New Competition Structure for 2018

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Ducboy
    Registered User
    • Aug 2017
    • 7

    #46
    Nuttsy didnt your ressies get a smashing by a div 5 side today

    Comment

    • Nuttsy
      Warming the Bench
      • Dec 2012
      • 117

      #47
      Originally posted by Ducboy
      Nuttsy didnt your ressies get a smashing by a div 5 side today
      "My Ressies", if your referring to Campbelltown I haven't been involved with the club for some time now but I'll humour you. So Your point is? The Blues aren't the ones telling everyone they are ready for Prems like your mob is

      Comment

      • saviour01
        Regular in the Side
        • Sep 2013
        • 932

        #48
        Almost as bad as your firsts getting flogged by someones reserves when you want to be in prems.

        Comment

        • Giants
          Pushing for Selection
          • Sep 2016
          • 69

          #49
          Originally posted by saviour01
          Almost as bad as your firsts getting flogged by someones reserves when you want to be in prems.
          Did watch Camden dismantle Syd Uni this afternoon. However the casualty ward will not help them next weekend.

          Was a decent crowd out there although the pitch looked a bit like Gore Hill.

          Comment

          • saviour01
            Regular in the Side
            • Sep 2013
            • 932

            #50
            Originally posted by Giants
            Did watch Camden dismantle Syd Uni this afternoon. However the casualty ward will not help them next weekend.

            Was a decent crowd out there although the pitch looked a bit like Gore Hill.
            Same. Looked like a fairly different Syd Uni side to the one we played 2 weeks ago. What was the yellow card for, didn't seem to be much in it?

            Comment

            • The Runner
              Regular in the Side
              • May 2017
              • 718

              #51
              jesus they're drinking their own bath water down south.. you'd think their locks for a Div 1 flag with the confidence going in to Prems next year.

              Comment

              • Giants
                Pushing for Selection
                • Sep 2016
                • 69

                #52
                Originally posted by saviour01
                Same. Looked like a fairly different Syd Uni side to the one we played 2 weeks ago. What was the yellow card for, didn't seem to be much in it?
                Not sure. Spoke to JL quickly after the game and he wasnt sure either but the charge was striking?

                Yeah must have been different side as they were never in it all day really.

                Comment

                • Pekay
                  Well retired, still sore
                  • Sep 2004
                  • 2134

                  #53
                  You can guarantee that'll be a much different Uni team come finals.

                  Comment

                  • Mug Punter
                    On the Rookie List
                    • Nov 2009
                    • 3325

                    #54
                    This talk about Camden stepping up to the PD comp next year is absolute madness. The idea that a team presently coming fourth in Div 1 could possibly step up both in terms of playing strength and admin demands is just delusional but it would just be like the dipsticks at the NSWAFL to push for it to tick that "growth box"

                    The west in Sydney is a huge black spot for the AFL. One would have thought that GWS would have some effect but at the senior level at least it has been non-existent, then again as we are told again and again it is a generational investment which I read as code for "we don't bother ourselves with the boring unsexy matter of senior amateur clubs in that area". I've always thought that Penrith were the obvious contender to emerge but for reasons unknown they haven't been able to leverage off their juniors and demographics. I gather that the Leaguies have really got their act together out there now under Gus Gould so that mat be a factor.

                    Camden have clearly done well and are progressing well but to throw them to the wolves from relative success to a grade where they will surely cop 20+ goal weekly hidings is surely a massive "sink or swim" gamble that the game should not have to take.

                    Comment

                    • Pekay
                      Well retired, still sore
                      • Sep 2004
                      • 2134

                      #55
                      You could almost make a case for three comps - Prems having 10 clubs of Seniors and Reserves, and 1st and 2nd Div having 8 & 7 clubs with Seniors and Reserves.

                      Promote and relegate between the 1st and 2nd Divisions.

                      Premier - the usual plus Camden if so be it.

                      1st Div - the highest ranking teams out of higher grades ie -

                      Blacktown
                      Parra
                      Mac Uni
                      Sutherland
                      Balmain (all D1)
                      Penrith
                      Sydney Uni
                      UTS (all D2)

                      2nd Div -

                      Randwick (D2 but came from lower grades)
                      SWS (D2)
                      Wollondilly (D2)
                      Pennant Hills (D2)
                      Campbelltown (D3)
                      Nor-West (D3)
                      North Shore (D3)

                      Saves clubs from D3 coming up against the likes of Div 1 powerhouses where we'd likely see cricket scores, like my mob against Sutherland.

                      Comment

                      • Cats (JL)
                        Registered User
                        • Sep 2017
                        • 1

                        #56
                        Originally posted by Pmcc2911
                        Lots of speculation about the structure for next year, any clues?
                        Afternoon gentlemen.
                        Been hearing so much about this site, thought I might join up to see what it's all about. Some interesting read so far.

                        Comment

                        • Tom Wills
                          Warming the Bench
                          • May 2008
                          • 478

                          #57
                          Sorry post on the wrong thread - what about the structure below for 2018?

                          Prems - Camden up - just do it - make it a 10 team comp
                          Div 1 - North Shore, Wests, UNSW up and Holdroyd down - allows Holroyd to rebuild and 12 team comp
                          Div 2 - North Shore, South West and UTS up - 12 team and a really even comp
                          Div 3 - St G and Magic up - 10 team comp
                          Div 4 - Camden, West North Shore up East Coast, South West down - good 10 team comp
                          Div 5 - the rest

                          Comment

                          • saviour01
                            Regular in the Side
                            • Sep 2013
                            • 932

                            #58
                            Isnt it already done that its firsts and reserves?

                            Comment

                            • The Runner
                              Regular in the Side
                              • May 2017
                              • 718

                              #59
                              Originally posted by saviour01
                              Isnt it already done that its firsts and reserves?
                              Officially it's "still in consultation"...

                              Comment

                              • Coastal Boy
                                Regular in the Side
                                • Nov 2003
                                • 516

                                #60
                                The divisionalisation structure has its flaws but it has served SydneyAFL well.
                                I cannot see how another structure would work better.
                                Unless each club is told you must have 3 opens teams plus u19s and cannot have any more the issues with tabling games will remain.
                                Don't change it I reckoned.

                                Comment

                                Working...