Changes for Round 5 - GWS

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Ludwig
    Veterans List
    • Apr 2007
    • 9359

    #76
    Originally posted by RogueSwan
    Is Talia injured or just on the outer? A 192cm 94kg (semi) experienced, relatively quick backman would be nice right about now.
    If you look at Talia, Melican and Maibaum, Talia clearly looks the biggest of the 3. He's got the size to cover the big forwards. To be fair, he hadn't played any competitive football for 10 months and a lisfranc injury requires a lengthy rehab, so it may take a while to get back to the form that got him a starting role last year. In the interim, Aliir has become an emerging star, Melican looks a very good chance to get a shot at senior level and we recruited Maibaum, one of the top rated KPDs in the draft. He is no longer next cab off the rank. He looks healthy though and seems to be playing okay, but will have to shine in the NEAFL to get call up.

    Comment

    • CureTheSane
      Carpe Noctem
      • Jan 2003
      • 5032

      #77
      Yeah but the club never really touches on Talia.
      I was one who called for his head after the drugs thing, but the club decided to keep him.
      In doing so he deserves to be treated like any other player and be considered for selection like anyone else.
      Yet the Swans seem to be brushing him under the carpet...
      The difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.

      Comment

      • RogueSwan
        McVeigh for Brownlow
        • Apr 2003
        • 4602

        #78
        Originally posted by Ludwig
        If you look at Talia, Melican and Maibaum, Talia clearly looks the biggest of the 3. He's got the size to cover the big forwards. To be fair, he hadn't played any competitive football for 10 months and a lisfranc injury requires a lengthy rehab, so it may take a while to get back to the form that got him a starting role last year. In the interim, Aliir has become an emerging star, Melican looks a very good chance to get a shot at senior level and we recruited Maibaum, one of the top rated KPDs in the draft. He is no longer next cab off the rank. He looks healthy though and seems to be playing okay, but will have to shine in the NEAFL to get call up.
        So, we have potential for our backline going forward but, at the moment our forward line is going backwards?
        "Fortunately, this is the internet, so knowing nothing is no obstacle to having an opinion!." Beerman 18-07-2017

        Comment

        • annew
          Senior Player
          • Mar 2006
          • 2164

          #79
          Originally posted by CureTheSane
          Yeah but the club never really touches on Talia.
          I was one who called for his head after the drugs thing, but the club decided to keep him.
          In doing so he deserves to be treated like any other player and be considered for selection like anyone else.
          Yet the Swans seem to be brushing him under the carpet...
          As he was contracted the club could not get rid of him. My opinion everyone deserves a second chance, he has not tested positive and should be given that second chance.

          Comment

          • MattW
            Veterans List
            • May 2011
            • 4236

            #80
            Originally posted by annew
            As he was contracted the club could not get rid of him. My opinion everyone deserves a second chance, he has not tested positive and should be given that second chance.
            Yes, but needs to be fit and in form. I'm not aware that his form in training or NEAFL suggests he's ready to play.

            Comment

            • Dosser
              Just wild about Harry
              • Mar 2011
              • 1833

              #81
              Originally posted by annew
              As he was contracted the club could not get rid of him. My opinion everyone deserves a second chance, he has not tested positive and should be given that second chance.
              I'm sure not everything comes out in the media.

              Comment

              • Plugger46
                Senior Player
                • Apr 2003
                • 3674

                #82
                Originally posted by CureTheSane
                Yeah but the club never really touches on Talia.
                I was one who called for his head after the drugs thing, but the club decided to keep him.
                In doing so he deserves to be treated like any other player and be considered for selection like anyone else.
                Yet the Swans seem to be brushing him under the carpet...
                Looked way off the pace in his JLT appearance.
                Bloods

                "Lockett is the best of all time" - Robert Harvey, Darrel Baldock, Nathan Burke, Kevin Bartlett, Bob Skilton

                Comment

                • annew
                  Senior Player
                  • Mar 2006
                  • 2164

                  #83
                  Originally posted by MattW
                  Yes, but needs to be fit and in form. I'm not aware that his form in training or NEAFL suggests he's ready to play.
                  If that is the case no problems I would hate to think he was being given the cold shoulder because of his indiscretion/charge. Hard to think he was ok for round 1 last year but not ok this year yet an unfit Allir was picked for example.

                  Comment

                  • Sandrevan
                    Warming the Bench
                    • May 2016
                    • 355

                    #84
                    The only definite in looks to be Tippett. However, who gets dropped for him. Perhaps one of the newbie small forwards Florent, Fox or Hayward. The one most in need of a rest is Florent.

                    Rohan - interrupted pre-season, no match practice, too much of a risk - 1 or 2 games in the NEAFL
                    Heeny - good pre-season but recovering from the GF (glandular fever) - ???
                    McVeigh - interrupted pre-season, no match practice, high risk of re-injuring his calf - ???? Perhaps if McVeigh is good at organizing the troops he can put on the pink and become the runner.

                    I suspect Horse will take the risk and play Heeny and McVeigh - but I hope not.

                    As other have said we could use 3 tall defenders - but who to bring in? And who would go out?

                    KJ out (injured), Mills or Jones into the midfield and bring in Melican for the defence.

                    I guess we'll find out tonight.

                    Comment

                    • Billericay
                      Regular in the Side
                      • May 2013
                      • 712

                      #85
                      I think Heeney will play. Rohan and McHack are less likely, but Horse has brought both in before without games in the NEAFL, so I really have no idea what will happen tonight. Who goes out is intriguing. I still vote for Fox Foot Florentine

                      Comment

                      • ugg
                        Can you feel it?
                        Site Admin
                        • Jan 2003
                        • 15978

                        #86
                        Fox returned to the rookie list for Rohan, so that's at least one out.
                        Reserves live updates (Twitter)
                        Reserves WIKI -
                        Top Goalkickers| Best Votegetters

                        Comment

                        • Flying South
                          Regular in the Side
                          • Sep 2013
                          • 585

                          #87
                          Last year when Macca returned from injury Horse left tbe decision to him. Mr I'm too good for reserves chose to come straight back into seniors. I'm expecting the same. Though he's not captain now so choice could be out of his hands.

                          Melican or Maibaum need to come in which will allow Aliir to play d3 and hopefully free him up a little for some intercept marking which is so important to modern day footy. Mills is slso good at reading this as well so i would keep him down back and play Jones more in the midfield to provide a bit more grunt.

                          Heeney and Rohan need a game or two in reserves for some conditioning and recovery. But i suspect they will name Heeney

                          Changes for me are
                          In: Tippett, Macca, Melican/Maibaum
                          Out: Florent, Foote, Jack

                          Comment

                          • ugg
                            Can you feel it?
                            Site Admin
                            • Jan 2003
                            • 15978

                            #88
                            Tippett Heeney Rohan Melican for Fox Florent Newman Aliir
                            Reserves live updates (Twitter)
                            Reserves WIKI -
                            Top Goalkickers| Best Votegetters

                            Comment

                            • annew
                              Senior Player
                              • Mar 2006
                              • 2164

                              #89
                              Originally posted by ugg
                              Tippett Heeney Rohan Melican for Fox Florent Newman Aliir
                              Interesting that Newman was omitted.

                              Comment

                              • magic.merkin
                                Senior Player
                                • Jul 2008
                                • 1199

                                #90
                                I'm quite comfortable with those changes. A few to find form, touches and some extra legs in the magoos.

                                Comment

                                Working...