Round 15: the other games. The winter solstice round.
Collapse
X
-
It seems Jordan Dawson lost teeth in the head high contact in the forward 50 that wasn’t paid. Several posts on Reddit claim this but I can’t find a news article to confirm if it is fact or hyperbole.
Gary Rohan scored 10 Coach’s votes despite taking out one his team’s best players.Comment
-
The AFL have now admitted, in the safety of the next day, that Dawson should have received a free....but who is surprised that not one of four umpires could see that free to the interstate team against a Victorian team in the dying seconds of a match with a 2 point margin to the Vic team?
Comment
-
I think i was last season that Brisbane was denied a free kick in the last seconds in their match against Geelong at Kardinia Park. The umpires have form against interstate teams especially when they are playing against Victorian teams.The AFL have now admitted, in the safety of the next day, that Dawson should have received a free....but who is surprised that not one of four umpires could see that free to the interstate team against a Victorian team in the dying seconds of a match with a 2 point margin to the Vic team?
Comment
-
Article re inconsistent umpiring in the Crows-Pies game. Not just the Dawson incident.
‘You @@@@ing kidding me?’: AFL got it wrong as Crows seek answersComment
-
The angst re: umps has been around for over a century. Just this morning I was reading about unruly crowds in 1918 and anger pouring over the fences at them.Article re inconsistent umpiring in the Crows-Pies game. Not just the Dawson incident.
‘You @@@@@@@ing kidding me?’: AFL got it wrong as Crows seek answers
John Worrall of The Australasian says he witnessed an umpire being assaulted by women and boys at a Richmond match.
There were complaints that umpires seemed to forget the rules and were rattled by crowds.
It almost could have been written today. Not much has changed.Comment
-
In those days they were all Victorian teams, now there's interstate teams....I think a lot has changed and I think you know what I mean.The angst re: umps has been around for over a century. Just this morning I was reading about unruly crowds in 1918 and anger pouring over the fences at them.
John Worrall of The Australasian says he witnessed an umpire being assaulted by women and boys at a Richmond match.
There were complaints that umpires seemed to forget the rules and were rattled by crowds.
It almost could have been written today. Not much has changed.Comment
-
Comment
-
No argument on that angle from me Stevo. I agree wholeheartedly with the sentiment because interstate teams seem to come off second best. Well ours does anyway.
I was simply amused that umpiring has always been a source of angst. That much isn't new.Comment
-
Yes, you're right on that.Comment

Comment