AFL Team of the Year

[BeeEmmAre]

My Top 10 players after round 17.

1. Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda) 101
2. Simon Goodwin (Adelaide) 95
3. Brad Johnson (Western Bulldogs) 85
4. Scott West (Western Bulldogs) 80
5. Cameron Bruce (Melbourne) 79
5. Adam Goodes (Sydney) 79
7. Chris Judd (West Coast) 76
8. Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda) 74
9. Andrew McLeod (Adelaide) 72
10. Tyson Edwards (Adelaide) 71

SUPER SWANNIES

1. Goodesy 79
2. Hally 67
3. Judey 57
4. Kirky 52
5. Bucky 37
6. Snides 31
7. Rhino 26
8. Noggy 25
9. Craigy 21
10. Mickey 20

[BeeEmmAre]

My Top 10 after round 18

1. Simon Goodwin (Adelaide) 103
2. Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda) 101
3. Brad Johnson (Western Bulldogs) 85
4. Tyson Edwards (Adelaide) 81
5. Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda) 80
5. Scott West (Western Bulldogs) 80
7. Cameron Bruce (Melbourne) 79
7. Adam Goodes (Sydney) 79
9. Simon Black (Brisbane Lions) 78
10. Kane Cornes (Port Adelaide) 76
10. Barry Hall (Sydney) 76
10. Chris Judd (West Coast) 76

SUPER SWANNIES

1. #37 79
2. #1 76
3. #24 57
4. #31 52
5. #32 37
6. #20 35
7. #13 31
8. #5 29
9. #6 25
10. #19 20

[tara]

BMR where do Fev, Whitnall and Scotland feature on your list.

Curious for two reasons. Firstly Fev is by far and away the best FF this year considering the pathetic delivery he receives. Secondly just becuase of Whitnalls performing reasonable and Scotlands amount of possesions.

Also a fourth if I may - Where was Marc Murphy on the list prior to injury.

[BeeEmmAre]

Tara.

Fev is #29 with 56 points, Scotland is #36 with 49 points and Big Red is #52 with 43 points - yes, they are Carlton's top 3 players.

Murphy scored 24 points to round 12 when he got hurt, which ranked him #62 - equal to Heath Scotland at the same time.
He is now ranked #130.

For your interest, the Blues' list is as follows: Fevola 56, Scotland 49, Whitnall 43, Simpson 34, Stevens 29, Walker 24, Murphy 24, Lappin 21, Thornton 18, Houlihan 18, Bentick 16, Carrazzo 15, Waite 12, Koutoufides 11, Blackwell 8, McGrath 8, Wiggins 7, Betts 6, Fisher 3, Deluca 1.

[BeeEmmAre]

My Top 10 players after round 19

1. Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda) 111
2. Simon Goodwin (Adelaide) 103
3. Brad Johnson (Western Bulldogs) 92
4. Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda) 89
4. Adam Goodes (Sydney) 89
6. Tyson Edwards (Adelaide) 88
7. Scott West (Western Bulldogs) 84
7. Cameron Bruce (Melbourne) 84
9. Kane Cornes (Port Adelaide) 82
10. Chris Judd (West Coast) 81
10. Sam Mitchell (Hawthorn) 81

SUPER SWANNIES

1. Adam Goodes 89
2. Barry Hall 76
3. Brett Kirk 60
4. Jude Bolton 57
5. Amon Buchanan 37
6. Luke Ablett 35
7. Ryan O?Keefe 33
8. Adam Schneider 31
9. Craig Bolton 28
10. Michael O?Loughlin 20

[BeeEmmAre]

My Top 10 players after round 20.

AFL

1. Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda) 112
2. Simon Goodwin (Adelaide) 108
3. Brad Johnson (Western Bulldogs) 98
4. Scott West (Western Bulldogs) 94
5. Adam Goodes (Sydney) 93
6. Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda) 89
6. Tyson Edwards (Adelaide) 89
8. Sam Mitchell (Hawthorn) 84
8. Cameron Bruce (Melbourne) 84
10. Simon Black (Brisbane Lions) 83

SUPER SWANNIES

1. Adam Goodes 93
2. Barry Hall 76
3. Brett Kirk 60
4. Jude Bolton 58
5. Luke Ablett 43
6. Amon Buchanan 40
7. Ryan O?Keefe 40
8. Adam Schneider 31
9. Craig Bolton 28
10. Michael O?Loughlin 20

[BeeEmmAre]

My Top 10 players after round 21

AFL

1. Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda) 116
2. Simon Goodwin (Adelaide) 115
3. Brad Johnson (Western Bulldogs) 105
4. Adam Goodes (Sydney) 103
5. Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda) 98
6. Sam Mitchell (Hawthorn) 97
7. Scott West (Western Bulldogs) 94
8. Cameron Bruce (Melbourne) 92
9. Tyson Edwards (Adelaide) 92
10. Chris Judd (West Coast) 87

SUPER SWANNIES

1. Adam Goodes 103
2. Barry Hall 76
3. Jude Bolton 62
4. Brett Kirk 60
5. Ryan O?Keefe 49
6. Luke Ablett 43
7. Amon Buchanan 40
8. Adam Schneider 31
9. Craig Bolton 28
10. Michael O?Loughlin 20

[nomae]

IMO i reckon baz would be lucky to be AA this year, really.

[swans05]

wheres peter bell?

[BeeEmmAre]

Bazza's league rank is 17, so yes, he is sailing close to the cut off point for All Australian.

Peter Bell is just outside at No.11 on 85 points.

[NMWBloods]

Originally posted by nomae
IMO i reckon baz would be lucky to be AA this year, really.

Doesn't deserve it this year and won't get it. His second half has been just average.

[giant]

Originally posted by NMWBloods
Doesn't deserve it this year and won't get it. His second half has been just average.

Tend to agree, especially since he's been mainly playing FF, where Fev is the obvious candidate. FP is his really only chance & you'd think Johnson or Riewoldt would have better arguments.

[BeeEmmAre]

My final Top 10 players for season 2006.

1. Simon Goodwin (Adelaide) 124
2. Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda) 116
3. Brad Johnson (Western Bulldogs) 114
4. Adam Goodes (Sydney) 113
5. Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda) 108
6. Scott West (Western Bulldogs) 104
7. Sam Mitchell (Hawthorn) 103
8. Cameron Bruce (Melbourne) 99
9. Chris Judd (West Coast) 95
10. Tyson Edwards (Adelaide) 92


As such, the tips for the Brownlow Medal are as follows:

Simon Goodwin - winner
Nick Riewoldt - runner up
Brad Johnson - third

However, if you only take into account the best three players in each game instead of the best 10, it takes on a whole new look.
My Brownlow Top 10 in that instance would look pretty Good(es)(win)( ).

1. Adam Goodes (Sydney) 25
2. Simon Goodwin (Adelaide) 23
3. Brad Johnson (Western Bulldogs) 21
3. Scott West (Western Bulldogs) 21
5. Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda) 20
6. Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda) 19
7. Peter Bell (Fremantle) 16
8. Chris Judd (West Coast) 15
9. Cameron Bruce (Melbourne) 14
9. Tyson Edwards (Adelaide) 14


My selections for each clubs' best and fairests are as follows:

Adelaide: Simon Goodwin 124, Tyson Edwards 92, Andrew McLeod 82
Brisbane Lions: Simon Black 85, Luke Power 61, Jonathon Brown 54
Carlton: Brendan Fevola 64, Heath Scotland 57, Lance Whitnall 49
Collingwood: Nathan Buckley 78, Alan Didak 74, Ben Johnson 65
Essendon: Scott Lucas 58, James Hird 48, Jason Johnson 41
Fremantle: Peter Bell 85, Matthew Pavlich 67, Josh Carr 61
Geelong: Paul Chapman 71, Jimmy Bartel 65, Gary Ablett 57
Hawthorn: Sam Mitchell 103, Luke Hodge 80, Shane Crawford 54
Kangaroos: Brent Harvey 66, Nathan Thompson 63, Daniel Wells 62
Melbourne: Cameron Bruce 99, Travis Johnstone 58, David Neitz 49
Port Adelaide: Kane Cornes 87, Shaun Burgoyne 79, Brendon Lade 75
Richmond: Troy Simmonds 54, Matthew Richardson 49, Patrick Bowden 49
St Kilda: Nick Riewoldt 116, Nick Dal Santo 108, Robert Harvey 72
West Coast: Chris Judd 95, Ben Cousins 83, Daniel Kerr 66
Western Bulldogs: Brad Johnson 114, Scott West 104, Daniel Cross 58

And, of course, we can't forget the:

SUPER SWANNIES

1. Adam Goodes 113
2. Barry Hall 84
3. Brett Kirk 69
4. Jude Bolton 68
5. Ryan O?Keefe 56
6. Luke Ablett 43
7. Amon Buchanan 40
8. Adam Schneider 31
9. Craig Bolton 28
10. Michael O?Loughlin 20

[swantastic]

[QUOTE]Originally posted by BeeEmmAre
[B] If you only take into account the best three players in each game it looks like this....
My Brownlow Top 10 in that instance would look pretty Good(es)(win)( ).

1. Adam Goodes (Sydney) 25
2. Simon Goodwin (Adelaide) 23
3. Brad Johnson (Western Bulldogs) 21
3. Scott West (Western Bulldogs) 21
5. Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda) 20
6. Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda) 19
7. Peter Bell (Fremantle) 16
8. Chris Judd (West Coast) 15
9. Cameron Bruce (Melbourne) 14
9. Tyson Edwards (Adelaide) 14


Good work,thats what i like to see think you are pretty close.

[BeeEmmAre]

My 2006 All Australian Team

B: Cameron Bruce (Melbourne), Matthew Scarlett (Geelong), Kane Cornes (Port Adelaide)
HB: Sam Mitchell (Hawthorn), Lance Whitnall (Carlton), Daniel Kerr (West Coast)
C: Simon Goodwin (Adelaide), Scott West (Western Bulldogs, vc), Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda)
HF: Barry Hall (Sydney), Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda), Shaun Burgoyne (Port Adelaide)
F: Brad Johnson (Western Bulldogs), Brendan Fevola (Carlton), Matthew Pavlich (Fremantle)
FOLL: Brendon Lade (Port Adelaide), Adam Goodes (Sydney, c), Chris Judd (West Coast)
INTER: Troy Simmonds (Richmond), Tyson Edwards (Adelaide), Ben Cousins (West Coast), Simon Black (Brisbane Lions)
EMERG: Paul Chapman (Geelong), Robert Harvey (St Kilda), Peter Bell (Fremantle)
COACH: Paul Roos (Sydney)

Pit them up against my second best team.

B: Dane Swan (Collingwood), Nathan Bassett (Adelaide), Chad Cornes (Port Adelaide)
HB: Robert Harvey (St Kilda, vc), James Clement (Collingwood), Ben Johnson (Collingwood)
C: Josh Carr (Fremantle), Paul Chapman (Geelong, c), Andrew McLeod (Adelaide)
HF: Nathan Buckley (Collingwood), Johnathon Brown (Brisbane Lions), Luke Hodge (Hawthorn)
F: Nathan Thompson (Kangaroos), Fraser Gehrig (St Kilda), Danyle Pearce (Port Adelaide)
FOLL: Dean Cox (West Coast), Brett Kirk (Sydney), Peter Bell (Fremantle)
INTER: David Neitz (Melbourne), Heath Scotland (Carlton), Alan Didak (Collingwood), Jude Bolton (Sydney)
EMERG: Brent Harvey (Kangaroos), Daniel Cross (Western Bulldogs), Joel Corey (Geelong)
COACH: Chris Connolly (Fremantle)

Now that's a match I'd like to see.