Changes for R6 v GWS

[stevoswan]

Well, with Buddy out it will be good practice to learn how to score without him......or it could mean we just score 5 goals for the match instead of 8.

BTW, I wonder which team announced their change first and if the second announcement made in reaction to the first? It appears Davis was out then the Swans decided to rest Buddy.....wonder what his issue is? Groin?

[liz]

Bizarre suggestion. Do you really think the Swans would “rest” Buddy just because Davis is out? (Or vice versa?)

[Markwebbos]

So all those talls were because Buddy was in doubt!

[dejavoodoo44]

Davis is out but so is Buddy! Ronke and Buntine in

Bit disappointed that you didn't do the, 'do you want the good news, or do you want the bad news?' routine.

[stevoswan]

Bizarre suggestion. Do you really think the Swans would “rest” Buddy just because Davis is out? (Or vice versa?)

I didn't suggest it....I asked a question. I was after discussion, not a scolding....and certainly with Davis doubtful in the lead up, they may well have rested him knowing Buddy wasn't playing. Do you think the Giants actually believe we could beat them without Buddy or even with him? I doubt it.

[ugg]

I didn't suggest it....I asked a question. I was after discussion, not a scolding.

Both teams submit their team sheets at the same time.

[stevoswan]

Both teams submit their team sheets at the same time.

Thank you ugg....

[caj23]

This discussion about 'lumbering talls' overlooks that Blakey would be in the top 6 fastest players in this 22.

As Longmile says, another tall back is necessary given the Giants' forward line. Melican is really the only option given Grundy and Maibaum are out.

One possession between Blakey and Melican to quarter time

[MattW]

One possession between Blakey and Melican to quarter time

Took some pleasure out of that one?

[Ruck'n'Roll]

Well, with Buddy out it will be good practice to learn how to score without him......or it could mean we just score 5 goals for the match instead of 8.

No appreciable reduction in scoring, just more contributors.

[caj23]

Took some pleasure out of that one?

No need to, dodgy selections from the MC are regular occurrences now.

This weeks were just so blindingly obvious