Match Day Thread Rnd 18 Sydney V St Kilda. SCG. 19.25pm.

[barry]

one game doesn't get him close I'm afraid, get back to us in Round 23 ... next season

But you must see the similarities 09183305?

[Bill Posters]

Sinkers!! How good is he? Later Reid...

[0918330512]

Is it too early to say that "Sinclair is the new Joey daniher"?

Although if he plays like this for the rest of the season he might nab himself a Coleman!

[mcs]

OMG. is Heeney in trouble for that 'dangerous' tackle (as described by the commentators). We will need him against the Hawks next week.

Ridiculous talk from the commentators in my book - nothing in it really. Geary jumped into it to make it much worse than it was. Deserved a standing ovation if you ask me (as did the Mills hit a few minutes later!)

[S.S. Bleeder]

No way. He was 15m out. Have a shot.

Is it too early to say that "Sinclair is the new Joey daniher"?

Shirley you can't be serious. Sinclairs had 3-4 great games in his career. He'll go missing next week.

[Odysseus]

Really pleased with how Sinkers is going tonight. I was happy to see him back for this match, but he is going to be mighty difficult to drop after this performance.

[stevoswan]

Quality inconsistency in the umpiring in the middle - completely ignored the htb against the saints then pinged the swans one two seconds later....

Saw that.....it disgusted me as it's been happening all night. They're hot on us and it's play on when the Saints hold it or drop it. Scumpires......

[S.S. Bleeder]

Towers is soooo frustrating.

[0918330512]

But you must see the similarities 09183305?

Both tall? In all seriousness I think Joe is more athletic, better hands (tonight excepted for Sink - what tacky stuff have they smeared on Cal's hands tonight?!). Both crappy kicks at times (Joe improved this season, Cal improved tonight.

But gotta hand it to Cal, should get his first Brownlow votes tonight

[Faunac8]

While it is early in his FF career it's inspiring to see once again what the Swans coacihng team are able to deliver with the talent provided by the drafting team
Sinclair as a full forward who would have thought ?

[Faunac8]

Great defensive pressure

[S.S. Bleeder]

Newman didn't even flinch when he was trying to get his dislocated finger back in place.

[barry]

There is a lot to be said for sending guys back to the NEAFL , or a rest, to improve their game.

[S.S. Bleeder]

Zak's been very quiet tonight. I hope the cloud over his contract isn't having an impact.

[0918330512]

Zak's been very quiet tonight. I hope the cloud over his contract isn't having an impact.

Nah Sammy & Zac are both doing the team thing & through injury and quiet form simply driving their prices down a little