Match thread: Sydney Swans v St Kilda June 7 2026 03:15 PM AEST @ SCG

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • neilfws
    Senior Player
    • Aug 2009
    • 1867

    #91
    I do love a heist, more so when it's my team. They found a way to win despite missing/losing some important players.

    Saints certainly brought their best game yesterday and Swans were slow to respond - that's all it takes for things not to go as expected! The crowd never gave up hope though, which is something I've noticed a few times this season when the Swans have been on the back foot. There's a belief in the win, inspired in large part by Heeney I think, who is the ultimate competitor. Agree that McDonald really stood up yesterday too, a great game from him. Rowbottom really influential too.

    We had Serong, Cleary, Corey Warner and Jevan Phillipou up at our junior club this week - all great young blokes who interacted with our kids really well - so I was happy to see Serong have his moment.

    I said to the family early in the fourth that the Swans were going to steal it at the death having been behind all game - and I could just have easily been wrong as right - but I won that 50/50!

    The young defenders rightly praised by Cox in his press conference, Kyle and Edwards both did well with McCartin down. I noted that Snell's name came up in the potential names for next week.

    Comment

    • dejavoodoo44
      Veterans List
      • Apr 2015
      • 9557

      #92
      Originally posted by neilfws
      I do love a heist, more so when it's my team. They found a way to win despite missing/losing some important players.

      Saints certainly brought their best game yesterday and Swans were slow to respond - that's all it takes for things not to go as expected! The crowd never gave up hope though, which is something I've noticed a few times this season when the Swans have been on the back foot. There's a belief in the win, inspired in large part by Heeney I think, who is the ultimate competitor. Agree that McDonald really stood up yesterday too, a great game from him. Rowbottom really influential too.

      We had Serong, Cleary, Corey Warner and Jevan Phillipou up at our junior club this week - all great young blokes who interacted with our kids really well - so I was happy to see Serong have his moment.

      I said to the family early in the fourth that the Swans were going to steal it at the death having been behind all game - and I could just have easily been wrong as right - but I won that 50/50!

      The young defenders rightly praised by Cox in his press conference, Kyle and Edwards both did well with McCartin down. I noted that Snell's name came up in the potential names for next week.
      I actually thought that Windhager did a pretty good job tagging Heeney, but many people think that Heeney was BOG. Which points to how tough and determined Heeney is these days.

      And even though I've seen plenty of Kyle and Edwards at academy level, I've been pleasantly surprised by how good they've been at AFL level. I think Kyle has improved his disposal efficiency and he's more likely to hit the right target, while it seems to me that Edwards has improved his agility and he's probably now deceptively quick over 10 or 20 metres.

      Comment

      • UUaswan
        Senior Player
        • Sep 2024
        • 1049

        #93
        Originally posted by neilfws
        I do love a heist, more so when it's my team. They found a way to win despite missing/losing some important players.

        Saints certainly brought their best game yesterday and Swans were slow to respond - that's all it takes for things not to go as expected! The crowd never gave up hope though, which is something I've noticed a few times this season when the Swans have been on the back foot. There's a belief in the win, inspired in large part by Heeney I think, who is the ultimate competitor. Agree that McDonald really stood up yesterday too, a great game from him. Rowbottom really influential too.

        We had Serong, Cleary, Corey Warner and Jevan Phillipou up at our junior club this week - all great young blokes who interacted with our kids really well - so I was happy to see Serong have his moment.

        I said to the family early in the fourth that the Swans were going to steal it at the death having been behind all game - and I could just have easily been wrong as right - but I won that 50/50!

        The young defenders rightly praised by Cox in his press conference, Kyle and Edwards both did well with McCartin down. I noted that Snell's name came up in the potential names for next week.
        I like Rowy but if he had 8 kicks 6 of them were smothered
        Never question his effort but wasnt his best day

        I'm really starting to think that when Ramps comes back, Mills needs to go more midfield.
        Need him and Rowy under the ball, Mills in open space hasnt been great

        Comment

        • Sandridge
          Outer wing, Lake Oval
          • Apr 2010
          • 2259

          #94
          Still on a huge high from yesterday's great win!

          I've watch the "Last 2 Minutes" video on the club website numerous times and we got everything right! (Well, except for Nick's kick to Silvagni who managed to take 13 seconds off the clock with "cramp."

          The play that led to the final goal was a thing of beauty, reminiscent of Ball to Davis in the 2005 SF, Ball to Buchanan in the 2005 GF and Grundy to Gulden in our win against St.Kilda at Marvel last year.

          Grundy's tap to Isaac was magnificent, Isaac thought of handballing to Rowy but then spotted Serong and Jai finished it off! The jubilation from the players, the fans and those in the coachs' box was exhilarating!

          I'll bask in the glow of this win for a few days and worry about us being seriously undermanned for our next game later in the week.

          GO BLOODS!!



          Comment

          • MattW
            Veterans List
            • May 2011
            • 4270

            #95
            Originally posted by Nico

            He's too old at 23 for a Rising Star nomination. Now Harry Kyle might be different. No one has mentioned him. I thought he was darn good. He doesn't seem to make many mistakes and has courage in spades. I also think Roberts was short of a run, even though he covered more ground than anyone.
            Ah, thanks.

            Certainly agree re Kyle. He is making good decisions and using it well under pressure. 85% efficiency and no turnovers. His class is already evident. There was another lovely sweeping handball chain with Heeney through the middle.

            Comment

            • Thunder Shaker
              Aut vincere aut mori
              • Apr 2004
              • 4631

              #96
              It is good to get the win, but the Saints played bad football in the last few minutes. Their idea of saving a game is to stack the backline for the last few minutes and hope to keep the ball out. That doesn't work. If all players are inside the defensive 50, that's where the ball will be. A kick for goal will be likely. Kicking out to space doesn't work either. If the opponents are aware of this, they will keep players outside to get the ball and kick it back. They should have tried to get possession and kick it to their players, not vast open spaces guarded by opponents.

              They have kicked goals and the lead is down to five. We have packed the backline but cannot hold them for long. The crowd cheers ... booing, booing in the outer. We cannot keep it out. A shadow moves over the sun. We cannot keep it out. They are coming. (with apologies to Jackson and Tolkien)
              "Unbelievable!" -- Nick Davis leaves his mark on the 2005 semi final

              Comment

              • imuninformedtwo
                Regular in the Side
                • Aug 2024
                • 888

                #97
                Originally posted by dejavoodoo44

                I actually thought that Windhager did a pretty good job tagging Heeney, but many people think that Heeney was BOG. Which points to how tough and determined Heeney is these days.

                And even though I've seen plenty of Kyle and Edwards at academy level, I've been pleasantly surprised by how good they've been at AFL level. I think Kyle has improved his disposal efficiency and he's more likely to hit the right target, while it seems to me that Edwards has improved his agility and he's probably now deceptively quick over 10 or 20 metres.
                Heeney was bonkers tough. 30 possies, 11 contested, 6 tackles, 10 score involvements, 2 goals and of course the final give - all with a bloke hanging off him in a way that Isaac will be giving birth in 9 months.

                The difference for me though is how clean he stays. And some of those left foot kicks down the outer side wing in the final quarter, only he can do. Let alone the late switch to a left handed handball to Serong.

                Comment

                • stellation
                  scott names the planets
                  • Sep 2003
                  • 9754

                  #98
                  Originally posted by imuninformedtwo

                  Heeney was bonkers tough. 30 possies, 11 contested, 6 tackles, 10 score involvements, 2 goals and of course the final give - all with a bloke hanging off him in a way that Isaac will be giving birth in 9 months.

                  The difference for me though is how clean he stays. And some of those left foot kicks down the outer side wing in the final quarter, only he can do. Let alone the late switch to a left handed handball to Serong.
                  That final goal with a couple of guys being able to use the wrong side of their body immediately had me thinking “Gerard must be smiling!”.
                  I knew him as a gentle young man, I cannot say for sure the reasons for his decline
                  We watched him fade before our very eyes, and years before his time

                  Comment

                  • stellation
                    scott names the planets
                    • Sep 2003
                    • 9754

                    #99
                    I loved the resilience overall to work through a poor start and what must have been a pretty rattling moment with Tom going off the ground to get the win.

                    Wonderful performances from some of our up and comers. Jai obviously a great moment with the game winner, but he was solid all game. Edwards was a rock down back, sometimes literally- in one marking contest he had a mismatch with Ryan who tried to push him off balance and it was like he was pushing a brick wall.

                    Logan’s game reminded me of peak pre-move to the midfield ROK (is hot), and as Simon Day once said that ain’t bad! I was surprised to see he was only credited with 2 contested marks. Don’t make him burn energy as a second ruck unless it’s a break glass moment, let him roam as a CHF n big leading patterns and use his ability to read the game as he sees fit- how good was his anticipation to cut short the quick outlet kick out of defence by the Saints and give off a quick handball that I think ended up with Chad’s goal?
                    I knew him as a gentle young man, I cannot say for sure the reasons for his decline
                    We watched him fade before our very eyes, and years before his time

                    Comment

                    • UUaswan
                      Senior Player
                      • Sep 2024
                      • 1049

                      Originally posted by stellation

                      Logan’s game reminded me of peak pre-move to the midfield ROK (is hot), and as Simon Day once said that ain’t bad! I was surprised to see he was only credited with 2 contested marks. Don’t make him burn energy as a second ruck unless it’s a break glass moment, let him roam as a CHF n big leading patterns and use his ability to read the game as he sees fit- how good was his anticipation to cut short the quick outlet kick out of defence by the Saints and give off a quick handball that I think ended up with Chad’s goal?
                      Logan free to roam up the ground with a 3 permanent Fwd attack

                      Who would have @@@@ing thought !!!!!!!!

                      That is his role, he is more Reiwolt than Plugger

                      Comment

                      • Auntie.Gerald
                        Veterans List
                        • Oct 2009
                        • 6597

                        Thoughts on Harry Kyle’s first AFL game ?
                        "be tough, only when it gets tough"

                        Comment

                        • Hotpotato
                          Senior Player
                          • Jun 2014
                          • 2334

                          On form the Swans should have won by 5-6 goals. However
                          the Saints had nothing to lose by playing w flair, freedom and fast. co

                          Comment

                          • imuninformedtwo
                            Regular in the Side
                            • Aug 2024
                            • 888

                            Originally posted by stellation
                            I loved the resilience overall to work through a poor start and what must have been a pretty rattling moment with Tom going off the ground to get the win.

                            Wonderful performances from some of our up and comers. Jai obviously a great moment with the game winner, but he was solid all game. Edwards was a rock down back, sometimes literally- in one marking contest he had a mismatch with Ryan who tried to push him off balance and it was like he was pushing a brick wall.

                            Logan’s game reminded me of peak pre-move to the midfield ROK (is hot), and as Simon Day once said that ain’t bad! I was surprised to see he was only credited with 2 contested marks. Don’t make him burn energy as a second ruck unless it’s a break glass moment, let him roam as a CHF n big leading patterns and use his ability to read the game as he sees fit- how good was his anticipation to cut short the quick outlet kick out of defence by the Saints and give off a quick handball that I think ended up with Chad’s goal?
                            Only we old farts get the ROK is hot reference.

                            Comment

                            • grarmy
                              Warming the Bench
                              • Aug 2010
                              • 409

                              Originally posted by stevoswan

                              Apparently Ladhams played another blinder in the two's with the insane stats of 35 touches, 25 hitouts, 10 clearances, seven score involvements, eight marks and six inside-50s......wow!

                              I was so disappointed when he got dropped this week.
                              OMG! Finally something we can agree on. Wrong decision to play Melican over Ladhams. Melican was, as so often happens, out of touch and a metre off the pace. Ladhams is pretty average as a forward but he is greatly improved as a mark and ball user. Still an iffy kick but he would have been a far better option than Melican. I would be ticked off if he did not get a call up next week when we play is former side, Port.
                              "Play like you can’t lose."

                              Comment

                              • BRS328
                                Warming the Bench
                                • Feb 2018
                                • 488

                                Originally posted by dejavoodoo44

                                I actually thought that Windhager did a pretty good job tagging Heeney, but many people think that Heeney was BOG. Which points to how tough and determined Heeney is these days.

                                And even though I've seen plenty of Kyle and Edwards at academy level, I've been pleasantly surprised by how good they've been at AFL level. I think Kyle has improved his disposal efficiency and he's more likely to hit the right target, while it seems to me that Edwards has improved his agility and he's probably now deceptively quick over 10 or 20 metres.
                                I think you have to acknowledge the great job Colin Oriordan did as head coach of the academy in recent years and likewise Nick Malceski is doing with the VFL Team. Players are stepping up to the higher grade and appear ready for the challenge. You only have to look at the VFL team and you can see the fast ball movement has been drummed into them

                                Comment

                                Working...