AFLX Is anyone going?
Collapse
X
-
-
I can't imagine there'll be a big crowd there. Maybe the Melbourne one will attract a decent crowd, given it features six clubs with tribal histories, all based close by. But hard to see anyone travelling from SE Queensland or Melbourne up to Sydney for this. It's even hard to see many tripping up the M4.Comment
-
"Fortunately, this is the internet, so knowing nothing is no obstacle to having an opinion!." Beerman 18-07-2017Comment
-
In contrast, AFL already has a convenient duration. Reducing it to two ten minute halves, to me, just makes it trivial and largely pointless. Also, if you go to the venue and want to see all your team's games, you'll have to sit through games, in which your team isn't involved. Which seems to be introducing quite a few dull bits.Comment
-
Star Swan may lead from the back in AFLX - AFL.com.au
Here's some news about the players we're likely to see (and those we won't) in the AFLX.
Although I'm lukewarm about the concept, it will be a chance to see how some of the younger guys go without the senior blokes around. Even where the newbies get a chance in the NAB thingy (or whatever it's called nowadays), they're usually just bit part players. There'll be nowhere to hide in the AFLX, so anyone who does get a gig will have to pull their weight.
One player I hope we see a bit of is James Rose. Last pre-season he seemed to be running laps on his own for pretty much the entire three months (and with an obvious lack of enthusiasm). When I dropped along to watch a bit of training last week, he was involved with the main group and his ability to spot - and hit - a target 50m away on the "fat side" of the ground was a highlight. If he's improved his fitness and can up his work rate, I think he could be a surprise packet for us this season and I'd love to get an early glimpse of him in the AFLX.Comment
-
Interesting observation aboute Rose. I was a big fan a couple of years ago when I saw him play a NEAFL game (pre senior debut) and he looked a class above.
Seems to have gone backwards since his stunning debut quarter so really hoping it clicks for him this year, or it's delisting time.Comment
-
There's talk of McCartin being picked. If so, I wonder if this is because Buddy will be sitting it out. Tom is no Buddy but he will bring his own excitement. Apparently JPK is also not going to play.
If we substitute McCartin for Buddy and omit JPK, who should we pick?
I'm thinking: Rampe, Melican, Lloyd, Parker, Hanners, Papley, Towers (for his rucking!), McCartin, Rohan and Heeney. Jeez, that was harder than I expected. A lot of people left out. Can't believe Towers made the cut but I didn't want to select an actual ruckman. Aliir a real alternative option. What do others think? I can't believe nobody else has had a ping at selecting a team yet!All opinions are not equal. Some are a very great deal more robust, sophisticated, and well supported in logic and argument than others. -Douglas Adams, author (11 Mar 1952-2001)Comment
-
The article on the AFL site, quoted above, states that few of the senior players will play. It also says Heeney won't play (which isn't surprising, given he recently had knee surgery).
I can't see Hanners playing. I think he's on the sidelines at the moment. I'd also be surprised if Rohan were available, given his recent pre-season history.
There's no reason to pick just one team, either. I think they can involve different players in the two matches. I'd certainly like to see more of the fringe players get a chance. I mentioned Rose above, but Dawson, Aliir, Cameron, COR are others on the cusp of senior consideration who I'd love to get an early 2018 glimpse of. And it would be good to see how Hewett goes as the main man in the centre without Kennedy there. He also looked very sharp at training last week.Comment
-
Didn't read the article (clearly). I still like the team I selected although concede in what you have pointed out it's not going to be the one that runs out.
Yes, I'd like to see COR. Also players like Dawson, Newman, Aliir, maybe even Ronke out of our young talent team.All opinions are not equal. Some are a very great deal more robust, sophisticated, and well supported in logic and argument than others. -Douglas Adams, author (11 Mar 1952-2001)Comment
Comment