The Brendan Fevola poll - yes or no?

[Donners]

Ah, bless you Vossy.

[tara]

Amazing stuff Vossey! Legend is true! While other clubs navel gaze and talk rubbish about no dickheads he grabs the Coleman Medal winner.Watch Brisbane soar up the ladder! Maybe he realises that it doesn't matter how you get success as long as you get it.

Perfect fit for Vossy who has been known to get into more than a little strife whilst on the piss himself.

[hammo]

And Fev can still see what life would have been like at the Swans by having Amon deliver to him...

[Hartijon]

And Fev can still see what life would have been like at the Swans by having Amon deliver to him...

Hilarious and unfortunately true!

[Robbo]

Carlton really must want to get rid of Fev. Otherwise they have been royally screwed.

I thought Bradshaw would finish up after this season because one of his knees is almost shot and Rischitelli will struggle to get a game in Carlton's midfield. Looks like they will need Brad Fisher to kick their goals next year pfffft

[DST]

Carlton really must want to get rid of Fev. Otherwise they have been royally screwed.

I thought Bradshaw would finish up after this season because one of his knees is almost shot and Rischitelli will struggle to get a game in Carlton's midfield. Looks like they will need Brad Fisher to kick their goals next year pfffft

Agree, when you look at the names it looks like a decent deal for both.

But look at it based on Carlton's structure and the very real issue of Bradshaw breaking down, then this is a very very bad deal for Carlton.

If Voss had not decided to throw this deal up, my prediction of Fev to us for nothing more than pick 28 at 1.45pm on Friday might of actually come true as it looks very much like they are fair dinkum to see this trade through.

DST

[Jeffers1984]

Fev was perfect for Brisbane though. They are an improving side who made the finals and did well once they got there. They can really start pushing for a flag now, whereas we still would of been a long way off even if we did get Fev.

agree.

[Robbo]

Jesus christ I'm listening to SEN and the two blokes who are on atm are saying Brisbane have been screwed in this deal.....whatever they are on I want some.

[Plugger46]

Jesus christ I'm listening to SEN and the two blokes who are on atm are saying Brisbane have been screwed in this deal.....whatever they are on I want some.

Agreed. I reckon it's a terrible deal for Carlton.

[liz]

Agreed. I reckon it's a terrible deal for Carlton.

I'm with you too. Brisbane would be effectively trading one very very good FF with about 1 year left in him, for an even better one with as many as 4 years left in him, possibly more. Plus they are giving away a solid but hardly spectacular midfielder. If you put aside the emotional aspect of trading away a long-standing clubman like Bradshaw, from a purely footballing point of view it seems like an absolute winner for Brisbane.

If our list was currently where Brisbane's is, especially with Black, Power and Brown towards the end of their most productive parts of their career, I'd be all for the Swans going for it, assuming the behavioural aspects of Fevola could be managed.

Many Carlton fans were indicating they'd feel slightly ripped off if they got (a wishful) ROK and pick 14 from us for Fevola. I can't see how the puported Brisbane offer is even in the same ballpark.

[DST]

Many Carlton fans were indicating they'd feel slightly ripped off if they got (a wishful) ROK and pick 14 from us for Fevola. I can't see how the puported Brisbane offer is even in the same ballpark.

Ha ha ha.............................

The Carlton supporters would be spewing, I tried to tell them last night over at Bigfooty that if Sydney was the only option then our pick 28 or even 38 would be sufficent to land the deal, only to see suggestions like pick 6 and Vespremi be thrown back at me.

They just got a very large dose of humble pie today on how the trade system works when you have damaged goods and when good old Uncle Sydney was not there to bail them out with a stupid deal like we did in the early 90's.

DST

[wearebloods]

The X-Files

Apparently the Brisbane deal may be off & Roos said that the Swans still aren't interested Fev deal in limbo

However I was thinking, on the basis that Carlton won't have him back under any circumstances & sack him [if this list of potential wrong doings is anything to go by, then it's quite understandable-> Fev rumours ] but he still wants to play next year, what's to stop Sydney picking him up in the PSD on a new contract & no trade hoohah?

[573v30]

If we get him for a bargain then yes...

[Cardinal]

I would not be surprised to find out that Carlton has salary cap problems with all the goings ons.

[caj23]

After this weeks trading efforts I'd give them 14 and Barlow (and Moore if they wanted) in a heartbeat.

I'd even consider pick 6 straight up even given that Martin and Cunnington are likely to be gone by then