Fan of both but the SCG wicket has a unique character and gives wrist spinners a go , and is famous all round the cricket world because of it.Drop in pitches don't have this character and if you look at the revenue the AFL is not that far ahead of cricket to justify any change. The wicket should be heritage listed !!
SCG - a cricket ground
Collapse
X
-
Wild speculation, unsubstantiated rumours, silly jokes and opposition delight in another's failures is what makes an internet forum fun.
Blessed are the cracked for they are the ones who let in the light.Comment
-
Comment
-
Barry was right....
"The renovation of the SCG, which Cavalier oversaw, did not leave a vehicle entry wide enough to import the drop-ins used in Melbourne and Adelaide. Snookered!"
Comment
-
Last two tests at the SCG Australia scored 538/8 dec and 650/7 dec. This is the sort of exciting cricket people love, apparently.Comment
-
Comment
-
That's not the case with the new Perth pitches. The technology is improving. The Melbourne pitches have used inferior technology, but will be evolving to the better technology. The technological aspects are described here: MCG drop-in pitch to be upgraded to Perth standard | ESPNcricinfo.com.
I was against a drop in pitch until I saw Longmire's comments earlier this year, having read that article last December.Comment
-
AFL doesn't have a divine right that supersedes the traditions of a national sport played in every state.That's not the case with the new Perth pitches. The technology is improving. The Melbourne pitches have used inferior technology, but will be evolving to the better technology. The technological aspects are described here: MCG drop-in pitch to be upgraded to Perth standard | ESPNcricinfo.com.
I was against a drop in pitch until I saw Longmire's comments earlier this year, having read that article last December.Comment
-
Thanks for that pretty sneaky for sure but it is after all the Cricket Ground so I suspect they have a certain proprietary feeling about it.Barry was right....
"The renovation of the SCG, which Cavalier oversaw, did not leave a vehicle entry wide enough to import the drop-ins used in Melbourne and Adelaide. Snookered!"
https://www.smh.com.au/sport/soul-pa...05-p524fs.htmlComment
-
Comment
-
Don't reckon it can.be retained. Despite my affinity with the Swans, a minor sport in Sydney shouldn't be making demands on a national and historically significant icon, in my opinion.Comment
-
Rugby League was played there for almost 100 years and then AFL. Never been a problem to prepare the wicket which has had a unique character. People not into cricket would not appreciate significance of the ground and the wicket. Cricket is far more popular than AFL.in NSW and the SCG.is the home of cricket in that state.Comment

Comment