Who should retire or be traded

[hammo]

Crouch, Mathews, L.Barry should retire.

Hall should have a rest, get fit and get used to the new rules.

Bevan should be delisted.

J.Bolton traded.

McVeigh needs to be given an attacking role. If we cut a swathe through the list he'll be needed.

[Missy]

Retirees:


MOL - (retire gracefully)

I believe we can only have one either MOL or BBH to keep balance in fwd line

You'd keep BBH over MOL? No way. BBH looked nervous tonight. He's lost it and Im sick of using his injuires as an excuse.

[Guzzitza]

The question is, if said players are delisted/traded... How long will Roos stick around? We know he only wants to be coaching with his favourites still in action...once this group moves on, so is he - great commitment.

[Robbo]

Jolly is a quality player but if he doesn't want to be there then he's as good as Jarrad Sundqvist.

We would get a first rounder for him so we should definitely look at trading him.

[Sanecow]

Micky was actually great tonight

He @@@@s me but at least he can actually play the game.

[Missy]

Who gives a @@@@. Roos can go too. If he was the super coach he has been in the past few years, he would have adapted to other teams ability to read our play this year. His tactics and game plan are old.

[Mike_B]

Who gives a @@@@. Roos can go too. If he was the super coach he has been in the past few years, he would have adapted to other teams ability to read our play this year. His tactics and game plan are old.

Him AND his buddies in the coaches box. Just way too rigid.

[ugg]

It's all John Blakey's fault. Forward line has sucked since he arrived. Or that new runner, he has been pretty dodgy as of late.

[sprite]

You'd keep BBH over MOL? No way. BBH looked nervous tonight. He's lost it and Im sick of using his injuires as an excuse.

I'm saying to have balance in the fwd line - you can only have one.

Last week showed the way

If you go with Barry - MOL retires ( as I cannot see him being there for long haul).

Barry has at least 4 seasons - MOL maybe 1..

[Goal Sneak]

Gone = Bevan, McVeigh, J Bolton, Matthews, Crouch
Last Chance = Fosdike, Barry, Dempster, Hall, Schneider, Davis, Roos
Keepers = Mal, Kirk, Goodes, Mikey O, ROK, Ted, C Bolton, Schmidt, LRT, Kennelly

If Hall has another season like 2007, he should start boxing. Lets rebuild our midfield with some talented players who can get their hands on the ball and deliver it into the forward line accuratley. Time for Roos to think up a new game plan, if he can't, and persists with the same old players, he should go too.

[Bas]

I think the following will be delisted:

1. Grundy;
2. Vogels;
3. Jack (prmoted rookie)
4. Phillips;
5. Simpkin.
6. Doyle. Except I think they might keep him with jolly leaving.
7. Bevan.

They should trade:
1. Jolly, hopefully a top ten pick;
2. McVeigh
3. J Bolten
4. Ablett,
5. Buchanen.

Realistically, the only trade I expect is Jolly. The others I'm guessing.

The Swans need to bottom out for a year or trade early picks.

Waste of a year.

[Layby]

We lost the game for a number of reasons, but one major one was the ruck.

Spida was awful yet he does not get a mention

Collingwood have one ruckman who was coming back from injury and played only 60 % of game in the ruck

hmmm do you guys actually watch the game.

the other reason was Roos refusing to change a dysfunctional forward line,

O'keefe hardly had a kick should we trade him ?

Davis was not in the game should he have been left there ?

BBBH was unfit and sadly out of form should he have played ?

The interesting one was Craig Bolton, awful tonight, i reckon he should be traded.

[sprite]

Crouch, Mathews, L.Barry should retire.

Hall should have a rest, get fit and get used to the new rules.

Bevan should be delisted.

J.Bolton traded.

McVeigh needs to be given an attacking role. If we cut a swathe through the list he'll be needed.

I don't believe Jude has much currency on the open market these days to attract a reasonable selection or player

[sprite]

[QUOTE=Goal Sneak;332855]Gone = Bevan, McVeigh, J Bolton, Matthews, Crouch
Last Chance = Fosdike, Barry, Dempster, Hall, Schneider, Davis, Roos
Keepers = Mal, Kirk, Goodes, Mikey O, ROK, Ted, C Bolton, Schmidt, LRT, Kennelly

Disagree on McVeigh.

Disagree on Dempster - he has the ability to play taller, can deliver the ball. Has had limited game time this year

[doctor swan]

B1 is rated in Melb lets trade him to anyone who ll have him, maybe we can do a Sheedy and con them into a high draft pick