If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
I don't know that they should be playing, but it's given me and Stella Jr a sense of normality and happiness in all this weirdness this weekend.
I knew him as a gentle young man, I cannot say for sure the reasons for his decline
We watched him fade before our very eyes, and years before his time
Lucky to hold on as we run out of gas towards the end, but a win is a win. And I liked some of what we saw in the middle two quarters. Naismith showed that he can play a very good role for us - just need to keep him fit!
"You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."
After the not 15 call against the Gray mark and the run down by Lloyd paid the wrong way and the 50 meters. A probable 2 goal turn around we didn't score a goal.
Ok. I'll put my hand up and say the Crayfish made a big difference. More of a contest at the tap but a much better physical presence at stoppages than Sinclair. Aliir more than capable to give a chop out. Can't see where Sinclair fits in the team.
We need consistency in uncertain times. Rubbish umpiring it seems will not even be stopped by Corona
I was thinking about the umpiring, summarizing that the lack of home crowd should even things up.....but also thought our game will be a test to see if they simply don't like us. We won the count 21-18 but I suppose it can come down to where they're paid and in what situation. As I didn't watch, I can't judge but from what you said, it seems maybe they still don't like us.....
I was thinking about the umpiring, summarizing that the lack of home crowd should even things up.....but also thought our game will be a test to see if they simply don't like us. We won the count 21-18 but I suppose it can come down to where they're paid and in what situation. As I didn't watch, I can't judge but from what you said, it seems maybe they still don't like us.....
My comment wasn't so much that the umpiring wasn't one sided - more that they just pull some horrendous calls out of their butt, corona virus or no corona virus. When you see the replay of the Lloyd one (which did swing momentum) you'll see a perfect example of a poor call.
On broader themes, very good to see Naismith do a decent job, and it made a huge difference to our work in the clearances. Florent in particular looked buzzing in and around the ball, and Rowbottom/Kennedy did well. Heeney up forward did some great stuff. Brand and Gray (Despite his kicking) did a lot right, so some good signs there too. And McInerney showed some signs that his progress has continued over the summer.
Yes it was only Radelaide and they will finish in the bottom half a dozen imho, but not a bad run out - despite the strangeness of it all.
My comment wasn't so much that the umpiring wasn't one sided - more that they just pull some horrendous calls out of their butt, corona virus or no corona virus. When you see the replay of the Lloyd one (which did swing momentum) you'll see a perfect example of a poor call.
I think some umpires just like to make games 'dramatic' and get caught up in 'meddling' to create that drama. They're certainly not 100% impartial......ever.
I think some umpires just like to make games 'dramatic' and get caught up in 'meddling' to create that drama. They're certainly not 100% impartial......ever.
It was a terrible call. Then to pay 50...
One hopes they have to replay and review it during the week. Would be hard to watch.
He had observed that people who did lie were, on the whole, more resourceful and ambitious and successful than people who did not lie.
Comment