Round 1, 2009 - Automatic selections.....

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • liz
    Veteran
    Site Admin
    • Jan 2003
    • 16773

    #16
    Originally posted by reigning premier
    Put up or shut up Liz...

    Put YOUR list in instead of shooting holes in mine.


    If you read my post, I effectively have given you my list.

    Comment

    • reigning premier
      Suspended by the MRP
      • Sep 2006
      • 4335

      #17
      Originally posted by liz


      If you read my post, I effectively have given you my list.
      No. That would of been too easy. To provide a list that is......

      Comment

      • satchmopugdog
        Bandicoots ears
        • Apr 2004
        • 3691

        #18
        This thread was tooooooo early. At the rate we are going at the monent with retirements and injuries it looks likeOrreal and Pyke are certain starters. I could play a handy forward pocket.
        "The Dog days are over, The Dog days are gone" Florence and the Machine

        Comment

        • swantastic
          Veterans List
          • Jan 2006
          • 7275

          #19
          Originally posted by AnnieH
          No Goodesy in the ruck.

          Too important a player to have him stuck in one position.
          bloody oath Annie your always spot o n.
          Now this is a thread that i would expect on the ego -centric, wank session that is redandwhiteonline.com...

          Comment

          • Dalai Lama
            Suspended by the MRP
            • Nov 2008
            • 632

            #20
            Whip It for full back then?

            If not the ruck what about some run out from full back, given this thread has banished leapin' to one day wonder obscurity?

            Comment

            • Hartijon
              On the Rookie List
              • May 2008
              • 1536

              #21
              automatic

              I would like to see the Grand Final hangover finally put to rest and the team rejuvenated. The best way to achieve this is to have NO AUTOMATIC selections. Pick the whole team on merit again like in the pre-GF days when Kirkey stayed on only because he was good and Buchanan had to work his arse off to keep his spot.He is a champion when he does that! A team picked on form is also a happy team amongst the players because they are not carrying anyone. Player morale suffers when some players can not be dropped and those striving to make the team get dissallusioned.No passengers ,no automatic selections =success!

              Comment

              • Nthblood
                On the Rookie List
                • Jan 2009
                • 59

                #22
                Originally posted by Hartijon
                I would like to see the Grand Final hangover finally put to rest and the team rejuvenated. The best way to achieve this is to have NO AUTOMATIC selections. Pick the whole team on merit again like in the pre-GF days when Kirkey stayed on only because he was good and Buchanan had to work his arse off to keep his spot.He is a champion when he does that! A team picked on form is also a happy team amongst the players because they are not carrying anyone. Player morale suffers when some players can not be dropped and those striving to make the team get dissallusioned.No passengers ,no automatic selections =success!
                Well said its the way all team selection should be made, no one has a walk up spot at all. Everyone is equal and everyone has to work and earn there selection at all times.

                Comment

                • Dalai Lama
                  Suspended by the MRP
                  • Nov 2008
                  • 632

                  #23
                  Ebeneezer Goodes then?

                  A great philosopher once wrote
                  "Naughty naughty very naughty"

                  There's a guy in the place
                  He's got a bittersweet face
                  And he goes by the name of Ebeneezer Goodes
                  His friends call him Eezer and he is the main geezer
                  And he'll vibe about the place
                  Like no other man could
                  He's refined, sublime, he makes you feel fine
                  Though very much maligned and misunderstood
                  But if you know Eezer he's a real crowd pleaser
                  He's ever so good, he's Ebeneezer Goodes
                  You can see that he's mysterious,
                  Mischievious and devious
                  As he circulates amongst the people in the place
                  But once you know he's fun
                  And something of a genius
                  He gives a grin that grows around
                  From face to face to face
                  Backwards and then forwards,
                  Forwards and then backwards
                  Eezer is the geezer who loves to muscle in

                  Comment

                  • Donners
                    On the Rookie List
                    • Jan 2003
                    • 1061

                    #24
                    Truly automatic selections (assuming fitness) for me would be...

                    Hall
                    O'Keefe
                    Kirk
                    McVeigh
                    C Bolton
                    J Bolton
                    Mattner
                    Richards
                    Jolly
                    Goodes

                    Anyone else would have to prove themselves over their competitors for their spot, IMHO. There's plenty of obvious ones who will get a spot, but I don't think that they will get it "automatically".

                    Comment

                    • Number 43
                      Warming the Bench
                      • Dec 2008
                      • 168

                      #25
                      Team for Round 1

                      Crouch Barry Richards
                      Mattner C. Bolton Shaw
                      Malceski Goodes McVeigh
                      O'Keefe Hall Bevan
                      Vezpremi Grundy Playfair

                      Jolly
                      Kirk
                      J.Bolton

                      Currie, Jack, Moore, Bird

                      Comment

                      • connolly
                        Registered User
                        • Aug 2005
                        • 2461

                        #26
                        Originally posted by Donners
                        Truly automatic selections (assuming fitness) for me would be...

                        Hall
                        O'Keefe
                        Kirk
                        McVeigh
                        C Bolton
                        J Bolton
                        Mattner
                        Richards
                        Jolly
                        Goodes

                        Anyone else would have to prove themselves over their competitors for their spot, IMHO. There's plenty of obvious ones who will get a spot, but I don't think that they will get it "automatically".
                        Magic is an auto. And the Bevanator is so automatic it goes without saying. Or should. Which would save me the trouble (once again). He was ranked our third best defender last year (only the back stabber and bolton in front of him). The stabber has jigged off so surely the kid wouldn't trouble the selection committee with a discussion. In the first eight picked.
                        Last edited by connolly; 5 February 2009, 02:48 PM.
                        Bevo bandwagon driver

                        Comment

                        Working...