If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Gaz has had, and is having, quite a hard enough time at the minute.
I'm hoping the fires at Cobden haven't impacted his family's property.
Anyone know?
Gaz has had, and is having, quite a hard enough time at the minute.
I'm hoping the fires at Cobden haven't impacted his family's property.
Anyone know?
Gaz has had, and is having, quite a hard enough time at the minute.
I'm hoping the fires at Cobden haven't impacted his family's property.
Anyone know?
I took the word over a facebooker, rather than a trusted RWOer.
Should have done my own research.
Missing this week to stay in Sydney with his wife, who is in the final stages of her pregnancy. Good luck to them both and the little one, of course they are having twins but only one will survive due to some issue with it. It will be a bittersweet time for them. ......I think the pending birth made the selectors job easier, I'm not sure Gary would have been picked this week.......
Last edited by stevoswan; 23 March 2018, 06:44 PM.
I presume you?re not just talking about physically fit. There have been a number of circumstances where physically fit players have justifiably missed games (Buddy, Goodsey, Macca) and few would have begrudged them their absences.
In many work places, a spouse will miss a period of work when their partner gives birth.
Wasn?t suggesting he should have played this week; more that When he?s fit he plays. There was no other conundrum for the selectors as Steve suggested there might be.
Wasn?t suggesting he should have played this week; more that When he?s fit he plays. There was no other conundrum for the selectors as Steve suggested there might be.
You may be right about the 'conundrum' but I thought Haywood might get in ahead of Gary even though neither showed great preseason form. Haywood didn't get in anyway but Florent and Fox are ahead of Rohan on current form and all the other positions pretty much write themselves. The team looks pretty balanced to me.
I would say if fit and in form, he's a lock but he has to earn it like anyone else. We all know how good he can be but consistency has been a millstone to his progression to dependable star, which he should be....by now. I love him but history is slowly stacking up against him.
You may be right about the 'conundrum' but I thought Haywood might get in ahead of Gary even though neither showed great preseason form. Haywood didn't get in anyway but Florent and Fox are ahead of Rohan on current form and all the other positions pretty much write themselves. The team looks pretty balanced to me.
I would say if fit and in form, he's a lock but he has to earn it like anyone else. We all know how good he can be but consistency has been a millstone to his progression to dependable star, which he should be....by now. I love him but history is slowly stacking up against him.
My guess is that the selectors value him more highly than you do for his chasing and pressure. It's not just about stats - not even smothers, tackles, etc. Part of his value is how quickly he moves to close space for defenders trying to find a target out of the forward 50.
I think Rohan and Hayward are both in our best 22 when fit and available. Hayward hasn't had much of a pre-season, and is still very young (and skinny) so I don't have an issue with them leaving him out of the team until he's ready. But when he is, I think he'll come into the team.
I don't mind the team that has been picked in terms of the individual players. They are all highly capable. But balance wise it doesn't look quite right. Newman, Fox, Cunningham, McVeigh - all have played most of their recent football or have been training this off-season as half-back flankers. When you add them to Mills and Lloyd, that's a lot of players for that part of the ground. The selectors' hands were tied a bit this week, particularly with Rohan's unavailability, but I'll be curious to see how they structure the team. We just have Franklin and Reid as full-time forwards, with Jack and Papley likely to rotate between the forward line and the midfield. Maybe both will spend more time in the forward line this week than they will normally. Maybe Mills will get to spend a bit of time in the midfield. But one of more of those medium sized defenders is going to need to spend time forward as well, or we'll have an exceedingly crowded defence.
Well, Gary has finally made it to 100 games.....an achievement of application and persistence through some immense professional and life challenges, the latter and biggest only recently. Well done Gary......have a blinder on Saturday.
Comment