Rate a Season # 7 Luke Brennan

[Nico]

Gave him a 6 based on the games he player ie. his season in the 1's.

We can argue all day about his ability to kick etc but on the few games he played he did some good things, and his kicking was nowhere near in the bargain basement class of Ablett. The only way any player can prove himself is to get game time and he just wasn't given a heap on the days he played.

Again another player I would have had in ahead of Ablett.

[573v30]

2/10

A bit generous IMO, played 4 games (2 were good, 2 were ordinary) but has improved somewhat compared to his 5 games last year in possessions (11.0 vs. 9.8), marks (4.5 vs. 3.8) and tackles (2.8 vs. 0.4) but his decision making as a defender is questionable.

If he could repeat his better performances in the 2's then he might be a good option up forward, but he might be delisted before then as he's a fringe player at best.

[Rod_]

Gets a hard time since Ben Matthews isn't playing. Needed to improve and didn't really grab hold of the game by the scruff of the neck.

Doubt that he will go as I feel that there is something - Just hasn't shown it all yet.....

5 and I don't know why... (4 plus maybe on reflection)

maybe because if Leo leaves he will take on a backman role...? Keep

Has a small potential tick next to his name

IMO

Rod_

[Wazza]

Very hard to rate with the limited number of games - 3

Would really like to see him given another year and pick up a perm spot in defense. The "P" word again but he has the potential to be a hard running rebounder from a HB flank.

Cheers

waz

[ScottH]

I'm on the fence with Luke for all the reason already spouted.

[reigning premier]

5... but had limited oppurtunities.

I still think there's something in him. We just haven't got to it yet. His disposal is probably no worse than LRT but we persist with him!

We've kept worst list cloggers than him for longer. I'd be giving him at least one more season.

[Blood]

Tossing up between a 4 or a 5.

Ordinary footballer with very limited ability and a big heart.

Settling for 4.