Past players - what are they up to?

[Mel_C]

I saw the photo in the Herald Sun and it was nice to see. I'm glad there's no bad blood even though some of Rohan's comments have been contradictory.

[ugg]

Hannebery made his debut for Sandy in the VFL today. Had 24 disposals in 3 quarters

[dimelb]

Hannebery made his debut for Sandy in the VFL today. Had 24 disposals in 3 quarters

Pleased to hear that. I'd hate to see him leave the game because he was injured. And good luck to him and his team of strugglers, except when we play them.

[Captain]

Really wish we had kept Rohan.

[barry]

Really wish we had kept Rohan.

I think Geelong got a glimpse of Rohans form in a pressure game last weekend.

Even though they are 2 games clear, I'm not convinced they can win the flag.

[Blood Fever]

I think Geelong got a glimpse of Rohans form in a pressure game last weekend.

Even though they are 2 games clear, I'm not convinced they can win the flag.

Agree with this. Their young players will drop off and Scott's finals record is very ordinary post 2011 where he inherited a champion team.

[Odysseus]

I think Geelong got a glimpse of Rohans form in a pressure game last weekend.

Even though they are 2 games clear, I'm not convinced they can win the flag.

I'm sorry to agree with you Barry , but I do. Rohan's GF form doesn't give confidence in his contribution, and, as far as the team, I think that there are other teams that are pacing their run better than is Geelong. They're not handed a premiership just because they may be two games clear ahead at the bye.

[Markwebbos]

One thing the Cats have got going for them is that most of the time they play Dangerfield and Selwood away from the centre bounces. When they actually do play them in there, as they did against us at the start of the third quarter, it gives them another gear.

[MattW]

I think Geelong got a glimpse of Rohans form in a pressure game last weekend.

Even though they are 2 games clear, I'm not convinced they can win the flag.

I also agree, I think it's a pretty poor standard comp this year and Geelong's standing is more a reflection of that.

Reckon Collingwood, West Coast, GWS and Richmond are the preliminary finalists.

[Odysseus]

One thing the Cats have got going for them is that most of the time they play Dangerfield and Selwood away from the centre bounces. When they actually do play them in there, as they did against us at the start of the third quarter, it gives them another gear.

Fair point.

[stevoswan]

I also agree, I think it's a pretty poor standard comp this year and Geelong's standing is more a reflection of that.

Reckon Collingwood, West Coast, GWS and Richmond are the preliminary finalists.

I tend to agree with that assessment.....and the four preliminary finalists. Maybe Geelong might make it in place of Richmond if their was any change to it.

[liz]

Since AJ is one of three recent ex-players who already has his own dedicated thread, I've moved posts about him in here to that thread, just to keep the AJ conversation in one place.

[barry]

I tend to agree with that assessment.....and the four preliminary finalists. Maybe Geelong might make it in place of Richmond if their was any change to it.

I think Geelong, WC and GWS are the likely prelims, with one more spot up for grabs.

Could be Brisbane, if they dont petter out in the second half of the year.
Dont think it will be Collingwood. There glory run is ending, and beams is out for the year.
Dont think it will be Richmond. Good effort by tiges, but 5th is where they are at.
Could be Freo, just need a bit of consistency.
Dont think any of the others can make it.

[Markwebbos]

Since AJ is one of three recent ex-players who already has his own dedicated thread, I've moved posts about him in here to that thread, just to keep the AJ conversation in one place.

Thanks Liz

[bloodspirit]

I tend to agree with that assessment.....and the four preliminary finalists. Maybe Geelong might make it in place of Richmond if their was any change to it.

I disagree. I think Geelong is the real deal and will be a preliminary finalist. Not willing to predict more than that though, especially not this far out. My mate and my main disagreement in the pre-season about which teams would play finals involved me picking Geelong and he Essendon. I was pretty confident Geelong would go alright this year although I'm less confident about the seasons to come.