Hayes or Bolton

[SwansRock]

why are so many people going against him?

[SwansRock]

really all i can say is swans wouldn't be the same without Jude he gives them something.

so many players in the swans bring all the best to them smetimes they have bad games, just cause they have one bad game or miss a goal doesn't mean we should start searching for a new player from another team. otherwise we would have alot of our players missing.


in the end all that really matters is if we win the game and if we lose knowing that we tried our best so go Jude!!!

[NMWBloods]

[SwansRock]

[dendol]

Originally posted by SwansRock
in the end all that really matters is if we win the game and if we lose knowing that we tried our best so go Jude!!!

i sense another "mediocrity has been our bane" type discussion.

[monopoly19]

Re: Re: Re: mmm

Originally posted by Captain
Add the Fosdike rubbish to that as well.

How to argue with that logic?

[swansrule100]

personally i think bolton and fosdike are great players... who cares what lenny hayes did at stkilda... he may not of fitted in at sydney.

I can understand hypothetical discussion though of course, and guess some wish we had lenny hayes... but personally i support every player on the swans list, regardless of who we could of had or dont have, who cares, the players are here and i will support them all the way every one of them. I am probably too on eyed and silly and biasd but i love the sydney swans, always have , always will and the players we have now are awesome and i believe they are a mix capable of winning us a flag... just my opinion

[anne]

Jude any day - he is by far the best looking!

[Dpw]

Originally posted by swansrule100
personally i think bolton and fosdike are great players... who cares what lenny hayes did at stkilda... he may not of fitted in at sydney.

I can understand hypothetical discussion though of course, and guess some wish we had lenny hayes... but personally i support every player on the swans list, regardless of who we could of had or dont have, who cares, the players are here and i will support them all the way every one of them. I am probably too on eyed and silly and biasd but i love the sydney swans, always have , always will and the players we have now are awesome and i believe they are a mix capable of winning us a flag... just my opinion

Define "great" because I consider say Paul Kelly as great but would not consider Fosdike or Bolton to be in the same group. and yes you are biasd and silly, but hey feel free to enjoy footy as you like. Just a pet hate of mine how everyone is "great"

[swansrule100]

ohhh ok...

for me paul kelly is a champion.
i mean bolton and fosdike are great players in the sense that they are very god honest hard working types..

youve got like your locketts, kellys, voss whoever you know the type barassi whitten etc as champions.

then you have people like say a cresswell or a bayes who play 200 odd games and are like really great players

then id say people who are succesful at senior level but perhaps not in the top players in the league and not quite in the league of a cressa type player but are still great players.. like bolton... perhaps i should use different wording

then youd have guys with poetential or plain failures

i agree too many people are labelled too highly.... perhaps i shouldnt of said great :P

yeh im on eyed i know... just love the team

[SwansRock]

really

im not being mean i just don't see why people would ever bag out there team's players.


He tries his best.

well he isin't as good as Locket or Kelly or Cresswell.

but he's still cool!

[swansrule100]

no ones being mean.. :P just was speculation

im sure everyone wants jude to have a great career he could become a star in the league... lets hope he does

[Rod_]

I voted Lenny however I would have gone for both if avalable....


Rod_

[SwansRock]

no i meant i wasn't being mean