West Coast won it, hands down, didn't they. They got a premiership-winning, multiple AA and Coleman medallist full forward who has sustained excellence for over a decade. Judd was a great player, but Carlton got a marketing exercise. Typical of everything that's gone wrong at Carlton for the past 20 years.
Round 13: the other games. Thursday, Buckley, Freezy.
Collapse
X
-
-
West Coast won it, hands down, didn't they. They got a premiership-winning, multiple AA and Coleman medallist full forward who has sustained excellence for over a decade. Judd was a great player, but Carlton got a marketing exercise. Typical of everything that's gone wrong at Carlton for the past 20 years.Comment
-
I couldnt agree more. Only the melbourne media could spin that the Judd/Kennedy trade was even close to 50/50. For starters, WC got Kennedy for his whole career, rather than the tail end of Judds career, and they still had Judd when they won in 2006, so he delivered twice. Carlton got screwed badly.
Carlton (a Brownlow, 3 B&F, 4 AA). I remember a game at the SCG where he beat us singlehandedly. At his peak he was scary
good. West Coast have got more years out of Kennedy, but would he have been as good at Carlton had he stayed?
No one will ever know.Comment
-
I think both teams got players that wanted to return home, that wanted to play where they ended up. Judd was very good at
Carlton (a Brownlow, 3 B&F, 4 AA). I remember a game at the SCG where he beat us singlehandedly. At his peak he was scary
good. West Coast have got more years out of Kennedy, but would he have been as good at Carlton had he stayed?
No one will ever know.
Kennedy's recruitment was an essential pillar of WCE's construction of a premiership team. And before his career ends, they may sneak another. It's no disrespect to Judd to say it is no contest.'Delicious' is a fun word to sayComment
-
They don't put in regularly enough. Yesterday at the SCG proved yet again the gap between 1st and last is very little, and if you are off
5% or slack off just a tiny bit and the other team doesn't then you will lose. There are challenges being based where they are. I'm sure
some of them feel a bit out of the footy loop. But Brisbane in the early 2000s proved a vaguely talented bunch with a gale force superiority
complex and a ruthless coach can go a long way whilst being out of the southern states bubble.
- - - Updated - - -
- - - Updated - - -
I couldnt agree more. Only the melbourne media could spin that the Judd/Kennedy trade was even close to 50/50. For starters, WC got Kennedy for his whole career, rather than the tail end of Judds career, and they still had Judd when they won in 2006, so he delivered twice. Carlton got screwed badly.Comment
-
If the trade hadn’t happened would it have changed the fortunes of the two clubs? I don’t think significantly soComment
-
I think both teams got players that wanted to return home, that wanted to play where they ended up. Judd was very good at
Carlton (a Brownlow, 3 B&F, 4 AA). I remember a game at the SCG where he beat us singlehandedly. At his peak he was scary
good. West Coast have got more years out of Kennedy, but would he have been as good at Carlton had he stayed?
No one will ever know.Comment
-
trade occurred and for a number of years after the consensus was that Carlton were the "winner" of that trade. The fact that Kennedy was a
top 10 draft pick himself meant that he wasn't exactly a bag of chips as many referred to him at the time. But he did struggle at Carlton and
spent a lot of time there in the twos and ultimately was keen to return to WA. Likewise Judd was keen to move back to Melbourne.
What gets forgotten sometimes in discussions of trades is what the players themselves actually want and that goes a long way in
influencing what trades can actually occur in the first place. Sometimes a player can "win" in a trade even if the club they go to is not
seen in the same light. All that said, they are both champs and I wish they both had played for us.Comment
-
can't get the ball unless a midfielder kicks it to them. I think the RWO mandated hatred of Carlton is colouring some of the
discussion of the Judd-Kennedy trade and that is okay I guess.Comment
Comment