It is as if the whole club trained last week purely on butchering the footy.
Round 17: Sydney Swans Reserves v Giants @ SCG
Collapse
X
-
-
-
Swans Clearances
- J.Rose 3
- J.Brown 2
- K.Galloway 2
- J.Hardman 2
- B.McGlynn 2
- S.Murray 2
- T.Nankervis 2
- N.Newman 2
- C.O'Riordan 2
- D.Baron-Hay 1
- N.Cooper 1
- J.Deep 1
- B.Jack 1
- H.Marsh 1
- M.Wilson 1
Giants Clearances- J.Barrett 12
- W.Hoskin-Elliott 8
- L.Whitfield 6
- C.Byrne 3
- D.Simpson 3
- C.Bance 2
- F.Carroll 2
- B.Clark 1
- M.Flynn 1
- H.Macreadie 1
- P.McKenna 1
- J.Powell 1
- N.Shipley 1
Swans 27 Giants 42Comment
-
Comment
-
I don't think Coach Shaw would have been overly disappointed with the outing in the sense that the work rate and pressure skills were pretty good for the whole match, even amongst all the skinny bodied top ups out there. I think the number of scoring shots each team had was a fair reflection of the ability to win the ball and get it going in the right direction. But the scoreboard reflected that the Giants had a bit more system, skill and composure in their forward 50.
I suspect Coach Longmire would have been a little less enamoured in the sense that those he might think about as senior options didn't show the skill level necessary, on the whole.
Newman was probably one exception. His ball use was good, and he showed some dash and dare running the ball out. Nankervis continued his good form too. He wasn't as dominant as last week but still pretty good. I suspect Sinclair must be looking over his shoulder at what Nankervis is dishing up in the reserves (which can only be a good thing).
The only other one who impressed me somewhat was Marsh, who came on after quarter time and was pretty decent in defence and through the midfield. He needs another couple of weeks, you'd think, before pushing for a senior recall, but it was a solid return after his few week layoff.
Rose, Jack, McGlynn and Hiscox all got plenty of the ball but butchered it far too often.
I'm with you Liz,if there was only a little more scoreboard pressure might have been a different finish.
Toppies were generally good,Davis a bit wasteful but no worse than the rest,Hardman had a good go for a 16 yr old,Wilson just missed a couple of chances but kicked a cracker in the last qtr with a great pressure act which resulted in a goal that got them back into the game.Baron-Hey & Hebron good under the pump in defence for youngsters yet again..Comment
-
-
I'm with you Liz,if there was only a little more scoreboard pressure might have been a different finish.
Toppies were generally good,Davis a bit wasteful but no worse than the rest,Hardman had a good go for a 16 yr old,Wilson just missed a couple of chances but kicked a cracker in the last qtr with a great pressure act which resulted in a goal that got them back into the game.Baron-Hey & Hebron good under the pump in defence for youngsters yet again.."You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."Comment
-
NEAFL highlights Rd 17 - July 25, 2016 - sydneyswans.com.au
For once the highlights have no boring vision of set shot goals!
Only because there were no set shot goals on the day, but hey let's not quibble about the specifics.
I'll add my own highlight, young Hardman's exciting forward play that deserved a goal but had a cruel bounce at the end with his dribble kick.
Last edited by ugg; 26 July 2016, 02:42 PM.Comment
-
I'll admit Hardman surprised me. Nicely. He was ok out there.
Can hardly expect a fantastic game with that many toppies in the mix and hardly any go to players. Bit disappointed in Ted and Benny's output tho.
the wind was a factor. Not a breeze. A Mighty Wind. However, kicking for goal was not exactly hit and miss. More miss and miss. Still, it wasn't horribleIf you've never jumped from one couch to the other to save yourself from lava then you didn't have a childhoodComment
-
I get the impression that Ted is pretty relaxed about the phase-down in his footy career. He has a lovely photo and post on his Instagram account @tedrichards25. But I'm sure if he gets selected for the seniors he will still be giving us his 100%.Comment
-
I thought Ted was okay once he moved back into the backline. He was organising the backline which I'm sure was a great learning experience for the youngsters like Baron-Hay and Hebron playing back there. He did cop one almighty spray from James Rose in the last quarter when he took a shot from the boundary that didn't score.Comment
-
I thought Ted was okay once he moved back into the backline. He was organising the backline which I'm sure was a great learning experience for the youngsters like Baron-Hay and Hebron playing back there. He did cop one almighty spray from James Rose in the last quarter when he took a shot from the boundary that didn't score.All opinions are not equal. Some are a very great deal more robust, sophisticated, and well supported in logic and argument than others. -Douglas Adams, author (11 Mar 1952-2001)Comment
-
Comment
Comment