Changes for 1st Qualifying Final vs GWS

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • troyjones2525
    Swans Fanatic!
    • Mar 2008
    • 2908

    Changes for 1st Qualifying Final vs GWS

    I know we have a couple of weeks to discuss this but there are a few players who will be nervous over the next 2 weeks. You'd imagine that Mills is a guarantee to come into the side but Harry Marsh played well! Then there's the Papley v McGlynn argument which on last weeks form is a no brainer but season form Papley would be in front! Has Towers papers been stamped after doing not a lot wrong the last few months with horse preferring the 2 smalls? And then there's Cunningham...been quiet the last few weeks. Will he keep his place?

    Many questions to ponder in an otherwise pretty settled side. We can go a few ways which is handy and helpful if we decide to pick horses for courses and against certain opposition.

    I'll go out on a limb and pick my side that will hopefully put us through to a S.C.G. Prelim final!

    Out: Cunningham
    In: Mills

    Hard call because i do like Cunningham's speed and ball use but he hasn't been getting enough of it and i think that Marsh has good speed but extra height and neat foot skills to play his role. Mills obviously fits straight back in to where he has been in a great debut season.

    Gotta stick with the 2 smalls after last week with Towers an unlucky emergency with Harry C.

    What is everyone elses thoughts?

    Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk
  • MattW
    Veterans List
    • May 2011
    • 4218

    #2
    Originally posted by troyjones2525
    I know we have a couple of weeks to discuss this but there are a few players who will be nervous over the next 2 weeks. You'd imagine that Mills is a guarantee to come into the side but Harry Marsh played well! Then there's the Papley v McGlynn argument which on last weeks form is a no brainer but season form Papley would be in front! Has Towers papers been stamped after doing not a lot wrong the last few months with horse preferring the 2 smalls? And then there's Cunningham...been quiet the last few weeks. Will he keep his place?

    Many questions to ponder in an otherwise pretty settled side. We can go a few ways which is handy and helpful if we decide to pick horses for courses and against certain opposition.

    I'll go out on a limb and pick my side that will hopefully put us through to a S.C.G. Prelim final!

    Out: Cunningham
    In: Mills

    Hard call because i do like Cunningham's speed and ball use but he hasn't been getting enough of it and i think that Marsh has good speed but extra height and neat foot skills to play his role. Mills obviously fits straight back in to where he has been in a great debut season.

    Gotta stick with the 2 smalls after last week with Towers an unlucky emergency with Harry C.

    What is everyone elses thoughts?

    Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk
    Yep, I agree: Mills for Cunningham. Marsh was impressive on the weekend, more versatile than Cunningham.

    Comment

    • barry
      Veterans List
      • Jan 2003
      • 8499

      #3
      In: mills
      Out: marsh

      Comment

      • Buzz80
        On the Rookie List
        • Aug 2016
        • 31

        #4
        Originally posted by troyjones2525
        I know we have a couple of weeks to discuss this but there are a few players who will be nervous over the next 2 weeks. You'd imagine that Mills is a guarantee to come into the side but Harry Marsh played well! Then there's the Papley v McGlynn argument which on last weeks form is a no brainer but season form Papley would be in front! Has Towers papers been stamped after doing not a lot wrong the last few months with horse preferring the 2 smalls? And then there's Cunningham...been quiet the last few weeks. Will he keep his place?

        Many questions to ponder in an otherwise pretty settled side. We can go a few ways which is handy and helpful if we decide to pick horses for courses and against certain opposition.

        I'll go out on a limb and pick my side that will hopefully put us through to a S.C.G. Prelim final!

        Out: Cunningham
        In: Mills

        Hard call because i do like Cunningham's speed and ball use but he hasn't been getting enough of it and i think that Marsh has good speed but extra height and neat foot skills to play his role. Mills obviously fits straight back in to where he has been in a great debut season.

        Gotta stick with the 2 smalls after last week with Towers an unlucky emergency with Harry C.

        What is everyone elses thoughts?

        Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk
        Yeah i would have to agree also
        Out: Cunningham
        In: Mills
        Hard to make any changes after last week but agree Mills has to come back in. I like the balance Marsh adds to the backline, can play short or tall and has good disposal.

        Towers may be handy breaking the lines against GWS also but hard to find anyone else to leave out. I think McGlynn played his best game for years so keeps his spot for next game at least.

        Comment

        • giant
          Veterans List
          • Mar 2005
          • 4731

          #5
          Cunningham would have to be feeling the heat I suspect. May hold his place given the opponent.

          Comment

          • Doctor
            Bay 29
            • Sep 2003
            • 2757

            #6
            Good analysis whether you turn out to have made the right or wrong prediction Troy. My feeling is that it'll be Mills for Marsh just because it's last in first out, but your argument is sound. Whoever misses out will be unlucky.

            It's great that McGlynn has done what he can to show that he and Papley can in fact play in the same side. It's up to the selection panel now as to whether or not he has convinced them.
            Today's a draft of your epitaph

            Comment

            • barry
              Veterans List
              • Jan 2003
              • 8499

              #7
              Very dangerous to keep mcglynn in the team in my opinion. Ie bad for us.

              Comment

              • ernie koala
                Senior Player
                • May 2007
                • 3251

                #8
                I agree with most above...

                OUT : Cunningham (Hasn't done enough of late)

                IN : Mills

                Marsh looks ready made for finals intensity and physicality.

                McGlynn will be fine, he's a proven performer over many years and should be full of confidence,

                I hope they give him a close checking role on one of GWS's small defenders.
                Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it's time to pause and reflect... MT

                Comment

                • Maltopia
                  Senior Player
                  • Apr 2016
                  • 1556

                  #9
                  Is Sweet Caroline out or is that also played at ANZ?

                  Comment

                  • Hotpotato
                    Senior Player
                    • Jun 2014
                    • 2271

                    #10
                    Out with the bye. Bring all the finals forward one week .
                    Whose dumb idea was this ?

                    Comment

                    • barry
                      Veterans List
                      • Jan 2003
                      • 8499

                      #11
                      Has mcglynn performed in finals?

                      Comment

                      • Beerman
                        Regular in the Side
                        • Oct 2010
                        • 823

                        #12
                        McGlynn was working much, much harder than Papley on Saturday - perhaps Papley is getting worn down. I haven't been able to get to many games this year, but on last Saturday's effort, I would not be surprised to see Papley dropped at some point during finals.

                        I was also surprised to read a few weeks ago that Cunningham has the highest disposal efficiency of all the Swans. There you go!

                        Mills has to come in, I think Marsh will be the one dropped.

                        Comment

                        • Ludwig
                          Veterans List
                          • Apr 2007
                          • 9359

                          #13
                          Originally posted by Maltopia
                          Is Sweet Caroline out or is that also played at ANZ?
                          I think they will play something by Barry White or Barry Manilow, perhaps Mandy. I'm sure everyone will be crying out for Sweet Caroline.

                          Comment

                          • Beerman
                            Regular in the Side
                            • Oct 2010
                            • 823

                            #14
                            Originally posted by Beerman
                            McGlynn was working much, much harder than Papley on Saturday - perhaps Papley is getting worn down. I haven't been able to get to many games this year, but on last Saturday's effort, I would not be surprised to see Papley dropped at some point during finals.

                            I was also surprised to read a few weeks ago that Cunningham has the highest disposal efficiency of all the Swans. There you go!

                            Mills has to come in, I think Marsh will be the one dropped.
                            On reflection, it's time they brought me in! I've been "Warming the Bench" for the past 6 years now - about time I got the call-up.

                            Anyone know what it takes to become a regular in the side?

                            Comment

                            • CureTheSane
                              Carpe Noctem
                              • Jan 2003
                              • 5032

                              #15
                              Mills for Marsh for me.
                              Cunningham has been solid all year and now is not the time to start making too many changes.
                              We're about to play finals with a bunch of kids in the team. I think Cunningham will stand up to the pressure more than Marsh, who will get his chance

                              Where to here for Laidler if he doesn't play finals?
                              The difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.

                              Comment

                              Working...