Tweet
Malceski is our lucky charm why would we trade him???
-
"I feel it in my fingers i feel it in my toes... Sydney Swans are all around me and there everywhere i go. A premiership is there beside me and thats all i know"
Only $1 for a cornetto that is DAYLIGHT SAVINGS!!!!! -
Re: Hawks - Tell em they're dreaming!
Now that you've worked up almost the entire board into a hysterical panic about the possibilty of Malceski being traded for Spida, would you care to tell us where you heard this (aka your source)? Or did you just throw in Malceski's name for effect (which appears to have worked very well)?Originally posted by Bas
So the Dorks want either a 1st or 2nd round pick or someone like Malceski for Everitt.
Settle down people - there's no evidence whatsoever that Malceski will be traded for anyone.Last edited by cruiser; 4 October 2006, 09:57 PM.Occupational hazards:
- animal psychic Amanda de WarrenI don't eat animals since discovering this ability. I used to. But one day the lamb I was eating came through to me and ever since then I haven't been able to eat meat.Comment
-
today's age quotes malceski as being a prospect for hawthorn with picks...edited after belatedly reading guides for posting..sorry modsLast edited by royboy42; 4 October 2006, 09:48 PM.Comment
-
They might not be trying to be cute or unreasonable but they are being both cute and unreasonable.Originally posted by royboy42
today's age quotes malceski as being a prospect for hawthorn with picks...edited after belatedly reading guides for posting..sorry mods
Hopefully the leadership group don't mortgage our future in a personal quest for atonement. I think we have the tools for a repeat bid already and I really do think Everitt would come through via the PSD.
If we were to trade enything more than a second round pick, I would be staggered (and mightily dissappointed).He had observed that people who did lie were, on the whole, more resourceful and ambitious and successful than people who did not lie.Comment
-
I think it's worth remembering that Malceski was a name dropped by the Hawks. Last year they started off by wanting Jude Bolton for Spida...and that wasn't going to happen either.Comment
-
Didn't we have this discussion a year ago? I might have said yes then, but I think he's too old, now. I'm backing Jolly and Doyle to be our ruck combo for 2007, with Earl Shaw (he'd have to be ready for the seniors soon) or possibly Eriksen as backup. And trading Malceski would be insane.Comment
-
Hearing that the leadership (Leo Barry) saying they would want him. & that Barry Hall is a very good friend of Spida & he really want him.
I just hope that the leadership group don't have the final say.
Cos if it was Nick could be traded!!Comment
-
Malcheski will shorely not be traded.
As someone has already said this talk is a knee jerk reaction to a disappointing effort by Jolly in the GF.
When Doyle had to stand up to Cox in the last quarter he did, with a few more games will prove his worth. Jolly must be one of the top 5 ruckman in the league.
If Everitt came to Sydney I would be suprised if Doyle stayed. This year is his do or die year - to see whether he can cut it week in - week out against the best the league have to offer.
It would be disappointing for him (and me) if he was pushed to No.3 ruckman.The eternal connundrum "what happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object" was finally solved when David Hasselhoff punched himself in the face.Comment
-
I agree. 2007 should be Doyle's year to stand up. It would seem surprising and disappointing to get rid of him now ( he would surely leave if Spida came to town),just as he seems to be coming into his own. If he can hold up as far as injuries are concerned, he is a much better long term prospect for us than the old guy.Originally posted by Bloody Hell
Malcheski will shorely not be traded.
As someone has already said this talk is a knee jerk reaction to a disappointing effort by Jolly in the GF.
When Doyle had to stand up to Cox in the last quarter he did, with a few more games will prove his worth. Jolly must be one of the top 5 ruckman in the league.
If Everitt came to Sydney I would be suprised if Doyle stayed. This year is his do or die year - to see whether he can cut it week in - week out against the best the league have to offer.
It would be disappointing for him (and me) if he was pushed to No.3 ruckman.Comment
-
Agree with all the comments about 2007 being Donkey's year. If he can have a full pre-season and go into the year in peak fitness then he is basically a gun new recruit.
Given we are looking to bolster our ruck division, there is NO way Doyle will be traded. I think Roos has come round to the thinking that you need 3 top ruckmen in your squad. So Doyle stays.
Can someone confirm that Amon has re-signed? The rumour that he wants to head back to Melbourne won't go away, as unlikely as it sounds.
Could we trade Mathews or Spriggs to Brisbane for a 2nd round pick (they desperately will need experienced players) and on-trade to the Hawks for Spida??"As everyone knows our style of football is defensive and unattractive, and as such I have completely forgotten how to mark or kick over the years" - Brett Kirk
Comment
-
I think the most likely player traded for Spida will be Vogels. Which would be a good trade for all involved.
He isnt getting game time in teh seniors, and the role he plays has been filled. He would be second in line for the forward line after H Grundy. His trial on teh backline, whislt he was good, but the role has been taken now by Ted.
He goes to the hawks, who coudl do with a tallish forward, where he will get more game time. We get Spida.. everyone is happy...season 2012- top 4 here we comeComment
-
Fair and balanced common sense opinions free of emotion are not welcome here!Originally posted by cowcar
I think the most likely player traded for Spida will be Vogels. Which would be a good trade for all involved.
He isnt getting game time in teh seniors, and the role he plays has been filled. He would be second in line for the forward line after H Grundy. His trial on teh backline, whislt he was good, but the role has been taken now by Ted.
He goes to the hawks, who coudl do with a tallish forward, where he will get more game time. We get Spida.. everyone is happy...
PS I agree with you.I hear not what you say, for the thunder of who you are.Comment
-
I would love to have this rumour quashed. Anybody???Originally posted by hammo
Can someone confirm that Amon has re-signed? The rumour that he wants to head back to Melbourne won't go away, as unlikely as it sounds.
It can't be true can it? Who would want to leave the Swans in the middle of this amazing ride?Comment
-
....a midget melbournite??I'm Flyin' High...Comment
-
Vogels said his manager was currently in negotiations with the Swans working out another contract.
``The Swans have indicated I'm a required player so we're just working through that,'' he said.
``I'd like a two-year deal, but we'll wait and see.''
"As everyone knows our style of football is defensive and unattractive, and as such I have completely forgotten how to mark or kick over the years" - Brett Kirk
Comment
Comment