Sydney AFL Team of the Year

[BeeEmmAre]

Here is my first instalment for the Sydney AFL Team of the Year, based on the system that successfully picked Paul Gambale as the highest vote winner in the Phelan Medal in its first season operating on the Sydney AFL.
I would like to expand it this year, but that depends on the Sydney AFL website.

PREMIER DIVISION

1. Damien Charlston (East Coast) 10
1. Peter Dugmore (St George) 10
1. Cameron Stanton (Wollongong) 10
1. Michael Talbot (Pennant Hills) 10
5. Troy Bartlett (Wollongong) 9
5. Adam Buttling (St George) 9
5. Seb Parker (Pennant Hills) 9
5. Josh Ryder (East Coast) 9
9. Daniel Posch (Wollongong 8
9. Gavin Raper (St George) 8
9. Lloyd Shepherd (Pennant Hills) 8
9. Ryan Smyth (East Coast) 8

FIRST DIVISION

1. L. Taylor (Sydney University) 10
1. A. Westwood (South-West Sydney) 10
3. A. Crespi (Sydney University) 9
3. P. Gleason (South-West Sydney) 9
5. C. McLachlan (Sydney University) 8
5. T. Pitt (South-West Sydney) 8
7. A. Furley (South-West Sydney) 7
7. R. Lavery (Sydney University) 7
9. S. Dowsett (South-West Sydney) 6
9. I. Loughan (Sydney University) 6

SECOND DIVISION

Season still to commence

[Pekay]

Love your work BMR,look forward to seeing the likes of Smits Holland Travers Rogers Burrows up in lights,and also to keep an eye on other teams.Now i'm shooting for that list-does a clean sheet count?

[BeeEmmAre]

Depends on (y)our club.

[BeeEmmAre]

Sydney AFL Top 10s after round 2

PREMIER DIVISION

1. Damien Charlston (East Coast) 20
2. Joel Cooney (UNSW-ES) 17
3. Matthew Tonizzo (Campbelltown) 16
4. Gavin Raper (St George) 14
5. Steven Cook (Balmain) 13
6. Peter Dugmore (St George) 10
6. Chris Fretwell (Campbelltown) 10
6. Damien Hall (St George) 10
6. Seb Parker (Pennant Hills) 10
6. Lloyd Shepherd (Pennant Hills) 10
6. Cameron Stanton (Wollongong) 10
6. Michael Talbot (Pennant Hills) 10

FIRST DIVISION

1. Ian Loughan (Sydney University) 14
2. Jeremy Dwyer (Sydney University) 10
2. Matt Mackay (UTS) 10
2. Luke Taylor (Sydney University) 10
2. Adam Westwood (South-West Sydney) 10
6. Aaron Crespi (Sydney University) 9
6. Nick Gilbert (UTS) 9
6. Peter Gleason (South-West Sydney) 9
6. Michael Higgins (Sydney University) 9
10. Alan Kymantas (UTS) 8
10. Chris McLachlan (Sydney University) 8
10. Troy Pitt (South-West Sydney) 8

Not submitted to website: Round 2: Holroyd Parramatta, Macquarie University, Southern Sharks, South-West Sydney.

SECOND DIVISION (round 1)

1. Robin Alexander (Whales) 10
1. Michael Coupe (Bulldogs) 10
1. Grant Webb (St Clair) 10
4. Sean Holt (Bulldogs) 9
4. Stuart McKinley (St Clair) 9
4. Stephen Roberts (Whales) 9
7. Adam Bioletti (Whales) 8
7. Paul Gallo (Bulldogs) 8
9. David Backler (Bulldogs) 7
9. Tony Sargeant (Macquarie Uni) 7

Not submitted to website: Round 1: Balmain, Manly-Warringah, Pennant Hills, Southern Sharks, Sydney Uni Blue, Sydney Uni Red.

Are these missing clubs' best players likely to appear at any stage????

[BeeEmmAre]

Updated as best I can at the moment.

[ash]

sydney afl

bud you probably got two out of 10 right.

Not sure where you get your info from but is way off

[BeeEmmAre]

My Sydney AFL Top 10s after round 3 (round 2 Div 2)

PREMIER DIVISION

1. Gavin Raper (St George) 22
2. Damien Charlston (East Coast) 20
2. Joel Cooney (UNSW-ES) 20
4. Troy Luff (UNSW-ES) 19
5. Steven Cook (Balmain) 18
6. Tim Richter (Wollongong) 17
7. Matthew Tonizzo (Campbelltown) 16
8. Max Collett (UNSW-ES) 14
8. Eid Kassem (Western Suburbs) 14
10. Lee Campbell (Balmain) 13
10. Declan Donohue (St George) 13

FIRST DIVISION

1. Adam Westwood (South-West Sydney) 19
2. Ryan Collins (Southern Sharks) 16
2. Scott Dowsett (South-West Sydney) 16
2. Daniel Napper (Southern Sharks) 16
5. Ian Loughan (Sydney University) 14
5. Jason Philp (Southern Sharks) 14
5. Craig Pridgeon (Manly-Warringah) 14
8. Jason Allie (South-West Sydney) 12
9. Michael Bellman (Southern Sharks) 10
9. Jeremy Dwyer (Sydney University) 10
9. Matt Mackay (UTS Bats) 10
9. Matt Rawle (Manly-Warringah) 10
9. Daniel Stanton (Southern Sharks) 10
9. Luke Taylor (Sydney University) 10

Not submitted to website: Round 2: Holroyd Parramatta, Macquarie University. Round 3: Sydney University, UTS Bats

SECOND DIVISION

1. Stephen Roberts (UNSW-ES Whales) 19
2. Adam Bioletti (UNSW-ES Whales) 16
2. Ben Train (Macquarie University) 16
4. Robin Alexander (UNSW-ESWhales) 10
4. Damien Brown (Nor-West) 10
4. Michael Coupe (UNSW-ES Bulldogs) 10
4. Jerome Samaha (UTS Black) 10
4. Charles Stuart (Sydney University Blue) 10
4. Grant Webb (St Clair) 10
10. Cheyne Anderson (Southern Sharks) 9
10. Sean Holt (UNSW-ES Bulldogs) 9
10. Andrew Kraefft (Sydney University Blue) 9
10. Stuart McKinley (St Clair) 9
10. Colin Sharpen (UTS Black) 9
10. Andrew Travers (Nor-West) 9

Not submitted to website: Round 1: Balmain, Manly-Warringah, Pennant Hills, Sydney Uni Red. Round 2: Balmain, St Clair, Sydney Uni Blue, Sydney Uni Red, UNSW-ES Bulldogs, UTS Black, UTS Green.

[House]

BMR- Do you have any information on Damien Charlston? I notice he has two best on grounds from you.

[Pekay]

Re: sydney afl

Originally posted by ash
bud you probably got two out of 10 right.

Not sure where you get your info from but is way off

Thats why you are a rookie Ash.Its worked in plenty of comps. The favourite doesnt always win the Brownlow.

[BeeEmmAre]

Originally posted by House
BMR- Do you have any information on Damien Charlston? I notice he has two best on grounds from you.

I know very little about him, actually.
He obviously has made a big impression on those who have been watching the Eagles though, and as such, I look forward to seeing him go round on Sunday.

Sydney AFL Digital Sports Match of the Round

North Shore v East Coast @ Gore Hill Oval.

Cheerz Pekay - spot on.

[BeeEmmAre]

The Top 10 after round 4 (belatedly)


PREMIER DIVISION

1. Gavin Raper (St George) 22
1. Matthew Tonizzo (Campbelltown) 22
3. Damien Charlston (East Coast) 20
3. Joel Cooney (UNSW-ES) 20
5. Jason Clarke (Pennant Hills) 19
5. Troy Luff (UNSW-ES) 19
7. Max Collett (UNSW-ES) 18
7. Steven Cook (Balmain) 18
7. Matt Withers (Western Suburbs) 18
10. Tim Richter (Wollongong) 17

FIRST DIVISION

1. Matt Mackay (UTS Bats) 27
2. Roland Wood (Sydney University) 25
3. Jason Philp (Southern Sharks) 22
4. Michael Bellman (Southern Sharks) 20
4. Craig Pridgeon (Manly-Warringah) 20
6. Jeremy Dwyer (Sydney University) 19
6. Adam Westwood (South-West Sydney) 19
8. Chris McLachlan (Sydney University) 18
9. Matt Griffiths (Southern Sharks) 17
10. Ryan Collins (Southern Sharks) 16
10. Scott Dowsett (South-West Sydney) 16
10. Daniel Napper (Southern Sharks) 16

Not submitted to website: Round 2: Holroyd Parramatta, Macquarie University.

SECOND DIVISION

1. Andrew Kraefft (Sydney University Blue) 19
1. Stephen Roberts (UNSW-ES Whales) 19
1. Andrew Travers (Nor-West) 19
4. Adam Bioletti (UNSW-ES Whales) 16
4. Ben Train (Macquarie University) 16
6. Anthony Leach (UTS Black) 15
7. Tim Britton (Sydney University Blue) 14
8. Chas Wilkinson (Sydney University Blue) 13
9. Robin Alexander (UNSW-ES Whales) 10
9. Damien Brown (Nor-West) 10
9. Michael Coupe (UNSW-ES Bulldogs) 10
9. Joel McMullen (Pennant Hills) 10
9. Jerome Samaha (UTS Black) 10
9. Adrian Sibbick (UTS Black) 10
9. Charles Stuart (Sydney University Blue) 10
9. Grant Webb (St Clair) 10

Not submitted to website: Round 1: Balmain, Manly-Warringah, Pennant Hills, Sydney Uni Red. Round 2: Balmain, St Clair, Sydney Uni Red, UNSW-ES Bulldogs. Round 3: Balmain, Macquarie University, St Clair, UTS Green.

[ash]

?

How does this system work?

I am a Penno supporter as see you gave Clarke pts despite him realistically not being in the top 10 players in that game.

I am also surprised by looking at best players each week you are missing StGeorge and ECE better players?

Originally posted by BeeEmmAre
The Top 10 after round 4 (belatedly)


PREMIER DIVISION

1. Gavin Raper (St George) 22
1. Matthew Tonizzo (Campbelltown) 22
3. Damien Charlston (East Coast) 20
3. Joel Cooney (UNSW-ES) 20
5. Jason Clarke (Pennant Hills) 19
5. Troy Luff (UNSW-ES) 19
7. Max Collett (UNSW-ES) 18
7. Steven Cook (Balmain) 18
7. Matt Withers (Western Suburbs) 18
10. Tim Richter (Wollongong) 17

FIRST DIVISION

1. Matt Mackay (UTS Bats) 27
2. Roland Wood (Sydney University) 25
3. Jason Philp (Southern Sharks) 22
4. Michael Bellman (Southern Sharks) 20
4. Craig Pridgeon (Manly-Warringah) 20
6. Jeremy Dwyer (Sydney University) 19
6. Adam Westwood (South-West Sydney) 19
8. Chris McLachlan (Sydney University) 18
9. Matt Griffiths (Southern Sharks) 17
10. Ryan Collins (Southern Sharks) 16
10. Scott Dowsett (South-West Sydney) 16
10. Daniel Napper (Southern Sharks) 16

Not submitted to website: Round 2: Holroyd Parramatta, Macquarie University.

SECOND DIVISION

1. Andrew Kraefft (Sydney University Blue) 19
1. Stephen Roberts (UNSW-ES Whales) 19
1. Andrew Travers (Nor-West) 19
4. Adam Bioletti (UNSW-ES Whales) 16
4. Ben Train (Macquarie University) 16
6. Anthony Leach (UTS Black) 15
7. Tim Britton (Sydney University Blue) 14
8. Chas Wilkinson (Sydney University Blue) 13
9. Robin Alexander (UNSW-ES Whales) 10
9. Damien Brown (Nor-West) 10
9. Michael Coupe (UNSW-ES Bulldogs) 10
9. Joel McMullen (Pennant Hills) 10
9. Jerome Samaha (UTS Black) 10
9. Adrian Sibbick (UTS Black) 10
9. Charles Stuart (Sydney University Blue) 10
9. Grant Webb (St Clair) 10

Not submitted to website: Round 1: Balmain, Manly-Warringah, Pennant Hills, Sydney Uni Red. Round 2: Balmain, St Clair, Sydney Uni Red, UNSW-ES Bulldogs. Round 3: Balmain, Macquarie University, St Clair, UTS Green.

[BeeEmmAre]

Ash, I can basically only go on the best players as they are submitted to the Sydney AFL website.
These best players are submitted by the coaching staff or officials at each club, so for Jason Clarke to score points, he must have been rated in the best players by the Pennant Hills officials who collate them.

A player scores points from 10-1 based on where he was named in the best, and what the result of the match was.
For example, Penno's 100+ win over Balmain will get the Demons best six 10,9,8,7,6,5 while the Tigers best four will get 4,3,2,1.
A close match, though, such as your seven point loss to St George, will give the Crows 10,8,6,4,2 and the Demons 9,7,5,3,1.
There are other combinations in between these of course, but this is a basic run down of how I collate the points.

[ash]

system and player info

Hi BMR,

I would like to know more about you system.

I am an avid Penno supporter and see that some if not most times the best player is not selected.

Do you have any other informationon the following 3 players who seem to be carving up in the early rds this year:

ECE - Goodey
NOrths - Hill
ST George - Hall


Much appreciated.

Originally posted by BeeEmmAre
The Top 10 after round 4 (belatedly)


PREMIER DIVISION

1. Gavin Raper (St George) 22
1. Matthew Tonizzo (Campbelltown) 22
3. Damien Charlston (East Coast) 20
3. Joel Cooney (UNSW-ES) 20
5. Jason Clarke (Pennant Hills) 19
5. Troy Luff (UNSW-ES) 19
7. Max Collett (UNSW-ES) 18
7. Steven Cook (Balmain) 18
7. Matt Withers (Western Suburbs) 18
10. Tim Richter (Wollongong) 17

FIRST DIVISION

1. Matt Mackay (UTS Bats) 27
2. Roland Wood (Sydney University) 25
3. Jason Philp (Southern Sharks) 22
4. Michael Bellman (Southern Sharks) 20
4. Craig Pridgeon (Manly-Warringah) 20
6. Jeremy Dwyer (Sydney University) 19
6. Adam Westwood (South-West Sydney) 19
8. Chris McLachlan (Sydney University) 18
9. Matt Griffiths (Southern Sharks) 17
10. Ryan Collins (Southern Sharks) 16
10. Scott Dowsett (South-West Sydney) 16
10. Daniel Napper (Southern Sharks) 16

Not submitted to website: Round 2: Holroyd Parramatta, Macquarie University.

SECOND DIVISION

1. Andrew Kraefft (Sydney University Blue) 19
1. Stephen Roberts (UNSW-ES Whales) 19
1. Andrew Travers (Nor-West) 19
4. Adam Bioletti (UNSW-ES Whales) 16
4. Ben Train (Macquarie University) 16
6. Anthony Leach (UTS Black) 15
7. Tim Britton (Sydney University Blue) 14
8. Chas Wilkinson (Sydney University Blue) 13
9. Robin Alexander (UNSW-ES Whales) 10
9. Damien Brown (Nor-West) 10
9. Michael Coupe (UNSW-ES Bulldogs) 10
9. Joel McMullen (Pennant Hills) 10
9. Jerome Samaha (UTS Black) 10
9. Adrian Sibbick (UTS Black) 10
9. Charles Stuart (Sydney University Blue) 10
9. Grant Webb (St Clair) 10

Not submitted to website: Round 1: Balmain, Manly-Warringah, Pennant Hills, Sydney Uni Red. Round 2: Balmain, St Clair, Sydney Uni Red, UNSW-ES Bulldogs. Round 3: Balmain, Macquarie University, St Clair, UTS Green.

[ash]

thanks. disregard same ? but players?

thanks