Just looking at goal of the year again...

[goswannie14]

Originally posted by motorace_182
He may not hit the guy on the chest 10/10 like others can, but his pace, acceleration, and ability to read the footy off hands are unmatched at the moment.

If the guy is as good as you say, then why do 5/10 kicks going to opponents or the advantage of the opposition? You have a look at the GF...I rest my case. (and he was given BOG for doing that)

BTW I did not say that he wasn't any good, I said the he was not as good as some of the commentators would have us believe. I would prefer a Robert Harvey to a Chris Judd any day

[Bleed Red Blood]

Originally posted by motorace_182
The guy is a freak. Noone can brake a pack open like this bloke can. He dominates the stoppages, even with tagging being such an overwhelming part of our game these days. You cannot say he isnt the best out there at the moment, he is phenominal. He may not hit the guy on the chest 10/10 like others can, but his pace, acceleration, and ability to read the footy off hands are unmatched at the moment.
I couldnt give a hoot who the commentators choose to get off over each week, but that shouldnt stop us from sitting back and marvelling at someone with such talent as there are only a few in every generation.

How much does that have to do with Big Cox's tap's though - Win's the ruck contest every time.

[NMWBloods]

taps
wins

Still, as good as Cox is, he doesn't make Judd. It's not like other teams with great ruckmen also have awesome midfielders.

[SheppSwanFan]

Originally posted by motorace_182
You cannot say he isnt the best out there at the moment, he is phenominal. He may not hit the guy on the chest 10/10 like others can, but his pace, acceleration, and ability to read the footy off hands are unmatched at the moment.

I can... Watch me.

He's not the best going around. There.

If I had to pick a player from West Coast to play with the Swans, there'd be 2 before Judd. (Cousins and Kerr) It's not hard to look good when you have the dominant ruckman in the league tapping it to you. Having said that, I do agree with his being a strong SOB and hard to stop, but If you're getting 27 possessions, IMHO 20 plus of those should go to advantage and I dont always see it from Chris Judd.

EDIT: Mind You, if he ever decides that he'd like to come and play footy for a real team instead of a bunch of backmen and midfielders, I'd happily give him a nice red and white jumper.

[goswannie14]

I like how you think SheppSwanFan.

BTW do you support the Shepp Swans too?

[SheppSwanFan]

Originally posted by goswannie14
I like how you think SheppSwanFan.

BTW do you support the Shepp Swans too?

God No! Unfortunately the Shepp Swans are well... evil swine.

Mooroopna supporter here.

[goswannie14]

I have just watched the "Sensational Swans" DVD, although Davis' goals in the semi were impressive, I think Micky O'Loughlin had the two best Swans goals for the year IMO. His off the ground effort against the Bulldogs was simply magnificent, closely followed by his off break against the Bummers at the Dome. Both wonderful efforts and truly spectacular in typical Micky O style

[dread and might]

Where are people watcing this goal of the year footage.

I can't seem to acess the "broadband features" multimedia on AFL.com even though i am a bigpond customer and have no trouble acessing the password bits of the site???

[Dave]

Originally posted by dread and might
Where are people watcing this goal of the year footage.

I can't seem to acess the "broadband features" multimedia on AFL.com even though i am a bigpond customer and have no trouble acessing the password bits of the site???

I'm viewing it from the AFL site.

[goswannie14]

Originally posted by dread and might
Where are people watcing this goal of the year footage.

I can't seem to acess the "broadband features" multimedia on AFL.com even though i am a bigpond customer and have no trouble acessing the password bits of the site???

I had to download a new part of Windows media player before I could watch it

[ScottH]

Originally posted by goswannie14
I had to download a new part of Windows media player before I could watch it

What "part"?

[goswannie14]

Originally posted by ScottH
What "part"?

Whatever the computer told me I needed to download before it would work, I did and it did...work that is

[dread and might]

emailed Afl.com and they actually got back to me pretty quickly. Mind you they passed the buck to microsoft and said that there was nothing they could do though they did suggest trying it through Internet explorer.

I just don't understand why all the other bits work.