Let's dream for a minute...

[JudesaGun]

To a time in the near future (hopefully) where our best is available and we can field this squad:

BACKS
Jack Barry Richards
Kennelly Bolton Mattner

CENTRES
Malceski Moore McVeigh

FORWARDS
O'Keefe Hall Barlow
Davis O'Loughlin Buchanan

RUCKS
Jolly Kirk Goodes

Interchange
Everitt Ablett LRT Bolton

[Mogg0]

Jack in the backline? He's 4 foot-nothing. Purely a midfielder.

Here's mine, with changes in italics.

BACKS
Bolton Barry Richards
Kennelly Malceski Mattner

CENTRES
Kirk Jack Moore Goodes

FORWARDS
O'Keefe Hall Barlow
Davis O'Loughlin Buchanan

RUCKS
Jolly Everitt

Interchange
McVeigh Ablett LRT J Bolton

[JudesaGun]

Jack in the backline? He's 4 foot-nothing. Purely a midfielder.

Here's mine, with changes in italics.

BACKS
Bolton Barry Richards
Kennelly Malceski Mattner

CENTRES
Kirk Jack Moore Goodes

FORWARDS
O'Keefe Hall Barlow
Davis O'Loughlin Buchanan

RUCKS
Jolly Everitt

Interchange
McVeigh Ablett LRT J Bolton

Jack is a tagger and although rotates through the midfield is named in the backlne most weeks and often plays through there (depending on opposition).

And you're short a centre.

[BSA5]

BACKS
Jack Barry Richards
Kennelly Bolton Mattner

CENTRES
Malceski McVeigh Goodes

FORWARDS
O'Keefe Hall Barlow
Bird O'Loughlin Buchanan

RUCKS
Jolly Kirk Moore

Interchange
Everitt Ablett LRT Bevan

I would rather see this lineup. I've underlined outright changes to your side, and italicised shifts in positioning within the side.

[connolly]

To a time in the near future (hopefully) where our best is available and we can field this squad:

BACKS
Jack Barry Richards
Kennelly Bolton Mattner

CENTRES
Malceski Moore McVeigh

FORWARDS
O'Keefe Hall Barlow
Davis O'Loughlin Buchanan

RUCKS
Jolly Kirk Goodes

Interchange
Everitt Ablett LRT Bolton

Davis - you are having a laugh right? And Buchanon is no longer in the best 22. Jack to the midfield, Bevo to defense/pinch hitting, Moore as a small forward and Playfair as a tall forward and Barlow to the midfield and thats about right.

[JudesaGun]

Davis - you are having a laugh right? And Buchanon is no longer in the best 22. Jack to the midfield, Bevo to defense/pinch hitting, Moore as a small forward and Playfair as a tall forward and Barlow to the midfield and thats about right.

If Davis gets his act together, he's in. Playfair is not in our best 22, Buchanan is easily. Still don't rate Bevan and never will. Barlow is more of a goal kicking half forward in my eyes.

[TheGrimReaper]

Davis - you are having a laugh right? And Buchanon is no longer in the best 22. Jack to the midfield, Bevo to defense/pinch hitting, Moore as a small forward and Playfair as a tall forward and Barlow to the midfield and thats about right.

Buchanan not in our best 22? You are having a laugh right?

[RogueSwan]

Davis - you are having a laugh right? And Buchanon is no longer in the best 22. Jack to the midfield, Bevo to defense/pinch hitting, Moore as a small forward and Playfair as a tall forward and Barlow to the midfield and thats about right.

Gotta agree with Connolly here except about Monty, sure he is a bit ordinary at the moment but when he is playing well he is definitely top 20.
This is a slightly hypothetical thread isn't it?

[hammo]

Fosdike?

[NMWBloods]

BACKS
Jack Barry Richards
Kennelly Bolton Malceski

CENTRES
Mattner Schmidt McVeigh

FORWARDS
O'Keefe Barlow Davis
O'Loughlin Hall Moore

RUCKS
Jolly Kirk Goodes

Interchange
Everitt Buchanan Fosdike Ablett/Bevan


I'd prefer Jack up in the middle, but the only BP would be Bevan.

[connolly]

Buchanan not in our best 22? You are having a laugh right?

Sadly no. He has lost a yard, terrible disposal and will make way for either Fosdike or Schmidt when they are fit. Big Barry's mobility and run has covered for the poor midfield disposal by hard running into space for years. With a slower less mobile forward line we have to be able to hit chests. No wonder poor Davo lost confidence.

[JUDO]

2007 gf team
Sorry LRT

BACKS
Richards Barry Brennan
HALF BACKS
Kennelly Bolton Mattner
CENTRES
Malceski Jack Mcveigh
HALF FORWARDS
O'Keefe Playfair Ablett
FORWARDS
Davis Hall O'Loughlin
RUCKS
Everitt Kirk Goodes
INT
J Bolton Buchanan Fosdike Jolly

[Plugger46]

These are the changes I'd like to see between now and the end of the year.

In: Hall, Davis, Malceski, Fosdike, Schmidt

Out: Playfair, J.Bolton, LRT, Mathews, Bird/Bevan

[Chilcott]

These are the changes I'd like to see between now and the end of the year.

In: Hall, Davis, Malceski, Fosdike, Schmidt

Out: Playfair, J.Bolton, LRT, Mathews, Bird/Bevan

Plugger 46 is on the money.

But I would have Bird in and maybe Playfair (but at whose expense????)

[JUDO]

I could'nt get Bird Barlow or Bevan in.
Although i do reall like Barlow.
Bevans got a meldal already and I think Birds to slow