Rnd 3 - Rate a Captain.

[ScottH]

Hall. 4/10. out classed in the 1st half again.

Kirk 6/10. plenty of ball, caused a bit of carnage, and got Fev outted.

Barry 5/10. Got plenty of the ball, and gave it straight back again. 18 uncontested marks.

[woo]

sorry Guys..I still think this 3 captain thing is silly....
choose one of them and put Jude Bolts in as vice...hes bloody tough and we all know he would do a great job in circa 2 years when the current clowns (and I say that with respect as I love all 3 of them) will be retiring...and heading towards the end of their careers.

[jude_boltons_babe]

Barry hall has to play heaps better

[satchmopugdog]

Adam goodes has played well as Captain in my opinion .....but I am on to the third bottle of champers.....Long Service Leave is the best thing since Paul Chambers!!!!!

[ROK Lobster]

Originally posted by jude_boltons_babe
Barry hall has to play heaps better

LAY OFF HIM. HE IS TRYING HIS HARDEST (on and off the bbq). YOU ARE STARTING TO MAKE ME ANGRY!!!

[satchmopugdog]

I'm with you ROK..But at the moment I don't think my opinion is worth much...the keys on the boarrd keep moving.

[liz]

Hall may not have had a great game by his standards, but he was still one of the most influential players out there.

I'd probably give them all a 6/10.

[woo]

I reckon Hall had a awesome game considering he was tagged by 2 players most of the night.....

we all have to give the big guy a break....

[Nico]

It is not Barry hall who is playing badly, it is the dopes up the ground who have a problem getting the ball into him quickly. The same dopes are too slow when in possession to pick up the quick leads. And it is not only Bazza's leads they are failing to respond to.

[NMWBloods]

Hall 6/10

Kirk 5/10

Barry 4/10

[goswannie14]

Originally posted by jude_boltons_babe
Barry hall has to play heaps better

That's almost the dumbest comment I've seen on this forum. Hall was in everything the other night. A CHF is not supposed to kick a bag of goals every week, but he is supposed to be setting up goals as well as kicking some. He did that on Saturday night despite the overcrowding ofCarlton in our forward 50.

Hall needs room to move, but the midfield, needs to deliver the bal into the forward line better than they are at the moment.

[stellation]

Originally posted by ROK Lobster
LAY OFF HIM. HE IS TRYING HIS HARDEST (on and off the bbq). YOU ARE STARTING TO MAKE ME ANGRY!!!

6/10, sorry I can't give you anymore; it is old but still funny.

[ROK Lobster]

Originally posted by stellation
6/10, sorry I can't give you anymore; it is old but still funny.

YOUR JUST AS BAD. LAY OFF OR ELSE I"LL TELL EVERYONE YOUR REALLY GEOFF DYMOCK

[Jeffers1984]

Leo 5.5/10 - Severly overated performance

Hall 5.5/10

Kirk 6.5/10

[Carolyn]

Leo Barry - 5/10

Brett Kirk - 6/10

Barry Hall - 6/10