Round 21: Gold Coast Suns Reserves v Sydney Swans Reserves @ Metricon Stadium

[barry]

Towers and Hayward both greater than Rose.

I think the only 2's that have a chance at seniors this year are Cunningham, Allir and Dawson. Draw a line through the rest

[ugg]

I agree with barry regarding Rose. I don't think he's close to senior selection

However in addition to those 3 named I think Robinson, Laidler and as much as many would disagree Foote would also be on the fringes

[Scottee]

I agree with barry regarding Rose. I don't think he's close to senior selection

However in addition to those 3 named I think Robinson, Laidler and as much as many would disagree Foote would also be on the fringes

What does Rose have to do that he is not doing now to get selected Ugg? On the face if it he is going great guns.

Sent from my SM-T805Y using Tapatalk

[Ludwig]

I agree with barry regarding Rose. I don't think he's close to senior selection

However in addition to those 3 named I think Robinson, Laidler and as much as many would disagree Foote would also be on the fringes

How do we know if Rose would not be better than Towers or Hayward unless we give him a go? Same with Dawson. And if consistent high quality NEAFL form is not a measure of how we make selections for injured our under-performing senior players, then what is?

[Mug Punter]

I would think that Cunningham would be the logical choice to replace Hayward if our match committee feel he isn't hard bodied enough for finals. Quick, strong and plays the lock down role well up forward.

We've got a number of players in the twos making a case for senior selection but ultimately they need to make the senior team better. The only players I can see as being under threat are Towers, Hayward, Newman and one of Sinclair/Tippett.

One thing is for sure, we're going to have a number of players coming back for pre-season training trying to smash it for senior selection - Florent, Dawson, Cameron, Maibaum, Aliir, Robbo and Rose for starters. It's a very very healthy situation for our squad

[Mug Punter]

I would think that Cunningham would be the logical choice to replace Hayward if our match committee feel he isn't hard bodied enough for finals. Quick, strong and plays the lock down role well up forward.

We've got a number of players in the twos making a case for senior selection but ultimately they need to make the senior team better. The only players I can see as being under threat are Towers, Hayward, Newman and one of Sinclair/Tippett.

One thing is for sure, we're going to have a number of players coming back for pre-season training trying to smash it for senior selection - Florent, Dawson, Cameron, Maibaum, Aliir, Robbo and Rose for starters. It's a very very healthy situation for our squad

Add AJ to that list too

[Ludwig]

We are a lock for the premiership this year. We are so good than even a player who is tall, strong, evasive, quick, a great mark, quick decision maker, excellent field kick and kick for goal and can play any position on the ground is not good enough to make the senior side. Lucky for Adam Goodes that he played in a an era when the Swans needed a player like that, otherwise he would have spent his career in the NEAFL.

[Markwebbos]

We are a lock for the premiership this year. We are so good than even a player who is tall, strong, evasive, quick, a great mark, quick decision maker, excellent field kick and kick for goal and can play any position on the ground is not good enough to make the senior side. Lucky for Adam Goodes that he played in a an era when the Swans needed a player like that, otherwise he would have spent his career in the NEAFL.

Can't guess who you are referring to.

[Dosser]

Can't guess who you are referring to.

Why is he talking up Talia?

[rb4x]

Sounds like Dawson

[barry]

BJ I assumed

[ugg]

MATCH REPORT: Sydney starves off brave Gold Coast to clinch minor premiership – NEAFL

I'm all for doing whatever is necessary to win but I draw the line at depriving the opposition of food.

[ugg]

Florent injured shoulder

[ugg]

ugg has there been a correction in the match report?

I've only just read the report so I wouldn't be aware of any previous mistakes. What are you referring to?

[rb4x]

I assumed that starved had been changed to to staved in the body of report. Missed the headline.