Swans chat What will Buddy get?

[RogueSwan]

Are we wearing "bloods" coloured glasses or not?

[i'm-uninformed2]

I’ll say it: he’ll get a week, he will deserve it, and will be lucky to avoid getting two.

[MattW]

I’ll say it: he’ll get a week, he will deserve it, and will be lucky to avoid getting two.

Yes.

[baskin]

Could someone please explain how Buddy's is worse than Shuey's hit on Mills?

[i'm-uninformed2]

Could someone please explain how Buddy's is worse than Shuey's hit on Mills?

Sure. It was graded as careless contact. Buddy will be graded as intentional. And I think in both cases, that's right. I'm not here to hang Buddy, but it was what it was.

[0918330512]

Based on form, enthusiasm & output, I’d hope Buddy gets a year!

I mean a one year extension

[barry]

Could someone please explain how Buddy's is worse than Shuey's hit on Mills?

Exactly. If there is any consistently, it will be a fine.
Buddy was also off balance, and falling backwards. Thats a big difference.

[707]

Dermie reckons it's 3-4 weeks!

I hate having him commentating, other than the above ridiculous statement, he prattles on non stop in every game.

One weeks rest for Buddy I'd reckon, won't do him any harm

[AB Swannie]

This is such a difficult question. Shuey should've got a week and so should Buddy..... but Shuey didn't get a week (nor did Astbury in round 1) and so neither should Buddy.

[Ralph Dawg]

This is such a difficult question. Shuey should've got a week and so should Buddy..... but Shuey didn't get a week (nor did Astbury in round 1) and so neither should Buddy.

I haven't seen either of the preceding incidents but Buddy has some previous form for "accidental" striking. I'd like to see the tribunal fine him but I'd be surprised if he doesn't at least get a week.

[Hotpotato]

He’ll get off .

[Bangalore Swans]

Based on form, enthusiasm & output, I’d hope Buddy gets a year!

I mean a one year extension

It’s the Buddy 2023 campaign. Fits with his number as well.

Why can’t Buddy push on like Tom Brady and play until he’s 40? He’s more focused than at any time in his career. He loves football and is athleticly very sound.

I would be planning for a Logan, Amartey and Buddy forward line show for years to come.

[Mark26]

Dermie reckons it's 3-4 weeks!

I hate having him commentating, other than the above ridiculous statement, he prattles on non stop in every game.

One weeks rest for Buddy I'd reckon, won't do him any harm

Buddy will get a week. Dermie is okay.

[Matty10]

Buddy will get a week. Dermie is okay.

I don’t mind listening to Brereton for analysis post game or during the week, but I don’t really enjoy his contribution during the contest (it might just be the tone of his voice).

I missed his suggestion that Buddy should get 3-4, but that must be in a hypothetical sense where the current set of rules don’t apply. If he is graded like Shuey it will be a fine, otherwise he will get one. Anything higher and the Swans would appeal (and win).

[Faunac8]

Dermie reckons it's 3-4 weeks!

I hate having him commentating, other than the above ridiculous statement, he prattles on non stop in every game.

One weeks rest for Buddy I'd reckon, won't do him any harm

Wouldn’t it be nice if Dermie got three or four weeks off as well ?