What about Ray Hall?

[cruiser]

Is he still a wanted player at Tigerland? Is he playing well enough to make a useful addition to our defence. Is it time another greater Sydney (actually Woy Woy!!) boy returned home?

[punter257]

personally i'd let him go through to gilly

[Nico]

Re: What about Ray Hall?

Originally posted by cruiser
Is he still a wanted player at Tigerland? Is he playing well enough to make a useful addition to our defence. Is it time another greater Sydney (actually Woy Woy!!) boy returned home?

How come this hack gets brought up in trade week every year on this site as a possible pick up for us.

For once for all he is very, very ordinary.

[robbieando]

Re: Re: What about Ray Hall?

Originally posted by Nico
How come this hack gets brought up in trade week every year on this site as a possible pick up for us.

Because everyone thinks that if a player is from NSW that they MUST have some sort of use for use regardless of how useless that player might really be.

People for once and for all let only target the GOOD PLAYERS from NSW that aren't already at the Swans. Why do we want a team full of Chambers-like hacks for???

[Layby]

Re: Re: Re: What about Ray Hall?

Originally posted by robbieando
Because everyone thinks that if a player is from NSW that they MUST have some sort of use for use regardless of how useless that player might really be.

People for once and for all let only target the GOOD PLAYERS from NSW that aren't already at the Swans. Why do we want a team full of Chambers-like hacks for???

I think the overuse of use only has a use if the use intended is useful. Otherwise, the overuse of use can prove useless and distract from the use for which it was intended.

Dont you ?

[cruiser]

Re: Re: What about Ray Hall?

Originally posted by Nico
How come this hack gets brought up in trade week every year on this site as a possible pick up for us.

Just to stir up some discussion. What's trade week without a Ray Hall thread? And we Coasters like to care about our own.

[barry]

Playfair, Ray Hall, are just different versions of LRT and Ted Richards.

I dont see a lot to be gained by trading for them, and I prefer the ones we've got.

[giant]

Re: Re: Re: What about Ray Hall?

Originally posted by robbieando
Because everyone thinks that if a player is from NSW that they MUST have some sort of use for use regardless of how useless that player might really be.

For the same reason all AFL bad boys are seen as great trade targets for the Swans by some on this site.

[Chow-Chicker]

Here's a simple description - dud. In fact, the whole trade period reminds me of the old trash 'n' treasure. There is just a helluvalot of trash and very, very little treasure. Just about all the names bandied around is junk. Those I consider of some value are Akermanis, Bradshaw and Notting. Hey guess what? All Brizzy boys!!! The rest is trash. Trade for picks I say.

[NMWBloods]

Originally posted by barry
Playfair, Ray Hall, are just different versions of LRT and Ted Richards.

I dont see a lot to be gained by trading for them

Nice summary.

[cruiser]

Originally posted by barry
Playfair, Ray Hall, are just different versions of LRT and Ted Richards.

I dont see a lot to be gained by trading for them, and I prefer the ones we've got.

You have a problem with Ted Richards and/or our trade last year for getting him?

[adnar]

Re: Re: Re: What about Ray Hall?

Originally posted by cruiser
Just to stir up some discussion. What's trade week without a Ray Hall thread?

Needs more Fosdike to Adelaide, but I think there's already one of those. And Trade saddin...oh

[nomae]

what about ray hall?
the best thing i remember about him is that he ran too far in a game against us in 2002. (we lost)

[giant]

Re: Re: Re: Re: What about Ray Hall?

Originally posted by adnar
Needs more Fosdike to Adelaide, but I think there's already one of those. And Trade saddin...oh

Nice....

[barry]

Originally posted by NMWBloods
Nice summary.

Thanks,

You deleted my last phrase "I prefer the ones weve got". Any reason ?