Is Fred Campbell the best Campbell ever to play with the Swans

[ROK Lobster]

When he plays for Sydney and then moves to St Kilda???

Thanks Mr Pedantic.

I was going to say soemthing about changing the list to players and cosches etc etc but didn't think the regular RWOer would be that concerned with triffling details. Seems I was wrong...

[Chilcott]

Robert Neill is another who thrived after going to St Kilda.

I don't think he ever recovered after a famous training session held by Gary Buckenara after a bad loss. It involved going up & down hills in the pouring rain on hands and knees.

[ScottH]

How many Campbells have played, or at least been listed with the swans?

According to RWO's list.

7

[Donners]

He was actually a promising little midfielder. I was disappointed when he left, but obviously he had issues outside football.

[ROK Lobster]

How many Campbells have played, or at least been listed with the swans?

According to RWO's list.

7

Has any other name so dominated the 0's - at any club?

[Reggi]

I came across Troy Grey in working life

He complained to one of our sales guys on why he hadn't received something.

The response was it was retribution for him giving the free kick in the dying minute to Gary Ablett that cost us the game rnd 1 1995

He couldn't believe anyone remembered, yes we remembered Troy

Add Troy Grey and Robbie Neill to the list of being sent to the graveyard

[ScottH]

I came across Troy Grey in working life

He complained to one of our sales guys on why he hadn't received something.

The response was it was retribution for him giving the free kick in the dying minute to Gary Ablett that cost us the game rnd 1 2005

He couldn't believe anyone remembered, yes we remembered Troy

Add Troy Grey and Robbie Neill to the list of being sent to the graveyard

I think you might mean 1995, Reggi.

[Reggi]

I think you might mean 1995, Reggi.

Correct 1995, hard to imagine it was that long ago Rnd 1 1995

[ROK Lobster]

Correct 1995, hard to imagine it was that long ago Rnd 1 1995

I thought I was going mad. Not only could I not remember Troy Grey, I was rwally struggling with recalling a narrow loss to Geelong, round 1, 2005.

[Nico]

Could have been anything but never got the opportunities others did? Who's fault was that - I guess we'll never know. Best Campbell ever for mine.

Clearly season 2008 has been a riveting experience for you so far ROK.

[Nico]

Interesting

Moving to The Aints has been a graveyard for Sydney Players Foschini, P Morwood, F Campbell, Schneider?

Moving the other way seems the way of superstardom and legend status, Cazaly, Lockett (C O'brien) and B Hall

I have left out Jayson Daniels as they poached him from the sydney zone technically he was Sydney, then St Kilda, then Sydney then St Kilda again

How bad were St Kilda. They took him back!

[Nico]

Thanks Mr Pedantic.

I was going to say soemthing about changing the list to players and cosches etc etc but didn't think the regular RWOer would be that concerned with triffling details. Seems I was wrong...

Your spelling is atrocious today and at 11am I see. That flask in the bottom draw seems to be taking a hiding on a Monday morning.

[Reggi]

I thought I was going mad. Not only could I not remember Troy Grey, I was rwally struggling with recalling a narrow loss to Geelong, round 1, 2005.

Reading this thread. You seem to be having that kind of day

[ROK Lobster]

Reading this thread. You seem to be having that kind of day

Oh no, I was a big fan of Fred.

[Triple B]

The response was it was retribution for him giving the free kick in the dying minute to Gary Ablett that cost us the game rnd 1 1995

He couldn't believe anyone remembered, yes we remembered Troy

Gray also gave the hospital pass to Scott Direen against the Tiggers at Waverley in '96.

Direen made it back later in the year, but was NEVER the same steady player he was for us before getting KO'd.