Best 22 for 2019

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • longmile
    Crumber
    • Apr 2011
    • 3362

    #31
    everyone keeps forgetting smith!

    Comment

    • Cainit
      On the Rookie List
      • Jul 2017
      • 42

      #32
      Smith is overrated Florent will take his spot...

      Comment

      • longmile
        Crumber
        • Apr 2011
        • 3362

        #33
        Originally posted by Cainit
        Smith is overrated Florent will take his spot...
        ??? Whoa. Maybe Cunningham who has some experience tagging players could, but theyre not even the same kind of player. The fact you think Smith is overrated is bizarre. When was the last time a small forward went to town against the Swans with Smith in the team? I can't think of any small forwards having 4+ bags against us in recent years.


        On another note I think we can play Reid/Naismith/Sinclair in the same team. With Reid a permanent forward and Sinclair to play 70% forward and 30% ruck. I think Reid and Sinclair are mobile enough for this too happen. Does anyone know if Naismith should be right to go come round 1?

        Comment

        • Cainit
          On the Rookie List
          • Jul 2017
          • 42

          #34
          Let me just clarify Smith is a good player but we need speed out of defence and I think a defence with Smith Grundy and McVeigh in it can absorb attack but cant get it out quick enough to counter attack anymore.
          I think we need to by like the Hawks and maybe put these old guys on ice while our young brigade gels together. Mcartin Allir Florent Llyod Melican Rampe is exciting to me as a backline.

          Comment

          • 111431
            Regular in the Side
            • Sep 2010
            • 697

            #35
            Originally posted by AB Swannie
            You are probably right but I'm not sure if he'll be there round 1. I am also unconvinced about Naismith. It's obvious that the club thinks very highly of him giving him 3 more years during an ACL reco but apart from being really tall I don't see it.
            I’m with you on that - he is a good tap ruckman and not much else

            Comment

            • MattW
              Veterans List
              • May 2011
              • 4195

              #36
              Originally posted by 111431
              I’m with you on that - he is a good tap ruckman and not much else
              He's only played 28 games. Give him a chance.

              Comment

              • Markwebbos
                Veterans List
                • Jul 2016
                • 7186

                #37
                Swans have a lot of eggs in the Naismith basket

                Comment

                • Bloody Hell
                  Senior Player
                  • Oct 2006
                  • 3085

                  #38
                  Rampe to the midfield.

                  Mills to the midfield.

                  Jones to the midfield.
                  The eternal connundrum "what happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object" was finally solved when David Hasselhoff punched himself in the face.

                  Comment

                  • Plugger46
                    Senior Player
                    • Apr 2003
                    • 3674

                    #39
                    Originally posted by AB Swannie
                    You are probably right but I'm not sure if he'll be there round 1. I am also unconvinced about Naismith. It's obvious that the club thinks very highly of him giving him 3 more years during an ACL reco but apart from being really tall I don't see it.
                    I'm convinced he'll be there if fit but I agree on him as a player. Clearly a better tap ruckman than Sinclair but he doesn't do much around the ground.
                    Bloods

                    "Lockett is the best of all time" - Robert Harvey, Darrel Baldock, Nathan Burke, Kevin Bartlett, Bob Skilton

                    Comment

                    • caj23
                      Senior Player
                      • Aug 2003
                      • 2462

                      #40
                      Originally posted by MattW
                      He's only played 28 games. Give him a chance.
                      He's not 21 though, he's 26 the same age as Max Gawn

                      Comment

                      • gazza
                        Warming the Bench
                        • Mar 2005
                        • 329

                        #41
                        3 new recruits for 2019 Naismith mills reid
                        forgotten 1996
                        2005 a much sweeter memory,2012 even better

                        Comment

                        • Captain
                          Captain of the Side
                          • Feb 2004
                          • 3602

                          #42
                          Originally posted by caj23
                          He's not 21 though, he's 26 the same age as Max Gawn
                          Yes, this is the concern!

                          Though the Eagles showed this year, having a B Grade (by that I mean a non top tier) ruckman doesn't stop you winning the premiership.

                          Comment

                          • caj23
                            Senior Player
                            • Aug 2003
                            • 2462

                            #43
                            I think there are two key issues with our rucks next year:

                            1. Does Naismith's tap work offset his inability to impact around the ground; and
                            2. Is Sinclair capable of impacting playing predominately as a forward

                            The MC clearly intend to play two rucks, and the new rules should help with that. I think it can work but I guess we'll see

                            Comment

                            • Markwebbos
                              Veterans List
                              • Jul 2016
                              • 7186

                              #44
                              Originally posted by caj23
                              I think there are two key issues with our rucks next year:

                              1. Does Naismith's tap work offset his inability to impact around the ground; and
                              2. Is Sinclair capable of impacting playing predominately as a forward

                              The MC clearly intend to play two rucks, and the new rules should help with that. I think it can work but I guess we'll see
                              Sinkers has a good tank, but isn't quite good enough as a ruckman. I don't know how much running Naismith can do in the offseason to help with that.

                              Comment

                              • caj23
                                Senior Player
                                • Aug 2003
                                • 2462

                                #45
                                Originally posted by Markwebbos
                                Sinkers has a good tank, but isn't quite good enough as a ruckman. I don't know how much running Naismith can do in the offseason to help with that.

                                They'll share the duties, thus neither will need that huge tank that a solo ruckman would need

                                Comment

                                Working...