Round 8: the other games

[imuninformedtwo]

Giants were dreadful, drop so many sitters. Pathetic kicks for set shots.
Whats happened to them ?

I know they've had injuries, but if I'm the AFL, I'm deeply worried about the Giants. They've got a list in transition, no real academy talent coming through (which wouldn't matter much these days anyway), getting two people and a dog to their games, and they'll be in a fringe state for a few years. They really have an even darker task trying to make it than ever before.

[Hotpotato]

Giants were dreadful, drop so many sitters. Pathetic kicks for set shots.
Whats happened to them ?

[dejavoodoo44]

While I don’t really want to see Greene get anything, it was bizarre that he didn't get 50, after Andrew rugby tackled him in the middle of the back.

[dejavoodoo44]

Looks like the punt that the Suns took with Ugle-Hagan is starting to pay off.

[Thunder Shaker]

If Gold Coast beat GWS with a score of 68 to 58, the ladder would be:
Geelong 5 wins, 791 for, 690 against
Gold Coast 5 wins, 791 for, 690 against

Very unlikely to happen, but not impossible. The AFL does have tie breakers that go beyond percentage but who knows what they are.

Half time score is currently 32 to 28 with both teams having awful accuracy in front of goal.

Could they really end at 68 to 58?

[dejavoodoo44]

Putting in the sort of performance, that will have Cody Walker standing up and saying, "Yeah, well, actually I was adopted."

Now that I think of it, I suppose a F/S prospect does have the right to say that they would prefer to go into the open draft? I know a few players have chosen between F/S and academy, but I don't think anyone has said that they think that the club is crap and that they'd rather try their luck elsewhere.

Actually, did Josh Dunkley more or less do that to us, because his father had a falling out with the club?

[dejavoodoo44]

Carlton doing their usual second half plummet against the Saints.

Putting in the sort of performance, that will have Cody Walker standing up and saying, "Yeah, well, actually I was adopted."

Now that I think of it, I suppose a F/S prospect does have the right to say that they would prefer to go into the open draft? I know a few players have chosen between F/S and academy, but I don't think anyone has said that they think that the club is crap and that they'd rather try their luck elsewhere.

[Thunder Shaker]

If Gold Coast beat GWS with a score of 68 to 58, the ladder would be:
Geelong 5 wins, 791 for, 690 against
Gold Coast 5 wins, 791 for, 690 against

Very unlikely to happen, but not impossible. The AFL does have tie breakers that go beyond percentage but who knows what they are.

[stevoswan]

Carlton doing their usual second half plummet against the Saints.

[stevoswan]

I haven't heard that much of Grundy speak, but he's supposed to be highly intelligent, with some esoteric intellectual pursuits.Which isn't exactly your stereotypical ruckman.

So you didn't watch this?

"It's where I need to be... playing for the Swans" - Grundy

He's super impressive!

[imuninformedtwo]

I haven't heard that much of Grundy speak, but he's supposed to be highly intelligent, with some esoteric intellectual pursuits. Which isn't exactly your stereotypical ruckman. Perhaps a bit like Reilly O'Brien, who has a masters in neuroscience, or something similar.

That’s true. But it was more a case of Grundy being able to articulate what he wanted to achieve in his career, why he felt Sydney might be a good fit, what he understood about our game plan and how comfortable he and his partner would be in Sydney (she’s a smart cookie herself). Whereas McKay barely asked a question, openly spoke about the potential money involved, and at one point womdered what the Swans would do about the risk he got home sick. Dumb as a brick.

[dejavoodoo44]

I tuned into the ABC Radio coverage of the last couple of minutes of the West Coast v Richmond game and was quite pleased to discover, that West Coast were having a reunion for their 2006 premiership side. After that loss, a waste water analysis of what's coming out of that function room might be interesting.

I really hope Cox didn't attend.

[dejavoodoo44]

Every club does this, but the McKay one had me in hysterics.

A real sliding doors moment for our club that one. Because he was dumb and greedy, and we weren’t prepared to go anywhere near Essendon’s offer, we dodged a bullet. Plus, my understanding is once he actually visited the club and left people deeply unimpressed, we all but withdrew our interest. Complete opposite to what happened with Grundy - once everyone met him, we went pulled out all stops.

I haven't heard that much of Grundy speak, but he's supposed to be highly intelligent, with some esoteric intellectual pursuits. Which isn't exactly your stereotypical ruckman. Perhaps a bit like Reilly O'Brien, who has a masters in neuroscience, or something similar.

[imuninformedtwo]

There's now a minor controversy, after somebody photographed the whiteboard that contained the Brisbane assessment of the Essendon players strengths and weaknesses, and then released it via social media.

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-2026-brisbane-lions-whiteboard-notes-about-essendon-leaked-online-st-kildas-max-king-injures-hamstring-in-vfl/news-story/73ccd784890b108c40077b5f078b8249

I find some of them quite amusing: a blank space for McKay's strengths and it looks like they decided that Prior's strength was his girlfriend.

Every club does this, but the McKay one had me in hysterics.

A real sliding doors moment for our club that one. Because he was dumb and greedy, and we weren’t prepared to go anywhere near Essendon’s offer, we dodged a bullet. Plus, my understanding is once he actually visited the club and left people deeply unimpressed, we all but withdrew our interest. Complete opposite to what happened with Grundy - once everyone met him, we went pulled out all stops.

[Thunder Shaker]

This is an interesting round so far with several close games. Draw, 12 points, 1 point, Richmond up by 4 at 3/4 time and North Melbourne leading Geelong by 1 in the third quarter.

Then there's Essendon being Essendon, losing by 64 points.