Welcome Paddy McCartin

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Velour&Ruffles
    Regular in the Side
    • Jun 2006
    • 898

    #31
    Originally posted by liz
    As others have observed, his kicking is a highlight. It's unusual to see a defender kick the ball with the precision, penetration and fluency that he does. I guess that's because (or why) he hasn't always been a defender.
    I seem to recall us having another defender cum forward last year who could kick the ball with precision, penetration and fluency, and who was also a good mark. I think he has left the club now, but Paddy is bigger, stronger, a better mark, a bloody good kick (although perhaps not quite as good) and really wants to be at the club. Maybe he's a good replacement, and maybe the club brains trust was doing this calculation when deciding to let Voldemort go.
    My opinion is objective truth in its purest form

    Comment

    • liz
      Veteran
      Site Admin
      • Jan 2003
      • 16773

      #32
      Originally posted by Velour&Ruffles
      I seem to recall us having another defender cum forward last year who could kick the ball with precision, penetration and fluency, and who was also a good mark. I think he has left the club now, but Paddy is bigger, stronger, a better mark, a bloody good kick (although perhaps not quite as good) and really wants to be at the club. Maybe he's a good replacement, and maybe the club brains trust was doing this calculation when deciding to let Voldemort go.
      Different kind of "defender". Dawson wasn't really a defender - he was a flanker who sometimes operated out of the defensive fifty.

      P McCartin is likely to play more as a real defender. (And while his kicking is good, I don't know it's at Dawson's level - based on what I've actually witnessed. Haven't seen him picking out a target over a long distance.)

      Comment

      • royboy42
        Senior Player
        • Apr 2006
        • 2078

        #33
        I dunno who Voldemort is, but referring to Dawson as nameless etc seems a bit strong.
        The Christchurch murderer deserves that , but not an athlete seeking to improve his life.

        Comment

        • dejavoodoo44
          Veterans List
          • Apr 2015
          • 8637

          #34
          Originally posted by royboy42
          I dunno who Voldemort is, but referring to Dawson as nameless etc seems a bit strong.
          The Christchurch murderer deserves that , but not an athlete seeking to improve his life.
          Yeah, Josh doesn't deserve that. Actually, is it Josh?
          Jeremy? Gordon? Something like that.

          Comment

          • dejavoodoo44
            Veterans List
            • Apr 2015
            • 8637

            #35
            Originally posted by liz
            Different kind of "defender". Dawson wasn't really a defender - he was a flanker who sometimes operated out of the defensive fifty.

            P McCartin is likely to play more as a real defender. (And while his kicking is good, I don't know it's at Dawson's level - based on what I've actually witnessed. Haven't seen him picking out a target over a long distance.)
            One thing that I like about Paddy signing, is that it increases the chances of Rampe being relieved of taking a monster forward and moved on to a medium forward. Not only would he be likely to dominate that type of match up, but it should allow him to play more of a rebounding role. And I think his rebounding skills are very good. He often plays on instinctively, he has a fast and accurate short kick, which usually gets the ball to someone in space.

            Comment

            • KSAS
              Senior Player
              • Mar 2018
              • 1793

              #36
              I'm reserved about Paddy making any sort of immediate impact or gaining early selection, considering he hasn't played senior footy since 2018 and only 5 VFL games last year. The club obviously sees him as a chance, same as the astute VFL followers here on what he might bring to the table. Can understand the excitement as I'm also very intrigued, but at the same time cautious due to his history. Fingers crossed.
              Last edited by KSAS; 2 February 2022, 10:28 AM.

              Comment

              • Ralph Dawg
                Senior Player
                • Apr 2018
                • 1729

                #37
                Originally posted by KSAS
                I'm reserved about Paddy making any sort of immediate impact or gaining early selection, considering he hasn't played senior footy since 2018 and only 5 VFL games last year. The club obviously sees him as a chance, same as the astute VFL followers here on what he might bring to the table. Can understand the excitement as I'm also very intrigued, but at the same time cautious due to his history. Fingers crossed.
                I agree. It wouldn't surprise me if the big motivation to give him a chance is more as insurance in the forward line with the looming retirement of Buddy and possibility of Logan returning home at some point.

                Comment

                • Rod_
                  Senior Player
                  • Jan 2003
                  • 1179

                  #38
                  In part a replacement for Dawson. IMO.

                  Skilled player and hope he can stand the test that footy will provide!

                  Good luck

                  Comment

                  • 707
                    Veterans List
                    • Aug 2009
                    • 6204

                    #39
                    Originally posted by Ralph Dawg
                    I agree. It wouldn't surprise me if the big motivation to give him a chance is more as insurance in the forward line with the looming retirement of Buddy and possibility of Logan returning home at some point.
                    Wash your mouth out Ralph!

                    I'm still distressed about Dawson defecting, don't want anyone suggesting McDonald could do the same

                    Comment

                    • Goal Sneak
                      Out of Bounds on the Full
                      • Jun 2006
                      • 653

                      #40
                      Originally posted by 707
                      Wash your mouth out Ralph!

                      I'm still distressed about Dawson defecting, don't want anyone suggesting McDonald could do the same
                      The idea has already been floated over in WA, since Jack Darling refused to get a jab. We need to be extremely pro-active as a club to get in front of any potential swooping eagles

                      Comment

                      • stevoswan
                        Veterans List
                        • Sep 2014
                        • 8559

                        #41
                        Originally posted by dejavoodoo44
                        Yeah, Josh doesn't deserve that. Actually, is it Josh?
                        Jeremy? Gordon? Something like that.

                        Comment

                        • Ralph Dawg
                          Senior Player
                          • Apr 2018
                          • 1729

                          #42
                          Originally posted by 707
                          Wash your mouth out Ralph!

                          I'm still distressed about Dawson defecting, don't want anyone suggesting McDonald could do the same
                          That was a bit glass half empty of me, sorry ??

                          Comment

                          • bloodspirit
                            Clubman
                            • Apr 2015
                            • 4448

                            #43
                            Are two McCartins better than one? How Paddy fits into Sydney's plans (theinnersanctum.com.au)
                            All opinions are not equal. Some are a very great deal more robust, sophisticated, and well supported in logic and argument than others. -Douglas Adams, author (11 Mar 1952-2001)

                            Comment

                            • MattW
                              Veterans List
                              • May 2011
                              • 4218

                              #44
                              In an interview on SEN yesterday, Harley indicated he expected Paddy to play senior footy as a defender this year.

                              Comment

                              • Auntie.Gerald
                                Veterans List
                                • Oct 2009
                                • 6480

                                #45
                                Paddy has an amazing set of levers to grab that footy

                                Could be a real asset down back or up forward if he gets thank tank and mindset on song
                                "be tough, only when it gets tough"

                                Comment

                                Working...