Changes for Round 6 - CARLTON

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Billericay
    Regular in the Side
    • May 2013
    • 712

    #61
    Originally posted by chalbilto
    It would appear that there is going to be minimal changes for this week. I think that with K.Jack out they will bring in Rose though I would like to see Newman brought in with Mills moved into the centre.
    Maybe... and if only one change, I vote Newman. Horse has been unusually tricky at selection this year and pulled the odd unexpected surprise. Maybe he's giving the players in the team one last chance (they have mostly had five) to prove themselves before he starts swinging the axe.

    I reckon no debutants this week.

    Comment

    • liz
      Veteran
      Site Admin
      • Jan 2003
      • 16769

      #62
      Originally posted by bloodspirit

      Strong words, liz! And I agree. I thought Rose had numerous defensive lapses on the weekend and so I haven't been calling for his return like others on the back of his classy goals etc.
      There was one other incident involving Rose that irritated me on Saturday. I do like watching him. He has a few tricks (though he can also make the simple look hard at times). But there was a passage sometime in the 3rd quarter where the Swans made a quick break out of defence and whoever had the ball was streaming through the middle of the ground at full pace. The forward 50 had been deserted but both Rose and Pink got on their bikes as soon as they saw what was unfolding and ran back hard towards goal. They separated. Pink got very deep and in the central corridor while Rose was a bit wider and shallower. Pink had a defender closer than Rose, who was in a lot of space, but both provided a good forward target. Whoever had the ball (and I can't remember who it was), picked Pink and delivered well. Pink took the mark and scored from close range with the resultant kick. All good and well. Both players did well, and Rose running to different space was important. But while all the other Swans who had reached the vicinity of the forward line ran over to Pink to congratulate him (which is the team norm most of the time whenever a goal is kicked), Rose stayed where he was, barely 20m away. His body language suggested he was sulking because the kicker had gone to Pink rather than him.

      I noticed that in the 4th quarter, when Rose kicked his final goal, Pink did make the effort to run out and congratulate him, despite being farther away.

      It may be a small thing. Maybe I'm being hard on Rose. But I did wonder if he's more focussed on his own individual contribution than the overall performance of the team. That assessment isn't purely based on that one incident. He does have a tendency to ping at goals when he's in range, without obviously looking to see whether there is a better option. And I can understand that a player who thinks he might be on the cusp of a senior spot would be eager to demonstrate to the coaches what he can do. I just wish he'd sometimes focus more on what he can do in terms of chasing and tackling, and not just on taking speccies or kicking clever goals (and wayward behinds).

      Comment

      • rb4x
        Regular in the Side
        • Dec 2007
        • 968

        #63
        Well from the training photos today it is obvious Newman and Rose did not go to Darwin and are in the mix. Not sure who Melican was kicking to in the photo. Number looked like 35 but did not look like Naismith. Might have been 33, BJ with a haircut and cap on. Very limited and blurry photos. Could see Franklin, Melican, Rohan, Reid, Parker, Rampe (with arm guard) and Ronke.

        Comment

        • liz
          Veteran
          Site Admin
          • Jan 2003
          • 16769

          #64
          I think that was Jack (33).

          Comment

          • ugg
            Can you feel it?
            Site Admin
            • Jan 2003
            • 15970

            #65
            Melican looks like he's kicking to Grundy, who's been known to wear a cap at training.
            Reserves live updates (Twitter)
            Reserves WIKI -
            Top Goalkickers| Best Votegetters

            Comment

            • Mountain Man
              Regular in the Side
              • Feb 2008
              • 908

              #66
              I just looked up players heights; as reported by Swans.

              Johnson is 194
              Allir 193
              Grundy and Talia 192
              Marsh 189
              Newman and Rampe 188

              Comment

              • ugg
                Can you feel it?
                Site Admin
                • Jan 2003
                • 15970

                #67
                And how tall is Melican?
                Reserves live updates (Twitter)
                Reserves WIKI -
                Top Goalkickers| Best Votegetters

                Comment

                • ugg
                  Can you feel it?
                  Site Admin
                  • Jan 2003
                  • 15970

                  #68
                  Hmm looks like Marsh did his hammy today and they're going to have to fly Laidler back from the NT

                  IN BJack Laidler Newman
                  OUT KJack (hip) Foote Marsh (hamstring)
                  Reserves live updates (Twitter)
                  Reserves WIKI -
                  Top Goalkickers| Best Votegetters

                  Comment

                  • annew
                    Senior Player
                    • Mar 2006
                    • 2164

                    #69
                    Originally posted by ugg
                    Hmm looks like Marsh did his hammy today and they're going to have to fly Laidler back from the NT

                    IN BJack Laidler Newman
                    OUT KJack (hip) Foote Marsh (hamstring)
                    Wondered how you got Laidler wrong cos you are never wrong

                    Comment

                    • ugg
                      Can you feel it?
                      Site Admin
                      • Jan 2003
                      • 15970

                      #70
                      In: A.Silvagni, B.Smedts, N.Graham, M.Kreuzer
                      Out: C.Polson, H.Macreadie (managed), A.Phillips, J.Pickett

                      Emg: M.Talia J.Foote J.Rose
                      Emg: D.Cuningham L.Jones D.Armfield
                      Reserves live updates (Twitter)
                      Reserves WIKI -
                      Top Goalkickers| Best Votegetters

                      Comment

                      • Markwebbos
                        Veterans List
                        • Jul 2016
                        • 7186

                        #71
                        Jack for Jack has a neatness to it. I hope BJ can be put on tackling duty and provide what his brother used to around the ball.

                        Glad to see Foote out Newman in. Would have preferred Aliir to Laidler but I'm prepared to be patient. Hayward stays in ????

                        Comment

                        • Mountain Man
                          Regular in the Side
                          • Feb 2008
                          • 908

                          #72
                          Melican 194
                          Maibaum 193

                          Comment

                          • Meg
                            Go Swannies!
                            Site Admin
                            • Aug 2011
                            • 4828

                            #73
                            Originally posted by ugg
                            Hmm looks like Marsh did his hammy today and they're going to have to fly Laidler back from the NT

                            IN BJack Laidler Newman
                            OUT KJack (hip) Foote Marsh (hamstring)
                            Ha! Laidler's partner put up a photo on Instagram of her dropping off Laidler at the airport this morning! Hope he does plenty of stretching on the flight back.

                            Comment

                            • ugg
                              Can you feel it?
                              Site Admin
                              • Jan 2003
                              • 15970

                              #74
                              Has she since deleted it? I don't see said photo.
                              Reserves live updates (Twitter)
                              Reserves WIKI -
                              Top Goalkickers| Best Votegetters

                              Comment

                              • Foreign Legion
                                Senior Player
                                • Feb 2003
                                • 3368

                                #75
                                I hope they give Brandon Jack at least 2 games. He has been very good in the NEAFL - I know the standard is low but if you keep performing you have to get a chance if you are on the list. I would imagine this is his last chance so he deserves at least 2-3 games to prove himself.

                                Newman is an excellent kick and finds the ball easily - I can't understand why he was dropped in the first place. I'm sorry for the fans, but I don't think Foote will make it. He tries hard for sure but seems a bit below this level.

                                Laidler is handy as he is pretty tall and relatively experienced. Pretty good balance to this side but I hope Aliir has a good game as we need his height, pace and skill back soon.

                                Comment

                                Working...