Changes for Round 17 - Carlton

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • waswan
    Senior Player
    • Oct 2015
    • 2047

    #76
    A proven player in the 2s is all aboit getting thru a game unscathed and with run
    He isnt there to dominate
    Unproven players need to dominate to earn a call up
    No one is expected Mcveigh to get it 40 times, just get thru a game

    Comment

    • Blood Fever
      Veterans List
      • Apr 2007
      • 4051

      #77
      Originally posted by waswan
      A proven player in the 2s is all aboit getting thru a game unscathed and with run
      He isnt there to dominate
      Unproven players need to dominate to earn a call up
      No one is expected Mcveigh to get it 40 times, just get thru a game
      Fair comment but McVeigh has shown he is still up to it in the ones whereas Kieren has struggled there for a while

      Comment

      • Ralph Dawg
        Senior Player
        • Apr 2018
        • 1729

        #78
        I like Jack, but his best days are well and truly over. Macca is at the end of his career too but injuries aside, still makes significant contributions when fit. I agree if Macca gets through today's game and looks ok, consider for ones. Jack in my eyes needs to prove he's still up to the standard because other then the game v GWS last year, I haven't seen too much evidence to suggest he is since 2016.

        Comment

        • MattW
          Veterans List
          • May 2011
          • 4231

          #79
          Originally posted by Nico
          Particularly given that McVeigh is coming back in via the 2's. First time this has happened, yet Jack by all reports has been average in the 2's. Would have thought McVeigh was a better option. MattW; I didn't say Stoddart was a small forward. If you read my previous post on Stoddart I advocated he play on the wing.
          Sorry Nico, missed that.

          Comment

          • Markwebbos
            Veterans List
            • Jul 2016
            • 7186

            #80
            Maybe Kizza will play a defensive role now that Clarke is out of the side?

            Comment

            • waswan
              Senior Player
              • Oct 2015
              • 2047

              #81
              Agree should be last year for both
              Also belueve both deserves games in merit and fitness.
              If Kizza does twice as much as Rose and Ronke last week combined we will say he has ahad a bad game.
              Im all for playing kids but not ones that dont perfom.
              Also reckon we should be playing them in position too

              Comment

              • Ralph Dawg
                Senior Player
                • Apr 2018
                • 1729

                #82
                Originally posted by waswan
                Agree should be last year for both
                Also belueve both deserves games in merit and fitness.
                If Kizza does twice as much as Rose and Ronke last week combined we will say he has ahad a bad game.
                Im all for playing kids but not ones that dont perfom.
                Also reckon we should be playing them in position too
                I can live with that waswan. But Rose has actually been pretty good of late so KJ in for Ronke would've made more sense to me. I'll confess, I didn't notice that Rose wasn't putting in effort watching it on TV but he does have a lovely set shot, unlike the Ronke, Papley and Hayward who all have the yips atm.

                Comment

                Working...