If Judd wasnt in the Carlton team friday night would they have won ?

[Big Al]

I think the more pertinent question is "would Judd have had the impact he did had Jack not left the ground"? Had that impact not happened, Carlton wouldn't have won whether or not the interchange thing happened.

Quick grammar lesson too people (to some not all). It's "could HAVE" not "could OF". Just because people pronounce it as "of" doesn't mean you spell it that way. Please note, I mean this with respect and not to pick on anyone in particular, but it has been annoying me for a hell of a long time - on this site and everywhere else to be honest.

Would of thought their was other things too worry about.

[dimelb]

Would of thought their was other things too worry about.

True, but they don't matter as much as speling and grammer.

[Bas]

True, but they don't matter as much as speling and grammer.

You spelt matta wrong.

[Auntie.Gerald]

whatz wong with that !

[longmile]

yes, yes we would have. If it wasn't for Jack's injury as well, he was doing a great job keeping Judd quite before he was injured

[Doctor]

Would of thought their was other things too worry about.

Heh heh. Yeah maybe, but you obviously don't know me well enough. ;-)

[giant]

No chance. BUt sadly he did.

[Auntie.Gerald]

Kingy on afl360 tonight said Judd was the difference by a country mile..........11 disposals final qtr in a team that had 44

[liz]

Kingy on afl360 tonight said Judd was the difference by a country mile..........11 disposals final qtr in a team that had 44

It was 11 contested possessions out of 44 - not disposals. Unlikely that Carlton would have won the game had they only had 44 disposals in that quarter.

[Auntie.Gerald]

thats why i shouldnt post at 1120pm at night

my bad !

[Triple B]

Doesn't really matter Auntie, the premise of your post was correct, King straight out claimed that Carlton would NOT have won that game without Judd, full stop.