

I actually think Stevic is a very good umpire - unless your team is playing Hawthorn.
I have noticed that he hasn't been appointed to a Hawks game all season so maybe the powers that be have noticed something - wishful thinking I know!

I've probably jinxed us now and our umpires on Thursday will be Stevic, Schmidt and Nicholls.

[dimelb]

I actually think Stevic is a very good umpire - unless your team is playing Hawthorn.
I have noticed that he hasn't been appointed to a Hawks game all season so maybe the powers that be have noticed something - wishful thinking I know!

I've probably jinxed us now and our umpires on Thursday will be Stevic, Schmidt and Nicholls.

It's Schmitt - and whatever you do, don't forget the m.

[kilroy]

It's Schmitt - and whatever you do, don't forget the m.

So Schmitt spelt m o r o n and pronounced as s h i t

sorry for the swear filter avoidance