Lade

[anniswan]

How did he get off and Judd gets a week?

Rhetorical question I think, I know the answer.

[paralowiepower]

Well considering what Pickett got then anyone else who does the same only gets half, and Lloyd didn't even get reported I think the tribunal owes us big time.

Anyway get your facts right, he was found guilty and given a reprimand.

And how could you give Lade weeks when Hunter (West Coast)did the same last week and also got a reprimand. Don't you want the tribunal to be consistant?

[Barry Schneider]

Originally posted by paralowiepower
Well considering what Pickett got then anyone else who does the same only gets half, and Lloyd didn't even get reported I think the tribunal owes us big time.

Anyway get your facts right, he was found guilty and given a reprimand.

And how could you give Lade weeks when Hunter (West Coast)did the same last week and also got a reprimand. Don't you want the tribunal to be consistant?

Both should have been suspended.Hitting blokes in the jatz crackers is a no no.

[ScottH]

Originally posted by Barry Schneider
Both should have been suspended.Hitting blokes in the jatz crackers is a no no.

Yet poking your finger up someones poophole can get you banned for how long??

[Barry Schneider]

Originally posted by ScottH
Yet poking your finger up someones poophole can get you banned for how long??

12 weeks.
There are a few differences in what AFL and league think is a serious offence.
Scotland and Fevola would have got at least 6 weeks or even more for eye gouging but got a few weeks for unnecessary contact or some other rubbish.
I still can't work out how Jolly got 2 weeks.

[ScottH]

Originally posted by Barry Schneider
12 weeks.
There are a few differences in what AFL and league think is a serious offence.
Scotland and Fevola would have got at least 6 weeks or even more for eye gouging but got a few weeks for unnecessary contact or some other rubbish.

In League you can also bop someone, and get 10 mins cooling off. Gehrig gives a little tap in the guts and gets a week.

Originally posted by Barry Schneider
I still can't work out how Jolly got 2 weeks.

Nope, nothing in it but carelessness/silliness on his part. No serious contact. I would love to know what the Swans presented as evidence in their appeals.

[SwallowdaFonz]

From AFL web site, Tribunal News:

"Port ruckman Brendon Lade accepted a reprimand for striking Sydney's Andrew Schauble."

A reprimand! Like he was not going to accept that "penalty".

[ScottH]

How is Schaubs injury?? has he been icing it???

[Ajn]

Best wear a box for protection, cause the tribunal ain't giving it!