Carey's last goal

[swan_17]

What a joke!! Don't know how the umpire didn't see that one, Carey's last goal of the day was CLEARLY over the line as he marked it....shocking (where was Jude's free for 'too high'?). Replayed it from both angles in slow motion, Carey and the ball appeared to be over the behind line on his first grab

[Nico]

Saw it that way myself. But what about the Carey umpiring inconsistency.

Throws Sadoo to the ground in 3rd quarter, no free. Gets a 10% of the same medicine late in the game and gets a bloody free!!!

[SXP]

Personaly I didn't see that beacuse I missed it, but according to Herald Sun it might have been over the line too.

[liz]

Originally posted by Nico
Saw it that way myself. But what about the Carey umpiring inconsistency.

Throws Sadoo to the ground in 3rd quarter, no free. Gets a 10% of the same medicine late in the game and gets a bloody free!!!

I thought there were soft frees and missed frees for both teams - but I agree with that. I didn't think you were allowed to throw your opponent to the ground before the ball arrives - but if you are, surely both teams must be allowed to do it.

[ugg]

You're forgetting Lizz, that this is Carey we are talking about. Saddington didn't play him well though as Dermot mentioned, trying to go body to body with him.

[Nico]

You're right Ugg. Either Saddo still hasn't learned to play body to body (He's too light anyway) or he has to be kept off the Carey and Tredrae types.

When Schaubes went on him he played him from behind.

[aflconvert]

He seems to be a protected species ; that goal when he threw Saddington to the ground and the ball nowhere in sight at the time . If Barry Hall had done that it would have been a free kick
for sure

[red_avengers]

We should have won it. That was definately over the line. I HATE that big oaf Carey. Very proud of the boys for fighting to the bitter end. Brave comeback in the second half.

Thought Bolton was fantastic. We missed Ball as got murdered in the ruck. Roos made a tactical error by not bringing O'Keefe on more. Thought LRT was OK because he made a few marks and got a few frees for but he needs to learn to how to dispose the ball as he always relies on someone else.

Adelaide looks like one very polished side. Only had the been Davis with the last kick we may have just clinch it.

I HATE Wank Carey
I HATE Wank Carey
I HATE Wank Carey
I HATE Wank Carey
I HATE Wank Carey
I HATE Wank Carey
x100

[swan_song]

Ive freeze framed and slo-mod it too...to me it looks to have been a clear point, which would have knocked 5 points off their score and given us the ball...whether in the end it would have made the difference we'll never know, but an almost "moral" victory could be claimed over the crows...

[Xie Shan]

I'm not crying "we wuz robbed", but it looked a lot like a point to me. Whether we would have won I'm not sure, but it hurts more knowing who kicked the goal. What about the burton 'mark' on the wing that C.Bolton knocked out of his hands? The commentators thought it was a mark, I'm a bit more diplomatic...Bolton stole it quickly enough to convince the umpires. Pretty clever work!

[Dpw]

I doubt it would have made a difference was proud of the boys I just can't stand the umpire bashing that happens here when we lose.

When made enought mistakes ourseleves without needing to use the umpires as an excuse.

[bay_4]

Agree with that DPW. Just watched the game on replay and there were plenty of iffy decisions, but they evened out. Maybe Carey's goal should've been a point, but Sydney's second last goal wouldn't have happened if that mark to the Crows player had been paid (as it probably should have).
Thus has the cookie crumbled. Still a lot of positives to take out of the game.

[NMWBloods]

Just watched it and Carey was clearly over the line - I looked at his feet - they were comfortably a metre outside the line. Of course not to mention the blatant throw over the shoulder by the Adelaide player to get the ball there.

[Ruda Wakening]

Originally posted by Dpw
I doubt it would have made a difference was proud of the boys I just can't stand the umpire bashing that happens here when we lose.

When made enought mistakes ourseleves without needing to use the umpires as an excuse.

Consistency is all i expect .

[Charlie]

I'm staring at still footage right now in the Herald-Sun.

Ladies and gentleman, I believe we have had a top two spot stolen from us.

This game should be called a draw at least!!!