Adrian Anderson should be suspended

[dawson]

He and the tribunal are going to get a pasting tomorrow, particularly by Patrick Smith.

The system is a farce and a complete joke.

Both he and his stupid system should go.

[punter257]

they need a massive review to fix all the ********
anderson is a mess

[Nico]

It is a fair call. When you listen to some of the more knowledgeable people on the system you just wonder what corporate incompetents put the system together.

To not have a clear description of what in and behind play is as an example, you wonder if they ever re read the first draft. Anyone who has got any knowledge of writing a report knows that you must cover your backside on every point and have it clearly explained.

Sounds like those who put it together have little or no business acumen.

[hammo]

Peter Schwab has made a dog's breakfast of the match reviews this year.

He should be the first one out the door.

If he had laid the correct gradings & charges then Hall would not have been dragged through this media circus for days on end.

The Gaspar decision is the final straw.

[midaro]

Hall effectively got a one week suspended sentence - which IMO is within the scope of what it deserved.

The tribunal worked fine. It might not have in the past--Gehrig--but as a body of precedent is built up, penalties will become more consistent. The system is fine.

[NMWBloods]

Anderson is an idiot.

[goswannie14]

Originally posted by hammo
Peter Schwab has made a dog's breakfast of the match reviews this year.

He should be the first one out the door.

If he had laid the correct gradings & charges then Hall would not have been dragged through this media circus for days on end.

The Gaspar decision is the final straw.

Yep - I reckon that Schwab is the problem;
Stuffed up coaching
Stuffed up Umpires
Stuffed up the new system

The system is OKay, its' Schwabs interpretation that needs some fixing.