I just can't see how we could fit Clarke in the midfield mix, given Mills spent less time there against the Crows, and we have the possibility of getting JPK in there as well. Matching up against a taller opponent wouldn't be an issue if aren't kicking to Clarke hoping he will take contested grabs.
Rnd 20, vs GWS at the SCG, on Saturday 30 July, 2:10 PM
Collapse
X
-
-
GWS always fire up against us and have a great record in recent seasons. It will be a challenging game. We need to shut down their key mids and starve Toby of opportunities.Comment
-
It’s a tough one if Hickey doesn’t get up . You would t want Reid playing close to a full game in the ruck due to his soft tissue injury history. Armartey looks a bit lost sometimes in the ruck but is ok in short spurts. We also have Fox who has pinch hit in the ruck in the past but then we rob the pretty solid structure of our back half .
Maybe we rotate the 3 through the ruck and bring in McDonald as the extra forward .
This gives us the option of having Armartey and McDonald in the same side who I think come finals are playing for the one spot .
Out of the side that played on the weekend who all could potentially come into the side at some stage if fit are
Kennedy
Campbell
Ladhams
Mcdonald
Cunningham
Wicks (medi Sub)
Ronke
That’s some serious depth with also leaving out Sheldrick And Roberts who have had a taste this year
Then you have Gould and melican that offer defensive tall depth that we haven’t needed so far .
We have a pretty small injury list at the moment but that can change pretty quickly but I think we have most bases covered
Sent from my iPhone using TapatalkComment
-
The fact we have a small injury list bodes well for our season!
It's interesting that our injuries have improved and Richmond's have gotten worse since we lured Damien Raper across. Does he deserve some credit? I find it impossible to gauge (but still interesting to speculate).All opinions are not equal. Some are a very great deal more robust, sophisticated, and well supported in logic and argument than others. -Douglas Adams, author (11 Mar 1952-2001)Comment
-
Article re match selections for both teams with comments from Horse and Mills.
Veteran Swan Josh Kennedy in the frame as Giants turn to big guns for derbyComment
-
Yeah nah
- - - Updated - - -
Yeah to thisComment
-
Comment
-
I wouldn't take anyone out of the guts and swap Campbell for Clarke. Only change FWIW.Comment
-
This works for me. I was concerned that JPK sitting a game out at this time would be a step backwards after getting a couple of games under his belt.Comment
-
Comment
-
Anyone who thinks James is being dropped is either not watching games closely or has an inherent bias .
Hard to argue that the Chad has become probably our best player under 25 but James would be one of the first picked each week based on what he delivers for the team on the field.
Based on that I don’t know where we play JPK and lord knows I want him in.Comment
-
Comment