Vote #1 - Paul Chambers

[Go Swannies]

Originally posted by NMWBloods
If the Eagles had one decent forward, they may be saying they have the silverware!

And what team wouldn't benefit from Judd in their side!

I'd settle for Kerr if Judd was unavailable.

[Agent 86]

Originally posted by Q...
Judd = Over rated posession accumulation machine

Now you're just being silly.

[C-Train]

Originally posted by Agent 86
Now you're just being silly.

Great player but seriously the commentators go overboard... saw an easy ball get and goal and they made it out to be the play of the century...

Thats why i think hes overrated but still in the top 5 players...

Personally if I had to chose between Hall and Judd...

GIVE ME BAZZA ANY DAY!

[Piobaireachd]

Originally posted by NMWBloods
If the Eagles had one decent forward, they may be saying they have the silverware!

And what team wouldn't benefit from Judd in their side!

If we had a Chris Judd in our team, no they wouldn't.

[barry]

Back on topic....

Does a tap ruckman need to gather a lot of possesions. Look at Harry Madden. Couldnt kick to save himself, took about 10 marks in his whole career, but extremely valuable ruckman, and look at him now.

I'm not defending Chambers. But Roos thinks he's doing the job required, and at this stage its good enough for me.

[NMWBloods]

I think his tapwork has been effective, particularly of late.

I don't believe the ruckman needs to get possessions, but he needs to negate the opposition ruckman and fall back to assist in the backline.

Chambers has improved in this area too, although still a lot of work to do.

[goswannie14]

Originally posted by NMWBloods
I think his tapwork has been effective, particularly of late.

I don't believe the ruckman needs to get possessions, but he needs to negate the opposition ruckman and fall back to assist in the backline.

Chambers has improved in this area too, although still a lot of work to do.

I agree with you 100% Bloods.

[ScottH]

Originally posted by NMWBloods
I think his tapwork has been effective, particularly of late.

I don't believe the ruckman needs to get possessions, but he needs to negate the opposition ruckman and fall back to assist in the backline.

Chambers has improved in this area too, although still a lot of work to do.

With the quality of Jolly's possessions/disposals of late, I wish he'd take a leaf out of Chambers book.

[dendol]

Originally posted by Q...
Judd = Over rated posession accumulation machine

I guess Goodes is a Brownlow-winning idiot for publicly stating that he is modelling his game on Judd (and Kouta).

[S.U.D]

Originally posted by dendol
I guess Goodes is a Brownlow-winning idiot for publicly stating that he is modelling his game on Judd (and Kouta).

I thought it was Roos who made the comment and I also thought it was Hird (and Kouta)!!

[giant]

Originally posted by barry
Back on topic....

Does a tap ruckman need to gather a lot of possesions. Look at Harry Madden. Couldnt kick to save himself, took about 10 marks in his whole career, but extremely valuable ruckman, and look at him now.

Torture for PM!!

[S.U.D]

Originally posted by giant
Torture for PM!!

You can't wish that on little Johnny in a public forum

[Jeffers1984]

I'm on the Torch Bandwagon. His Kamakazie efforts in the ruck and on the ground really impresses me.

[Ruck'n'Roll]

It's more sort of Kamikaze/Origami

He charges into the contest in like a mad thing but usually ends up folded into an unusual shape at the bottom of the pack.

[S.U.D]

Originally posted by Ruckman
It's more sort of Kamikaze/Origami

He charges into the contest in like a mad thing but usually ends up folded into an unusual shape at the bottom of the pack.

That mental image just got me into trouble at work for breaking into laughter.