2014 Team Nominations

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Mug Punter
    On the Rookie List
    • Nov 2009
    • 3325

    #46
    Originally posted by pieater
    Many current Premier sides are weaker than old reserve sides of 20 or so years ago.
    I think that the current first grade comp is a shadow of its former self, largely due (as mentioned by someone else) the NEAFL taking about 60 blokes each week (that's 5 A graders per club).

    The top 3-4 of the old SFA would usually be well above SFL reserves with the middle 3-4 on par and the bottom 2-3 below standard.

    Certainly some of the old power SFA sides would do quite well in this SFL comp. The Manly sides of the mid 90s (Peter Robertson, the Andersons and Hogarth) would not lose too much against the current Manly Premiers. Nor would the strong Holroyd Parramatta and Mac Uni struggle too much.

    To say that the current SFL first grade sides are worse than the ressies in the early 90s is a laughable statement though.

    Comment

    • unconfuseme
      Regular in the Side
      • Jan 2009
      • 681

      #47
      Making the statement and then vindicating with "the truth hurts" tells me that the contributor did play back then ... and never learned how to duck a tackle!!! ... a somewhat different game now, comparing apples and oranges.

      Comment

      Working...