Michael Voss or Barry Hall

[dendol]

Hall is a big, bald, angry man who kicks goals but doesnt get alot of possessions in the midfield where games are won and lost these days and since we need some quality midfielders we would be stupid not to accept this deal if it was offered and Voss is a 3-peat premiership captain and brownlow medalist and Hall hasnt won any flags and isnt captain and hasnt got a brownlow so wouldnt it be stupid if we were offered that and didnt take it and also i know you will say that Voss turns 30 next year but that would be unfair to count that because its discrimination just like if i went for a job and got told im too old.

[swansrule100]

swansrock!!! calm down please no one had a go at you!!! just be sensible ok.

theres nothing really wrong with you post i guess...would we give up hall for voss...maybe if voss was back at his peak! but i doubt it due to the lack of key forward we would be left with

[Sid]

A proper answer...

Hall is 2 years younger and hasnt had an injury since i remember at the swans. He is our best player at the moment. Although we do need experience in our midfield, theres no way i would swap voss for hall.