We've all been DUPED!

[Cheer Cheer]

Originally posted by NMWBloods
Goodes is a very very good player, with periods of sheer excellence, but is not a champion yet. Has the potential to become one.

Finally, some clear thinking!

Without getting caught up in the hysteria of the AA selections.

[redunderthebed]

so many contributions from you two guys and so little logic.
please define 'champion' and give us some examples.
crawford? koota?hird?harvey? anyone or no-one who won a brownlow?
However,you are certainly entitled to your opinion....GOD knows we see enough of them .

[Cheer Cheer]

Why should I bother answering you when you come out with those insults ?

Haven't got time to play with people who snap so easily, I would have been prepared to have a healthy debate if you were rational about it, unfortunately your post suggests otherwise.

Bye.

P.S On the other note for the record, I have probably posted least out everyone over the last 6 months. Not that I care what you think, just stating the facts.

[cruiser]

Originally posted by Cheer Cheer
Why should I bother answering you when you come out with those insults ?

Haven't got time to play with people who snap so easily, I would have been prepared to have a healthy debate if you were rational about it, unfortunately your post suggests otherwise.

Bye.

P.S On the other note for the record, I have probably posted least out everyone over the last 6 months. Not that I care what you think, just stating the facts.

Be fair. Your previous post responding to NMW suggested that I wasn't thinking clearly and was being hysterical and I didnt chuck a tantrum like this.

[Cheer Cheer]

Please state where I referred to you in that comment in which I responded to NMW.

We had constructive debate.

Lets keep the topic at hand, and not ruin a thread.

Any beefs take off the board.

[cruiser]

Originally posted by Cheer Cheer
Finally, some clear thinking!

Without getting caught up in the hysteria of the AA selections.

You suggested it above. Anyway, I'm not gonna argue this. But I think his question is fair. You should defend your view by defining champion please.

[Cheer Cheer]

Definition of Champion / Star in my book which I have already posted in this thread...

Does not have to be a brownlow medalist, has to perform at a consistently high level over at least 5 seasons, when i say consistently high, means being AA ( not every yr - but at least every two, with a couple of back to back selections , top couple in your teams B/F regulary, named in hypothetical " state squad " is for an example, you get the drift

An example of champion with brownlow medals - Robert harvey - dual brownlow winner - 8 AA selections, BF etc

An example of champion without brownlow medals - Wayne Carey - need I say more ?