Best and Fairest etc

[ItsAllGoodes]

Tomorrow night is the Swans Club Champion Dinner

It will probably be no surprise as to who wins the B& F but who do people think will be:

The Top 3 in the B&F
The Most Improved
Best First Year Player
Best Clubman

I will go for:

1. Goodsey 2 C Bolton 3 Hall (4 Okeefe)
Most Improved - Jarrad McVeigh, just ahead of Malceski
Best First Year - Heath Grundy
Best Clubman - David Spriggs

[Frog]

1 - Adam Goodes 2 - Barry Hall 3 - Jude Bolton (4 - Ryan O'Keefe)
Most Improved - Darren Jolly
Best First Year - Heath Grundy
Best Clubman - Brett Kirk

[swansrock4eva]

Isn't Malceski elligible as well for best first year? I thought the criteria included that it could be second year but <10 matches previous or something? Similar to the Rising Star award?

[strange]

best finals player? awarded to crouch last year IIRC

[gossipcom]

I don't know why but I feel like Teddy could pop up in the voting for Finals - either he or Goodes.

[katie-scarlett]

Originally posted by gossipcom
I don't know why but I feel like Teddy could pop up in the voting for Finals - either he or Goodes.

So concur.

Is there any real competition to vs Grundy for best first year?

[Frog]

Originally posted by katie-scarlett
Is there any real competition to vs Grundy for best first year?

Phillips ??? Torture ???

On second thought, nah ...

[benny_w]

Barry Hall or Brett kirk will be best finals players

[swansrock4eva]

Mickey or Teddy for mine in Finals.

Goodesy for B&F tho.

[Mike_B]

Goodes, C Bolton and ROK to share the placings for the B&F

Grundy best 1st year player
McVeigh most improved
No idea best clubman.
MOL best finals player.

[swantastic]

Originally posted by Mike_B
Goodes, C Bolton and ROK to share the placings for the B&F

Grundy best 1st year player
McVeigh most improved
No idea best clubman.
MOL best finals player.

Mike 1 addition Special K for best clubman.

[liz]

Originally posted by benny_w
Barry Hall or Brett kirk will be best finals players

Kirky.

Baz was probably in the lead going into the GF but even if they thought he was that far ahead after the first two finals, it would be a complete embarrassment for Hall to give it to him with him being so dirty on himself for his game on Saturday.

[j s]

Grundy only played 6 games Not enough I think to be named best first year player.

Malceski for me on this one (assuming he's eligible - had 5 games pre 2006 - the award is called "Rising Star" so presumably has similar criteria)

[ItsAllGoodes]

OK folks Rising Star it is...and on that basis it has to be Malceski

[OldE]

Isn't Eski too old for Rising Star? He's 22, IIRC.