Current Injury Status

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • S.S. Bleeder
    Senior Player
    • Sep 2014
    • 2165

    Team List Current Injury Status

    I thought that this thread already existed but can't find it. Giving our current injuries to our significant players I feel that it needs to be discussed and assessed.

    As I have it the list is something like this:
    Mills Foot Season
    Naismith Knee Season
    Ling Toe Season
    McVeigh Collarbone 8-10 weeks.
    Jack Knee TBA
    Tom Papley Hip 1-2 weeks
    Gary Rohan Hamstring TBA
    Riley Stoddart Concussion Test
    Isaac Heeney Concussion Test

    It looks like McVeigh is effectively gone for the season. He has been great this season. I hope the club don't consider him for next season; it's time to move on and give our youth a chance.

    My feelings are the same in regards to Jack, however, he has another season on his contract (go figure). Jacks been poor for the the last couple of years.

    In regards to our premiership chances for this season I feel that McVeigh and Mills are our biggest losses. Sinclair seems to b covering Naismith but if Sinclair gets injured we're screwed.
    Last edited by S.S. Bleeder; 6 July 2018, 06:56 PM.
  • KSAS
    Senior Player
    • Mar 2018
    • 1763

    #2
    McVeigh Collarbone 8-10 weeks.
    Jack Knee TBA
    Tom Papley Hip 1-2 weeks

    Tom Harley on the Swans website has estimated McVeigh will be out for 6 weeks (had surgery today & plate inserted). He also hasn't ruled out Jack for next game against North (10 day break) having a grade 1 medial knee ligament strain.

    I was hoping Papely would be available for next game.

    Also heard Hannebery is out for 3 weeks with that calf injury.

    Sizeable injury list now, but still have faith we can recover & hit finals in form.
    Time to reward Dawson & O'Riordan who have shown form in the NEAFL.

    Comment

    • RogueSwan
      McVeigh for Brownlow
      • Apr 2003
      • 4602

      #3
      Reid - achilles soreness
      "Fortunately, this is the internet, so knowing nothing is no obstacle to having an opinion!." Beerman 18-07-2017

      Comment

      • CureTheSane
        Carpe Noctem
        • Jan 2003
        • 5032

        #4
        Originally posted by RogueSwan
        Reid - achilles soreness
        lol
        I'm surprised that there are still people around who think he will be able to endure more than a few games without injury.
        I called it when we traded White.

        Right now
        Hanners >>> Reid
        The difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.

        Comment

        • barry
          Veterans List
          • Jan 2003
          • 8499

          #5
          Hanners was obviously carrying an injury, whether it was OP or whatever. When you are nursing an injury, your body over compensates in other areas, causing more injury.
          No surprise he's now hurt his calf.

          There is no scenario, where playing him benefits the swans or him. Poor list management.

          Comment

          • neilfws
            Senior Player
            • Aug 2009
            • 1818

            #6
            Originally posted by RogueSwan
            Reid - achilles soreness
            Worse than soreness:

            Sydney Swans on Twitter: "Longmire: Reid is having an achillies operation so he will miss about six weeks at this stage."

            and:

            Sydney Swans on Twitter: "Longmire on Reid: This is the other leg but the same operation in terms of his achillies."

            He's great when he's on the park, but he's never on the park. Just one of those players, unfortunately.

            Comment

            • CureTheSane
              Carpe Noctem
              • Jan 2003
              • 5032

              #7
              See I never thought he was great when he was on the park.
              At times he was very good, but most of the time he was just there, not much better than say McCartin is at the moment.
              Maybe that's just my interpretation...
              The difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.

              Comment

              • MattW
                Veterans List
                • May 2011
                • 4193

                #8
                Originally posted by neilfws
                Unbelievable.

                Comment

                • Plugger1300
                  Warming the Bench
                  • Feb 2010
                  • 310

                  #9
                  Reid is sooo important to our structure
                  People who think that he has to touch the ball 5 + times a qtr or kick 3 goals a game
                  are missing the point
                  At the moment we are robbing peter to pay Paul
                  Parker shouldn't be spending that much time forward

                  If Reid is there Buddy can roam
                  Parker can play in the middle
                  Changes us completely as side

                  McCartin will be a gun but he doesn't have the experience of Reid
                  Nor does his opponent have to pay him the same respect

                  Sad times

                  Comment

                  • MattW
                    Veterans List
                    • May 2011
                    • 4193

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Plugger1300
                    Reid is sooo important to our structure
                    People who think that he has to touch the ball 5 + times a qtr or kick 3 goals a game
                    are missing the point
                    At the moment we are robbing peter to pay Paul
                    Parker shouldn't be spending that much time forward

                    If Reid is there Buddy can roam
                    Parker can play in the middle
                    Changes us completely as side

                    McCartin will be a gun but he doesn't have the experience of Reid
                    Nor does his opponent have to pay him the same respect

                    Sad times
                    Yep, time to bite the bullet and see how it looks with Cameron up there too.

                    Comment

                    • mcs
                      Travelling Swannie!!
                      • Jul 2007
                      • 8149

                      #11
                      Originally posted by CureTheSane
                      See I never thought he was great when he was on the park.
                      At times he was very good, but most of the time he was just there, not much better than say McCartin is at the moment.
                      Maybe that's just my interpretation...
                      The issue is McCartin doesn't have the goals in him (yet) that Reid can provide - we are making up somewhat for that by playing him a fair way up the ground. He is doing a great job all things considered, but a fit Reid would have been a huge asset going into the last part of the season.

                      Sadly he is made of tissue paper it seems and just can't stay fit
                      "You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."

                      Comment

                      • Markwebbos
                        Veterans List
                        • Jul 2016
                        • 7186

                        #12
                        Also Melican having surgery and out for 2 months.

                        - - - Updated - - -

                        Originally posted by Plugger1300
                        Reid is sooo important to our structure
                        People who think that he has to touch the ball 5 + times a qtr or kick 3 goals a game
                        are missing the point
                        At the moment we are robbing peter to pay Paul
                        Parker shouldn't be spending that much time forward

                        If Reid is there Buddy can roam
                        Parker can play in the middle
                        Changes us completely as side

                        McCartin will be a gun but he doesn't have the experience of Reid
                        Nor does his opponent have to pay him the same respect

                        Sad times
                        Parker was playing forward in the absence of Heeney and Rohan, both of whom can play as marking targets. Hopefully at least one comes back this week

                        Comment

                        • Hotpotato
                          Senior Player
                          • Jun 2014
                          • 2261

                          #13
                          Just give the youngsters more time in the Ones for the last 8 games, go out and enjoy themselves not worrying about the result .

                          They might be headed to Randwick (see other post) but they are simply not in the race, they are compounding even before the turn .

                          Comment

                          • CureTheSane
                            Carpe Noctem
                            • Jan 2003
                            • 5032

                            #14
                            Originally posted by Plugger1300
                            Reid is sooo important to our structure
                            People who think that he has to touch the ball 5 + times a qtr or kick 3 goals a game
                            are missing the point
                            Rubbish.
                            Maybe missing your point.
                            I don't care if he gets 3 goals a game, but if you think 5 touches is enough, there is a point that you are missing.
                            Yes, I understand you point, I just don't agree.
                            Maybe my expectation of a senior AFL player are higher.

                            Originally posted by Plugger1300
                            McCartin will be a gun but he doesn't have the experience of Reid
                            Nor does his opponent have to pay him the same respect
                            Just wondering how McCartin gets that experience?
                            Send him hack to the NEAFL?
                            The difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.

                            Comment

                            • CureTheSane
                              Carpe Noctem
                              • Jan 2003
                              • 5032

                              #15
                              Originally posted by mcs
                              The issue is McCartin doesn't have the goals in him (yet) that Reid can provide
                              Debatable.
                              Compare 2018 stats for Reid vs McCartin
                              Not sure how many goals Reid will provide from here on...
                              The difference between insanity and genius is measured only in success.

                              Comment

                              Working...